General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsBibi and his monsters are bombing the shit out of Beirut today
The West is complicit
That is all
marble falls
(62,523 posts)Jk23
(455 posts)Redleg
(6,248 posts)A little reference to Life of Brian there.
Jk23
(455 posts)Always look on the bright side of life.
Jit423
(431 posts)They need jobs that are provided by the war machine and we need markets for our weapons. If there were no attacks by Hamas or Hezbollah Israel would provoke one as they have done in the past. The olive groves and orange groves and date groves once belonged to Palestinian farmers whose land and water wells have been taken over by the occupiers. This accounts for the Swiss cheese map of Israel today when the Palestinian remaining territories are mapped.
DJ Synikus Makisimus
(800 posts)Cut diamonds are their biggest export to the U.S. A high percentage of those seem to originate in Russia or in Russian-controlled Africa.
Jit423
(431 posts)No matter, Israel is a renegade nation and sooner or later they will have hell to pay and their innocent civilians will suffer the most.
JI7
(90,894 posts)from these locations.
Amishman
(5,832 posts)Many thousands this year, and it was happening regularly before Israel started hitting Hezbollah.
lindysalsagal
(22,446 posts)Killing for god. Totally insane.
Maru Kitteh
(29,233 posts)stop sending arms today and war would not stop. Where there is demand, somone will endeavor to meet it.
lindysalsagal
(22,446 posts)GrayJedi
(2 posts)Having the West stop sending weapons is a easy answer that would likely not solve the problem. If the West stopped sending weapons then we would loose a ally that we still have some influence over. Israel will simply turn to China, Russia or North Korea who would be glad to give them all the weapons and troops they need. The West would have no influence on them and loose a possible ally in the Middle East. It would be a even worst blood bath than we could imagine.
lindysalsagal
(22,446 posts)own demise.
EX500rider
(11,551 posts)lindysalsagal
(22,446 posts)They're fighting over us, so we have to exit to stop the fighting.
EX500rider
(11,551 posts)nycbos
(6,397 posts)But Iran does. This rouge nations funding terrorists organizations.
Kid Berwyn
(18,351 posts)Todays another day and another war.
Beastly Boy
(11,330 posts)Kid Berwyn
(18,351 posts)Instead, he's leading Israel on a path toward permanent war.
Beastly Boy
(11,330 posts)What obligates him to do so in the face of continued hostilities against Israel?
And what is your definition of the high road anyway?
Kid Berwyn
(18,351 posts)That would be a big part of my definition.
Beastly Boy
(11,330 posts)What makes Israel's action like the nazis?
Surely it is not their right and responsibility to fight back, is it?
As an example, did the nazis ever respond to German civilians being held hostage by the Jews?
Mountainguy
(1,021 posts)is vile.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)InAbLuEsTaTe
(24,670 posts)MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)attacking Israel and then Israel would stop attacking those terrorists who hide behind civilians?
Igel
(36,230 posts)But the group that needed to approve it hadn't approved it and the Lebanese side was still saying it was possible but details.
That was reporting as of this morning--and it was the same as the reporting yesterday afternoon.
Sundance1220
(177 posts)The days of the Israeli's doing things unilaterally are over.
Kid Berwyn
(18,351 posts)Continue making war and soon the war will make you do things you don't want to do, like seeing your own nation destroyed.
I make this point because Bibi is leading Israel toward disaster. Friends don't let friends mislead their countries, unilaterally or not.
Sundance1220
(177 posts)that hezbollah and Palestinian islamic jihad have been lobbing rockets and missiles - THOUSANDS OF THEM - into Northern Israel for years already? That Iran attacked Israel. I would be furious if the US President told them to sit back and take it after Oct 7. Enough is enough. Demand the terrorists lay down their arms, release all hostages and try leading their people rather than hiding behind them.
Kid Berwyn
(18,351 posts)For example, I remember when Israel attacked the USS Liberty, without mercy.
'But Sir, It's an American Ship.' 'Never Mind, Hit Her!'
https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/but-sir-its-an-american-ship-never-mind-hit-her-1.5492908
Officially, a mistake.
Unofficially, someone wanted the USA to think someone sank* their spy ship.
*Someone mustve been surprised the Liberty didnt sink.
Israel was never held to account for the above. So, today, Bibi does what Bibi wants, not what Biden asks.
Sundance1220
(177 posts)I was under the impression only white supremacists and bigots still try and argue against Israel using using it. I guess not. And that makes it perfectly okay for a dozen different terrorist organizations to continue to try and kill Israelis, kidnap Israelis, rape Israeli's, mutilate and kidnap Israeli's because of an accident over 50 YEARS AGO. We're done here.
soandso
(1,631 posts)It was an attempt at a false flag, to blame Egypt.
quaint
(3,651 posts)Thank you.
Redleg
(6,248 posts)If those people don't want to get bombed, they should move somewhere else. Ok- just pulling your chain. I am disturbed by all sides in the conflict seem to not care about non-combatant casualties. While I expect this kind of shit from extremists and terrorists, I don't expect it from nation states.
malaise
(278,801 posts)Rec
haele
(13,648 posts)This was in 2006.
Beruit is an old multicultural city.
Might as well bomb Doha, Nairobi, Jakarta, Paris - or Jerusalem.
There's Anti-Israel terrorists and plenty of wealthy anti Semitic government supporters in all those cities that happily fund or turn a blind eye to anti-Israel terrorism.
I know - But "Hezbollah".
Haele
kentuck
(112,957 posts)Don't you think?
malaise
(278,801 posts)As Kissinger said interests not friends
Beastly Boy
(11,330 posts)You make it sound like they are carpet bombing Beirut like the US carpet bombed Dresden. Can you provide any links, any links at all, that will confirm your statement to be true?
Any links? Please?
Oh, and who are "Bibi's monsters"? Could you be more specific? Since they are automatically presumed to be monsters, whoever they may be, do we get permission to pre-judge them in whatever they do?
Hamas has been staging leadership and supplies in Beirut since at least 2023. Doing the typical Hamas thing, using civilians as shields and not caring at all about consequences. Actually they do care. The want as much collateral damage body count as they can get. Good PR spin.
malaise
(278,801 posts)That is all
Response to malaise (Reply #11)
Post removed
calilama
(24 posts)because he spews antisemitism and pro Hamas bile....if you're a Jew ,your head needs to be on a swivel...either the Trump neo Nazis come for you or the pro Pali Jew haters do...they all hate the same thing...when Jews fight back...Bibi isn't great on a lot of issues but he is DEMOCRATICALLY elected in a free country and no other nation on earth would be asked to accept constant rocket barrages and terrorist attacks as demanded of Israel
peregrinus
(409 posts)Remove it
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)Redleg
(6,248 posts)We can debate the way he is going about "making Israel safe." I think that creating a humanitarian crisis in Gaza and now Lebanon will have long-term negative implications for the safety of Israel, but I could be wrong.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)If Israel fights back, the world screams Israel goes too far if someone's hair gets messed up.
Yet when Jews (yes Jews) die in terrorist attacks, it's always Israel's fault. I've been told many times that terrorism the only weapon Hamas and Hezbollah have to fight the evil Israeli.
Redleg
(6,248 posts)JFC.
getagrip_already
(17,549 posts)Of course it wont be peace. It just wont be 2000 pound bombs. Artillery will still pound. Tanks will still fire. Snipers will still kill.
It will just be a dull backround level of killing.
But the media will eat it up. Peace at last. Of course no palestinians will be allowed to return or remain, but hey, its the lesser of two evils.
And the hero will be louded.
Sundance1220
(177 posts)Until they do, the Israeli's fighting back will not stop. It's all in the hands of the terrorists who hide behind women and children.
Redleg
(6,248 posts)I don't question Israel's right to self-defense. I do reserve the right to question the way they are conducting the war, especially when specific actions appear to violate the rules of just war. The atrocities committed by Hamas and Hezbollah don't justify any and all military actions by the Israeli state.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)ISRAEL!!!!
Redleg
(6,248 posts)This veteran does. If you read my post I stated that Israel had a right to self-defense. People also have a right to state their objections to how Israel goes about doing that.
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)where did I ever say that people don't have a right to state their objections to how Israel goes about doing that?
I've reread my post several times and, so far, I've failed to see where I ever said any such thing.
Perhaps you can enlighten me as to where you interpreted my post to say that?
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)Redleg
(6,248 posts)EOM
Response to MarineCombatEngineer (Reply #75)
MarineCombatEngineer This message was self-deleted by its author.
Redleg
(6,248 posts)EOM
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)Redleg
(6,248 posts)Pax vobiscum.
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)Redleg
(6,248 posts)it does get old. I never said that Israel shouldn't defend it's own people and lands.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)Innocents died when the US started be able to bomb Japan almost daily.
Israel gets attacked. . .their apartheid state left Hamas freedom fighters no choice.
Israel fights back. . .what about innocent people?
People always suffer in wars their government fight. My wife's great grandmother was gang raped by the Japanese in 1938 after the fall of Nanjing outside Zhenjiang in Jiangsu.
But its Israel so all their actions, inactions, and mere existence is grounds for criticizing everything.
Hell, we went to war after 9/11 (albeit against the wrong people based on manipulation) when we were attack.
But Israelis die (and I don't want to use the J word because that would cause people to think I am conspiracy theorist) and the world yawns, blames Israel.
Israel fights back after saying "enough is enough" and the would condemns them.
I wonder why. . .maybe it's because a disdain for the people with that Star on their flag has been part of western civilization since the fall of the Roman empire. But now instead of saying "damn J's," we can coax into nice political language and say "damn Israel."
Redleg
(6,248 posts)or for the terrorist attacks on its citizens. I for one don't blame them. I do reserve the right to criticize how they wage war against their enemies, even when their cause is just, as it is against Hamas.
Sundance1220
(177 posts)like I can be a judge to people who are sent to bomb shelters just about every day while so many in the world think they should just lay down and take it. It's war and war ALWAYS sucks for civilians. And I'm speaking as someone who thinks bibi is loathsome and the worst thing to ever happen to Israel.
Redleg
(6,248 posts)The problem is that there are extremists like Hamas and Hezbollah that think nothing of attacking civilian targets because that creates the most terror. I happen to believe that the state of Israel should hold itself to a higher standard than those they rightly oppose and the world expects nation-states to conform to the rules of warfare. I believe that Netanyahu and some in his ministries are also extremists and it is quite possible that they are making Israel's security situation worse rather than better.
Sundance1220
(177 posts)I just wish I saw as much sympathy for Israeli civilians who have lived under the shadow of terrorism their entire existence. It's always Israel asked to be better, to give up their security in the hope people committed to their annihilation and will stand behind their own women and children no matter the cost, in fact, the bloodier the better, will change their minds.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)western civilization. Those people, me included, can do nothing right.
alarimer
(16,644 posts)No money, no weapons.
Bibi belongs in prison.
tritsofme
(18,709 posts)That is all.
Blue_Tires
(56,735 posts)Especially when Muslim-Americans voted for the angry orange idiot by an overwhelming margin...
Isn't it fascinating now that the election is over how all the public protests and disrupting Dem events and camping on Pelosi's doorstep and blocking bridge traffic in blue cities and self-immolation and angry defiant anti-Biden interviews and taking over city council meetings and college campus destruction on primetime TV have completely stopped??
Isn't it equally strange how there wasn't any similar outrage from these "activists" over Syria, Darfur, or the Uighur genocide in China?
When you answer these questions, you'll know everything.
sarisataka
(21,284 posts)one wonders why these groups are not flexing their demonstrated power by making demands of Republicans...
Rob H.
(5,589 posts)and Harris' refusal to say she would have done anything differently. They and the people who were okay with those policies need to step up and own their role in losing those voters.
Blue_Tires
(56,735 posts)😐
Response to Blue_Tires (Reply #72)
Post removed
Blue_Tires
(56,735 posts)And I'm blaming the fucking voters for backing a Nazi criminal conman, and nobody else...
Those trump voting Muslims can go fuck themselves with the rest of the R's.
OneGrassRoot
(23,444 posts)Trump and the GOP with the same demands, since the GOP is in power? I havent seen the same activism aimed at the GOP. And since so many voted for MAGA, surely theyll make demands as a constituency.
JustAnotherGen
(33,829 posts)Doing my black job and minding my own black business.
Elessar Zappa
(16,082 posts)Fuck Hezbollah.
Basso8vb
(458 posts)It's just going to get worse in January.
Happy Hoosier
(8,558 posts)Sorry, but the constant drumbeat against Biden and the Democrats is one reason this will get worse.
Jose Garcia
(2,921 posts)nycbos
(6,397 posts)sarisataka
(21,284 posts)or is she sitting on the sidelines?
Jose Garcia
(2,921 posts)no_hypocrisy
(49,197 posts)after that . . . . . .
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)then Israel would stop military action against them?
Think maybe that might have something to do with Israel bombing Hizbollah targets in Lebanon?
maxsolomon
(35,359 posts)the IDF kept the pressure up until Hezb agreed to withdraw across the Litani River.
Now, will the actually follow through?
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)I wouldn't hold my breath on them actually complying with the terms of the cease fire.
maxsolomon
(35,359 posts)I think it's worth a shot.
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)and I would urge all party's involved to honor the terms of the cease fire and work towards a lasting peace.
Rob H.
(5,589 posts)based on their recent history. It isn't as if the US is going to cut off their funding after a year of standing by and witnessing them commit war crimes and doing nothing to stop them.
alarimer
(16,644 posts)Ethnic cleansing is what this is. Then they can sweep in and take it all over.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)I love when Jews (yes Jews, not Israelis but Jews) are accused of ethnic cleansing and genocide.
I don't see Israel killing everyone man woman and child they meet or see. If they did, that would be genocide.
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)I think you have no idea what true ethnic cleansing is, and if you think Israel is conducting "ethnic cleansing" then they're doing an awful poor job at it.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)Rob H.
(5,589 posts)has been openly committing war crimes for over a year now, even going so far as to celebrate them on YouTube and TikTok, and the US has done nothing to stop them. We won't even cut off funding and as a result of that they know the US's statements of "deep concern" mean exactly nothing. Anyone who thinks the IDF is going to abide by a ceasefire is delusional.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)Where were you after Oct 7 when the people of Gaza were celebrating rape, kidnapping, torture, and murder of non military targets at a music festival?
Rob H.
(5,589 posts)but this didnt start on October 7 last year. People need to stop pretending otherwise and stop defending and both sides-ing the actions of a murderous far-right-wing demagogue who has overseen the wholesale slaughter of tens of thousands of people.
AZLD4Candidate
(6,375 posts)As I've been told by so many people, before Israel we had no enemies in the middle east. After Israel, we have no friends.
Hamas and Hezbollah want to kill every Jew and Palestinian Israeli in Israel but can't. Israel could wipe out everyone but won't.
If the terrorism stops, this stops. If people stopped harboring Hamas and Hezbollah terrorists, this would stop.
But of course, this is all Israel's fault.
If Oct 7 didn't happen, would this happen now? Don't give me history. If Oct 7th didn't happen, would Israel be at war? Yes or no!
Rob H.
(5,589 posts)rather than push through more huge weapons shipments and as much funding as we can before Biden leaves office. Just imagine the devastation that would be happening at Netanyahu's hands right now.
tenderfoot
(8,879 posts)It's never going to end ever.
nycbos
(6,397 posts)Novel concept I know
MarineCombatEngineer
(14,466 posts)yaesu
(8,360 posts)malaise
(278,801 posts)Rec
tenderfoot
(8,879 posts)alarimer
(16,644 posts)War criminal; should be jailed for life.
Dem4life1234
(2,004 posts)Please explain to me like I'm five. He's been there forever.
tritsofme
(18,709 posts)In Israel, the leader of the party with the most votes typically gets the first opportunity to form a government.
Except for a brief period a few years ago, that has been Netanyahu since 2009.
Dem4life1234
(2,004 posts)Yeah he has led for such a long time. I am sick of him.
H2O Man
(75,779 posts)Terrible.
Traildogbob
(10,195 posts)Having a very rare orgasm, hand full of pearls hugging his golden statue of trump.