Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Religion
In reply to the discussion: When did God give man Free Will? [View all]Jim__
(14,464 posts)40. The blog, The Conversation, has an article on that idea.
That article, Food for thought? Diet helps explain unique human brainpower, is from April 2017. Darren Curnoe is a scientist:
He is a palaeoanthropologist and archaeologist fascinated with human evolution and prehistory. Darren believes science isn't complete until it has been communicated to the wider community. Therefore, he has made writing, broadcasting and making films about science, especially human origins, a major part of his professional endeavours.
The idea expressed in that article is that it's the complex behaviors needed to satisfy the human diet that led to a bigger brain being advantageous. It doesn't say anything about the protein content of the diet.
An excerpt:
...
Now a new study by Alex DeCasien and colleagues published in Nature Ecology and Evolution has turned the debate completely on its head. Theyve found that the kind of diet a primate species consumes offers the best explanation for its brain size.
...
The human dietary niche is exceptionally broad and involves behaviours aimed at not only obtaining food but also making it more palatable and digestible; activities like extraction, digging, hunting, fishing, drying, grinding, cooking, combining other foods to add flavor, or even adding minerals to season or make food safe to eat.
...
Whats more, our large fruit eating ape brains got even bigger late in human evolution because our diets became ever more challenging to obtain and prepare, especially as a result of our ancestors penchant for eating meat.
Hunter-gatherers typically have a diet comprising between 30% and 80% vertebrate meat, while for chimpanzees its only around 2%. Instead, chimps get 60% of their diet from fruit, but hunter-gatherers typically obtain only 5% or 6 % (on the odd occasion a lot more) of their nutrition from fruit.
...
Now a new study by Alex DeCasien and colleagues published in Nature Ecology and Evolution has turned the debate completely on its head. Theyve found that the kind of diet a primate species consumes offers the best explanation for its brain size.
...
The human dietary niche is exceptionally broad and involves behaviours aimed at not only obtaining food but also making it more palatable and digestible; activities like extraction, digging, hunting, fishing, drying, grinding, cooking, combining other foods to add flavor, or even adding minerals to season or make food safe to eat.
...
Whats more, our large fruit eating ape brains got even bigger late in human evolution because our diets became ever more challenging to obtain and prepare, especially as a result of our ancestors penchant for eating meat.
Hunter-gatherers typically have a diet comprising between 30% and 80% vertebrate meat, while for chimpanzees its only around 2%. Instead, chimps get 60% of their diet from fruit, but hunter-gatherers typically obtain only 5% or 6 % (on the odd occasion a lot more) of their nutrition from fruit.
...
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
140 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Nonononono. You don't understand: The concept of evidence-based science didn't even exist back then.
DetlefK
Jan 2019
#118
I could have sworn that earlier civilizations figured out the movement of the stars, calculated the
erronis
Jan 2019
#121
I'm going with 1980. Unsurprisingly, it makes more sense than any holy book.
Pope George Ringo II
Jan 2019
#23
Several years ago, on a PBS special, the claim was made that the adaptation of a meat-based diet by
in2herbs
Jan 2019
#28
Animals are instinctive, they do not have the level of reasoning or critical thinking skills that
in2herbs
Jan 2019
#34
What animals made the scientific discovery for vaccines?? for going to the moon? The level of an
in2herbs
Jan 2019
#44
Ponder the self-awareness of a cat looking in a mirror and discovering it has ears.
Pope George Ringo II
Jan 2019
#47
I'd also point out that you're apparently arguing humans didn't "think" until the 20th Century...
Pope George Ringo II
Jan 2019
#49
This description makes it sound like humans have no control over their lives and if we're without
in2herbs
Jan 2019
#35
Nope. It makes Pelosi's decision approved by God... and Trump's decisions which come true.
keithbvadu2
Jan 2019
#62
The point is, you are making the implicit statement that your guiding "spiritual principles"...
trotsky
Jan 2019
#86
Nope, I'm saying that your faith-based method is no better or worse than any other.
trotsky
Jan 2019
#88
I don't think people understand the difference between belief and spiritual practice
marylandblue
Jan 2019
#100
And Guy has repeatedly said elsewhere here that evolution is the only process,
Voltaire2
Jan 2019
#71
Sure I am not claiming it has to evolve elsewhere, just that it certainly can.
Voltaire2
Jan 2019
#73