Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nevilledog

(53,350 posts)
Tue Nov 5, 2024, 03:42 PM Nov 5

Jon Meacham: I'm a Presidential Historian. This Is My Biggest Regret About Trump.

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/05/opinion/donald-trump-regret.html

No paywall link
https://archive.li/Na9FA

I thought I knew what we were dealing with. When Donald Trump began his rise to power in 2015, he struck me as a dangerous but recognizable demagogue. As a biographer of presidents, I tend to think historically and seek analogies from the past to shed light on the present. And so, for years Mr. Trump’s marshaling of fear, prejudice, resentment, xenophobia and extremism put me in mind of grievance-driven figures ranging from Huey Long to Joseph McCarthy to George Wallace. To me, Mr. Trump was a difference not of kind (we had long contended with illiberalism in America) but of degree (since the Civil War, no figure with such illiberal views had ever actually won the White House).

Then he proved me wrong. His concerted efforts to overthrow the November 2020 election very nearly succeeded — tangible proof that he is in fact willing to follow through on the authoritarian threats he so freely makes. I now see him as a genuine aberration in our history — a man whose contempt for constitutional democracy makes him a unique threat to the nation.

I say this not as a Democrat, which I am not. I first encountered the drama of American politics through a childhood interest in Ronald Reagan, whose public grace struck a chord within me. (At 10, I was not very astute about the implications of supply-side economics.) I became the biographer of George H.W. Bush. I have voted for both Republican and Democratic nominees for president and down the ballot. And I have spent much of my adult life studying and writing about the office that John Kennedy called “the vital center of action.”

Analogies thus come naturally to me. Yet more and more, I fear that trying to find historical precedents for Mr. Trump presents dangers of its own. No similar figure in American history has ever had such a strong grip on so many. To suggest otherwise diminishes the sense of urgency the moment requires.

*snip*
9 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Jon Meacham: I'm a Presidential Historian. This Is My Biggest Regret About Trump. (Original Post) Nevilledog Nov 5 OP
That he was president lame54 Nov 5 #1
In the end, it is up to democracy to save democracy. kentuck Nov 5 #2
it's not really democracy when the "loser" can receive millions more votes Skittles Nov 5 #3
Ronald Reagan's public Grace? give me a break NoRethugFriends Nov 5 #4
To be fair, graceful to a then 10-year old. tinrobot Nov 5 #7
Viewing him as an aberration is a mistake Trish6521 Nov 5 #5
A person who admired Reagan would view Trump as an aberration. yardwork Nov 5 #6
At least he's not young. If he were 60 we would be staring a repeat of Mussolini... /nt artemisia1 Nov 5 #8
Well Solly Mack Nov 5 #9

tinrobot

(11,474 posts)
7. To be fair, graceful to a then 10-year old.
Tue Nov 5, 2024, 08:39 PM
Nov 5

Unfortunately, a lot of adults act like 10 year olds when it comes to politics.

Trish6521

(7 posts)
5. Viewing him as an aberration is a mistake
Tue Nov 5, 2024, 08:34 PM
Nov 5

He was a symptom of bigger systemic problems (oligarchy, wealth inequality, corporate media caring more about profits than informing us, an out of touch punditry, pollsters who can be bought and influenced, social media algorithms that shape/distort our views, buyable corrupt politicians and the act of running for office as a marketing exercise).

The right wing echo chamber certainly has a lion’s share of blame here, but there’s so much more. We know Epstein and Diddy were blackmailing people to influence media, politics and Lord knows what else. How much influence is wielded this way? How many were willing to use Trump as a means to an end? (Not just politicians, but religious leaders, CEOs, other billionaires, other world leaders and dictators).

To view Trump as an aberration is to not fix all these issues so that another version of him can come along.

yardwork

(64,765 posts)
6. A person who admired Reagan would view Trump as an aberration.
Tue Nov 5, 2024, 08:39 PM
Nov 5

The rest of us view him as a logical extension of Reaganism.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Jon Meacham: I'm a Presid...