Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

yellowdogintexas

(23,058 posts)
41. she did not steal the idea of the pack librarians since it was a real thing
Sat Apr 13, 2024, 07:36 PM
Apr 2024

however, the books have some significant similarities in detail which prompted the author of "Bookwoman" to sue her. I picked up right away on them when I read Giver of Stars; mostly they are thinly veiled duplications of events out on the trail. There are a couple of characters that I felt were blatant copies of characters in "Bookwoman" and a couple of incidents which seem derivative of Bookwoman.

I read both books and I liked Bookwoman much better mostly because the author really conveys the feel and character of the Eastern Ky mountains in the 1930s, the attitudes toward women, the side story of Cussy's unique medical situation and the people she meets and deals with. It is better written and is told from the point of view of a woman whose family has lived in those mountains for several generations, a true inside story

Giver of Stars is told from the point of view of an outsider experiencing severe culture shock and saddled with a strange husband and horrid inlaws. This woman is navigating a world which is totally strange and baffling to her and her struggle to come to grips with this strange new place gives the story a different feel.


3

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I read The Kingdom Of The Blind several years ago. Srkdqltr Apr 2024 #1
Cool hermetic Apr 2024 #3
I just reread it. Most memorable character was the snow. Deep freezing blizzard cold. And the hat. cbabe Apr 2024 #12
The Target, a Robie and Reed novel by Baldacci. brer cat Apr 2024 #2
Another one! hermetic Apr 2024 #5
I just finished Pretty Girls by Karen Slaughter. MontanaMama Apr 2024 #4
Thanks, good to know hermetic Apr 2024 #6
Lady Tan's Circle of Women by Lisa See people Apr 2024 #7
That sounds quite awesome hermetic Apr 2024 #8
Just finished two.... mentalsolstice Apr 2024 #9
Never read that one.. hermetic Apr 2024 #10
Tim Washburn: two titles cbabe Apr 2024 #11
Ah Yellowstone hermetic Apr 2024 #15
A David Baldacci, Bayard Apr 2024 #13
Baldacci has a new one hermetic Apr 2024 #16
Good day. Yesterday finished the singe/songwriter Brandi Carlile memoir of her childhood, openly txwhitedove Apr 2024 #14
Yeah, hermetic Apr 2024 #17
yes indeed The Bookwoman is a wonderful book. I recommend it to anyone I know who reads yellowdogintexas Apr 2024 #40
Tried his Arthur and Queenie series while awaiting the next Chet and Bernie EverHopeful Apr 2024 #18
Bookwoman of Troublesome Creek was awesome NanaCat Apr 2024 #21
Oh--and BOOOOOOO to Jojo Moyes for stealing NanaCat Apr 2024 #22
she did not steal the idea of the pack librarians since it was a real thing yellowdogintexas Apr 2024 #41
The Exchange by John Grisham EverHopeful Apr 2024 #19
Ian Rankin is one of my very favourite writers NanaCat Apr 2024 #20
Date with Murder by Julia Chapman The King of Prussia Apr 2024 #23
Oh, I say hermetic Apr 2024 #24
My bad The King of Prussia Apr 2024 #26
Nah, you're good hermetic Apr 2024 #28
Babel by R. F. Kuang Deep State Witch Apr 2024 #25
I just finished The Trees by Percival Everett and was a bit confounded by japple Apr 2024 #27
Interesting hermetic Apr 2024 #29
Mrs. Plansky's Revenge by Spencer Quinn question everything Apr 2024 #30
What the... hermetic Apr 2024 #31
Spam calls!! When you decide to go after them, I'll gladly go with you for that adventure. Grrr txwhitedove Apr 2024 #37
Cool! hermetic Apr 2024 #38
Trump rally speeches are poor in grammar and sentence structure, but the fictional lies just keep on coming. usaf-vet Apr 2024 #32
Yeah, hermetic Apr 2024 #33
Which ones? usaf-vet Apr 2024 #34
Houstan and Hamilton hermetic Apr 2024 #35
Start here: A Cold Day in Paradise. usaf-vet Apr 2024 #36
Bedfordshire Clanger Calamity: Albert Smith's Culinary Capers Recipe 4 yellowdogintexas Apr 2024 #39
Those sound great hermetic Apr 2024 #42
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Fiction»What Fiction are you read...»Reply #41