2016 Postmortem

Txbluedog

(1,128 posts)

20. I disagree

Tue Dec 13, 2016, 03:56 PM

Dec 2016

It would require a constitutional amendment to get rid of the electoral college, that is 2/3rd votes in BOTH House and approval by 37 or so states. The republicans just lost the popular vote by close to 3 million---where's the incentive for them to do this?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

55 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Hillary ONE TERM & DONE: a possible face-saving compromise for GOP electors? [View all] yurbud Dec 2016 OP

I think you may be in the "bargaining" phase of the "7 stages". n/t PoliticAverse Dec 2016 #1

At the same time! Kotya Dec 2016 #3

what's GMTA? yurbud Dec 2016 #5

"Great Minds Think Alike". n/t PoliticAverse Dec 2016 #7

maybe. yurbud Dec 2016 #4

I can't tell if you are in the... Kotya Dec 2016 #2

Nope-Hillary is done, done! Txbluedog Dec 2016 #6

it would have a secondary benefit of making the GOP hate the electoral college even more than Dems yurbud Dec 2016 #9

The primary benefit is too scary Txbluedog Dec 2016 #10

I think whatever happens, the electoral college's days are numbered. Anything to expedite that yurbud Dec 2016 #16

I disagree Txbluedog Dec 2016 #20

Yep! EL34x4 Dec 2016 #21

the national popular vote interstate compact circumvents that two-thirds business yurbud Dec 2016 #22

Think you'll get any red states to agree? EL34x4 Dec 2016 #33

The will of the voters in this case was to cast about 3 million more votes for Hillary, though. trotsky Dec 2016 #15

You mean override Russia and traitors. The will of the people is that they elect Hillary Clinton.nt JTFrog Dec 2016 #19

Donald J Trump won the electoral college Txbluedog Dec 2016 #34

That's why the founders established a direct election... sfwriter Dec 2016 #26

This seems to be a reasonable compromise... Joe941 Dec 2016 #8

Where are people getting the notion that... Kotya Dec 2016 #11

If the situation were reversed kudzu22 Dec 2016 #38

The creative fuckery with our Democracy is getting to be amusing. B2G Dec 2016 #12

With the EC meeting in days, I had the same thought. rogue emissary Dec 2016 #13

The EC doesn't meet as a group onenote Dec 2016 #24

If it goes to the House, they'll almost certainly pick Trump onenote Dec 2016 #30

He doesn't have any EC votes tell they vote monday. rogue emissary Dec 2016 #36

It won't even remotely go that far. duffyduff Dec 2016 #43

A tie or fewer votes than Clinton are not the only two options onenote Dec 2016 #44

So far nothing about this election has been reasonable. rogue emissary Dec 2016 #49

Why does the GOP need to save face? EL34x4 Dec 2016 #39

Free republic is a extreme. rogue emissary Dec 2016 #47

I think the only slight hope is for a GOP-backed coup at the electoral college vote on the 19th mtnsnake Dec 2016 #14

that would be a slightly more acceptable outcome even so. yurbud Dec 2016 #23

The Republicans don't have to compromise on anything. Ace Rothstein Dec 2016 #17

This is called bargaining BainsBane Dec 2016 #18

I'm not sure anything "stranger" than what you suggest has ever happened in US presidential election onenote Dec 2016 #25

I don't consider that a compromise. David__77 Dec 2016 #27

that dramatically increases my respect for Willie Brown. yurbud Dec 2016 #40

I think he did a good job with all that. David__77 Dec 2016 #51

Who would play the role of Willie Brown in this scenario onenote Dec 2016 #45

I don't think Clinton would be a good choice to visibly handle any of that. David__77 Dec 2016 #48

How about one term of Pence and done? sfwriter Dec 2016 #28

I could see that happening if Dems had any ability to bargain, which they don't. yurbud Dec 2016 #29

What do they have to bargain with? onenote Dec 2016 #46

good point. yurbud Dec 2016 #50

Pence is as tainted as Trump. n/t duffyduff Dec 2016 #42

"we could get four years to get the Democrats house in order and present a fresh candidate in 2020" Adsos Letter Dec 2016 #31

The Democrats are going to get absolutely nothing from the GOP CentralMass Dec 2016 #32

I understand how you feel after being depressed for months after 2004 election. But let it go. Hoyt Dec 2016 #35

Spaghetti is right. :))) pangaia Dec 2016 #37

Not going to happen. duffyduff Dec 2016 #41

Your spaghetti's not sticking. Better Al Dente YOHABLO Dec 2016 #52

Nope Freethinker65 Dec 2016 #53

convince electors that she'll be impeached Jean-Jacques Roussea Dec 2016 #54

This is never going to happen. Trump will be the next president. That said, I don't think HRC was StevieM Dec 2016 #55