Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: A word of advice about controlling the Democratic Party message [View all]JCanete
(5,272 posts)48. Except that I didn't say populist rhetoric was good just cuz it feels good to hear it.
I said if you want to get something done in this environment you have to rally the people behind it with all your might. I gave you a prescription. The same one Sanders gave too. You can't reason with somebody who is voting based upon the interests of the people who got them their seat. You can only get the public to want, and then to demand, something from their government officials. You can use the bully pulpit for that. That is at least something that directly puts pressure on these seats.
You haven't convinced me that shit can be done the other way, and you didn't even try.
If you really think things get done, not from unilateral work, but from within congress, entirely internally, what exactly is it that is getting done? How does it get done? Sure budget battles get prosecuted and compromises have to be made by both sides, and typically are, but legislation? You are pretending that something about moderate policy makes it palatable to the Republicans. It doesn't. You're pretending that in this gerrymandered nation that the Republicans are afraid of being obstructionists and can be reasoned with. They can't be. and you can't rise up a people on vague substance. You have to give them a rallying cry.
And still the bigger picture remains...we are never the party with our hands on the levers of power because corporate interests own our media and we don't take them on, so we're not likely to ever have a majority let alone a filibuster proof one.
But aside from the media, in the context of this conversation who is trying to control somebody else's vote? I'm certainly not. I'm having a conversation, because I learn through these, even if it doesn't seem like it from your side of the discussion.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
55 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
"Clearly you don't sit down with those you disagree with." Are you referencing the poster?
Eleanors38
Dec 2016
#9
Unfortunately some want to control the Democratic Party message from the outside.
George II
Dec 2016
#7
That is not an accurate gauge of whether a message can resonate with people. Just running and tyring
JCanete
Dec 2016
#10
Winning with our current party is fan-fiction that our leaders keep regurgitating and fawning over.
JCanete
Dec 2016
#23
How can you disagree with my analysis and then say if your campaign resonates, donors will
JCanete
Dec 2016
#21
So, the premise I was responding to was basically "if your ideas are so hot prove it
JCanete
Dec 2016
#40
sad and wrong... your words are the things I was saying were reinforcing my argument. Not that I
JCanete
Dec 2016
#46
now you're basically saying that in the "real world" donors don't give a shit about policy, just
JCanete
Dec 2016
#55
Where I agree with you is that refighting the primary is pointless, and that energy spent
JCanete
Dec 2016
#27
That recurring theme about rhetoric versus policy--excuse me for being cute--is rhetoric.
JCanete
Dec 2016
#41
but that is nothing compared to the megaphone that went out over the corporate media from
JCanete
Dec 2016
#47
okay, I see, you're not responding to what I'm posting, just to a preconceived notion you already
JCanete
Dec 2016
#54
Except that I didn't say populist rhetoric was good just cuz it feels good to hear it.
JCanete
Dec 2016
#48
Well that's not exactly fair. He's a Presidential Candidate. He could have said "this is the only
JCanete
Dec 2016
#50
Another way is for everyone to call their Democratic congressmen, lots of them, and OFTEN
mtnsnake
Dec 2016
#20
Do you honestly think that tons of people here are going to follow your advice
mtnsnake
Dec 2016
#30
I would encourage those that aren't the type to run to still get involved and proactively seek good
think
Dec 2016
#25
A grad student I talked with today told me my generation was at fault.
redstatebluegirl
Dec 2016
#29