Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CTyankee

(65,857 posts)
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 01:23 PM Jan 8

the playing of the Navy Hymn just did me in...

I try to remind myself that President Carter was 100 years old and that he would have been glad to see Rosalyn again in heaven. But the tears still come for a generous, kind man and he left us at a point when we face the swearing in of a grotesque, vile human being as POTUS. The contrast could not be greater.

28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
the playing of the Navy Hymn just did me in... (Original Post) CTyankee Jan 8 OP
"Strong to Save"? sakabatou Jan 8 #1
Yes. Hubby was so moved he played several versions this morning... CTyankee Jan 8 #3
Georgia on My Mind' plays at end of Capitol service Emile Jan 8 #2
Yep. CTyankee Jan 8 #5
I cried on the plane yesterday as I watched a CNN sinkingfeeling Jan 8 #4
I love that he taught Sunday School at a church near his home after he left the Presidency. CTyankee Jan 8 #6
As the most decent and honorable American leaves us, wnylib Jan 8 #24
The greatest moral chasm between two presidents, ever Martin Eden Jan 8 #7
True and said so well Deuxcents Jan 8 #8
"The contrast could not be greater." dchill Jan 8 #9
It was FDRs favorite hymn Danmel Jan 8 #10
The church that I grew up in used to sing it from time to time, wnylib Jan 8 #27
Yes it still jerks my tears BOSSHOG Jan 8 #11
"human being"?? lastlib Jan 8 #12
Well said. surfered Jan 8 #13
In the service at the Carter Center, that hymn was sung by the Morehouse japple Jan 8 #14
Same here. madamesilverspurs Jan 8 #15
President Carter gets to see American democracy implode from a 50 yard line skybox. aeromanKC Jan 8 #16
I seem to recall it played for JFK, Navy Veteran, usonian Jan 8 #17
As I recall, Codifer Jan 8 #20
Ford was Navy sarge1943 Jan 8 #22
thank you Codifer Jan 8 #28
My first time voting at age 18 orangecrush Jan 8 #18
My mother teared up, any time she heard the Navy Hymn. Paladin Jan 8 #19
Got me, too. elleng Jan 8 #21
I was a junior in high school............. MyOwnPeace Jan 8 #23
Naval Academy Glee Club at the Capitol Rotunda DinahMoeHum Jan 8 #25
A British hymn written written in 1860 and.. surfered Jan 8 #26

CTyankee

(65,857 posts)
3. Yes. Hubby was so moved he played several versions this morning...
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 01:38 PM
Jan 8

he was in the Navy and headed for Guantanemo for duty when, on home for Christmas in Wisconsin, encountered a bad snowstorm, resulting in months of recovery, mostly physical therapy. That cut short his Navy service. His father had served in the occupation of Japan after WW2 so he wanted to serve in the Navy.

sinkingfeeling

(54,602 posts)
4. I cried on the plane yesterday as I watched a CNN
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 01:39 PM
Jan 8

documentary "The First Rock & Roll President". I remember how America was back then. GOPer, John Wayne, spoke at Carter's inauguration ball and the Republicans pushed the Panama Canal turnover. It brought back how far ahead Carter was. It reminded me of the chance we had last November and how low the US has come.
So, I cried for Jimmy Carter and I cried for my lost country.

CTyankee

(65,857 posts)
6. I love that he taught Sunday School at a church near his home after he left the Presidency.
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 01:47 PM
Jan 8

I had an uncle back in Texas when I was growing up who had been a state senator and was a local judge. He took me to Sunday School (Presbyterian) when I visited every summer. It was all the religion I got because my parents were put off by Billy Graham and all the Southern church folk at the time.

wnylib

(25,197 posts)
24. As the most decent and honorable American leaves us,
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 04:10 PM
Jan 8

the most indecent, despicable American takes over the nation.

That's plenty of reason to cry.

Martin Eden

(14,020 posts)
7. The greatest moral chasm between two presidents, ever
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 01:56 PM
Jan 8

Is the man being laid to rest vs the monster soon to take office.

wnylib

(25,197 posts)
27. The church that I grew up in used to sing it from time to time,
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 04:23 PM
Jan 8

usually around holidays like Memorial Day and Veteran's Day.

Not sure why they chose the Navy Hymn. Maybe because we were in a Great Lakes port city. We sang it often enough that I still remember all the words of the first 2 verses.

My father was a Navy vet from WWII. One of my brothers was a career Navy man. The other brother served one enlistment in the Navy.

lastlib

(25,548 posts)
12. "human being"??
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 02:28 PM
Jan 8

if that creature is actuallly a member of the human race, then we need to do some serious weeding out of the gene pool.....

japple

(10,457 posts)
14. In the service at the Carter Center, that hymn was sung by the Morehouse
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 02:55 PM
Jan 8

College Men's Glee Club. My tears flowed like a waterfall. Then they sang Mine Eyes Have Seen the Glory and the dam let loose. It was so beautiful.

?si=rYKoxGNogzOy2RL7

?si=jGRt3u1sx50rkDvP

madamesilverspurs

(16,190 posts)
15. Same here.
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 02:58 PM
Jan 8

We have Navy in the family all the way back to the Revolution. Both of my brothers served in the Navy; one did three tours in Viet Nam, the other traveled the world and retired two weeks before 9-11 and later blew all our minds when he voted for trump. I suspect there will be many more tears, given Carter's passing and trump's second coming.


.

aeromanKC

(3,589 posts)
16. President Carter gets to see American democracy implode from a 50 yard line skybox.
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 03:04 PM
Jan 8

Much better seats than we have!!

Codifer

(907 posts)
20. As I recall,
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 03:41 PM
Jan 8

the Navy has provided more presidents than other services:

FDR did not serve (polio) but was Secretary of the Navy

Truman was Army artilleryman (WWI)

Eisenhower was of course Army (Supreme Allied Commander)

JFK Navy

Johnson Navy

Nixon Navy

Ford ???

Carter Navy

Reagan fought the terrible battle of Topanga Canyon

poppy Bush Navy

Clinton none

shrub bush Air Force Reserve

Obama No war

The Sick Fuck fought and evaded social diseases with bone spurs

I will go now and look up Ford's service (at some point)

orangecrush

(23,773 posts)
18. My first time voting at age 18
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 03:32 PM
Jan 8

Was for Jimmy Carter.

I got to vote at 18 because of the Vietnam war.

There was a large push for "if I'm old enough to die for the country, I'm old enough to vote.

Edit -They changed the law in 1971.

Paladin

(29,814 posts)
19. My mother teared up, any time she heard the Navy Hymn.
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 03:36 PM
Jan 8

She had several school friends who went to war and never returned. One of them was a sailor who went down with the USS Arizona, at Pearl Harbor in 1941.

May God bless and keep President Carter, an accomplished Naval man and a first-rate chief of state.

MyOwnPeace

(17,291 posts)
23. I was a junior in high school.............
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 04:09 PM
Jan 8

and was at home because President Kennedy had been shot. As they carried his coffin up the steps of the US Capital (the place SO defiled by the in-coming regime!) - the US NAVY band (President Kennedy was in the Navy too) played 'The Navy Hymn.'
I'd never heard it referred to as 'the NAVY hymn' - but was blown away by the beauty of the band playing it.
I watched the video recording - and the tears flowed - just as they did in 1963.
A marvelous tribute to a great man - and GREAT AMERICAN..................

surfered

(5,607 posts)
26. A British hymn written written in 1860 and..
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 04:19 PM
Jan 8

…inspired by Psalm 107 and the bravery of British seafarers.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»the playing of the Navy H...