General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe unemployed high school drop out thug punk of a racist scumbag
told police he deliberately chose Mother Emanuel AME because of its historical significance to the African American community
Seven magazines -said it had to be done because if he didn't do it no one would.
What level of hate does it take to slaughter six women and three men.
Think about it - he is everything they came up with to caricature young black men.
I am not in the forgiving camp. Forgive my ass!!
etherealtruth
(22,165 posts)all of the dead were highly intelligent, successful, productive members of society ... and by all accounts really outstanding human beings .... and then we have the murderous low-life vermin.
It is sickening
malaise
(279,487 posts)He tore up their own playbook.
bettyellen
(47,209 posts)malaise
(279,487 posts)political connections.
heaven05
(18,124 posts)bettyellen
(47,209 posts)And I feel just dumbstruck with grief. I am not a person of faith, but reading about the victims and then hearing their family and survivors statements last night- just hit so very hard. I'm still stunned today by the love in that community, by their pain.
malaise
(279,487 posts)ChazII
(6,326 posts)and vermin is also an accurate description.
Mojorabbit
(16,020 posts)cui bono
(19,926 posts)SMH
JanMichael
(25,352 posts)he isnt insane he is a terrorist that commited an act 9f terrorism
malaise
(279,487 posts)He won't be heading for Nashville again (that's where he said he was heading).
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)If the victims want to that is up to them and none of our business. Only the 9 families involved can forgive or not forgive.
Hassin Bin Sober
(26,812 posts)Igel
(36,359 posts)If you make a pretense at Xianity, the rule is that "if you have anything against your brother" you have to forgive him. If not now, then later; there's no real immediate enforcement mechanism.
A lot of people have "something" against Roof, and for good reason. He killed 9 people who'd done nothing especially worthy of death, and that's an outrage against morality and principle. For some, it's more personal: The problem is he killed 9 people like themselves in some way meaningful to them--Americans, African-American, Democrats, Xians.... Or others, it's even more personal: An attack on one of their race or ethnic group is an attack against the entire race or ethnic group, something some are conditioned and trained into believing must be true. (In some cultures that would provoke a feud, with the need to kill 9 of his group to even the score, possibly with more as punishment.)
Forgiveness at the personal level, however, does not mean no law enforcement at the institutional level. (That's my particular way of squaring the circle, of connecting classical population movements with current physical and social culture.)
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)I want that neo-Nazi piece of shit to suffer to his dying day.
Scumbags like him make my country suck.
Plucketeer
(12,882 posts)"Accidents" can be forgiven. This young misfit is not eligible. Of course, there's the camp that'll worry whether or not the execution drugs might cause him some discomfort!
blm
(113,892 posts)He sent this nation a message and you don't like our replies to him and his KIND.
"None of our business" till the next one, and, let's add, "Not the time to bring up guns or racism issues", according to those who live on the same political page as Roof, eh?
Your reply is unsurprising. In fact, it's expected.
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)If only you would show your support in Everything.....not shocked at all though.
blm
(113,892 posts).
Response to blm (Reply #87)
Post removed
blm
(113,892 posts)As if we don't know the game. Gee never saw this game before, here .nope .not in 14 years.
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)For NRA and all you need to do is support DU and they disappear. 14 years is a long time to see advertisements you supposedly disagree with. It is very easy to change but only you can.
blm
(113,892 posts)Ms ASSUMPTION?
You don't think enough members know me here to know what game you're trying to play?
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)Ok. You go and spread lies about me without proof and I was trying to help you support our website. I was being nice. You were not being nice to me as typical.
blm
(113,892 posts)Last edited Sat Jun 20, 2015, 05:12 PM - Edit history (1)
You don't KNOW the dynamic here over the last 14 years, yet, you ASSUME you do and wrongly ASSUME that a donation is good cover.
DU don't play like that.
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)blm
(113,892 posts)You can't, because you LIED to try and make a classless point.
yeoman6987
(14,449 posts)blm
(113,892 posts).
it's so fucking clear
heaven05
(18,124 posts)not true, in any respect.
Rosa Luxemburg
(28,627 posts)The problem is that evil scumbag Roof is not alone. There's more of them out there.
malaise
(279,487 posts)Obama is correct - racism is a blight.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)Archae
(46,929 posts)99.9999% of the time, they are losers, dropouts, low-paying jobs (if they even HAVE a job,) and little real education.
alarimer
(16,683 posts)18-24 year old white guys with little prospects who spend most of their time on racist websites. Or Reddit, which I am sure had many, many individuals like this. I'm convinced there is an intersection between white supremacists, GamerGaters and MRA's.
1939
(1,683 posts)brush
(58,292 posts)putting violent ideas in their heads.
Sorry to say it . . . no not sorry, cops need to start profiling these easily influence 20-something, white males who always are the ones doing these mass shootings. Then again the Columbine creeps were teens and the apartment dweller that shot the 3 college students was a 40-something.
Maybe the cops need to start profiling . . .
Quackers
(2,256 posts)He should be executed for his crimes. I know others will disagree but in my opinion, this is a death penalty case.
malaise
(279,487 posts)I will never support the death penalty.
Little Star
(17,055 posts)after reading/hearing about supermax prisons I think the DP may be more humane. I've always been against the DP but after hearing about life in a supermax I just don't know anymore.
http://www.cnn.com/2015/05/13/us/dzhokhar-tsarnaev-supermax-prison/
Color me now confused.
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)Quackers
(2,256 posts)HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)What could this person possibly do to others in our society? He's obviously just misunderstood!
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)What's so hard to understand about that?
Quackers
(2,256 posts)What has he got to lose? Give him another life sentence? He poses a significant threat to others.
HERVEPA
(6,107 posts)Quackers
(2,256 posts)Oh wait.......
http://www.alternet.org/civil-liberties/protests-explode-after-kkk-plot-kill-black-men-florida-prison-exposed
Well, at least this new mass murderer isn't part of a hate group that wants black people dead......
Logical
(22,457 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)him killing POC in prison, especially since we don't hear much about the different gangs in prison. The black gangs, the latinos, the white supremacists. No bullshit about that either. Probably some asian gangs in there also.
Logical
(22,457 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)I stand by what I said.
Logical
(22,457 posts)Number of DNA Exonerations - 330
Average Number of Years Served - 14
Number of Real Perpetrators Found - 140
Astonishingly, more than 1 out of 4 people wrongfully convicted but later exonerated by DNA evidence made a false confession or incriminating statement.
Twenty people have been proven innocent and exonerated by DNA testing in the United States after serving time on death row. They were convicted in 12 states and served a combined 289 years in prison for crimes they didnt commit.
http://www.innocenceproject.org/
heaven05
(18,124 posts)but nice try. I ask you what I asked someone else. I speak from experience of the last 50 years of fighting the dylaan, the racist animal, roofs of this country. While I applaud that innocence project, what have you personally had to face because of your privileged position in a society geared to give you every advantage? Don't try distracting or obfuscating with bullshit as you have so far, answer the question. Dime a dozen and I've seen a lot of dozens this week. I'm through with your silly game, no merit to it.
Logical
(22,457 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)you can't answer which is all the answer I need from you. Your work is honorable and principled, I would never DENY that.
awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)protects society. We do not have to become an animal to deal with one.
Quackers
(2,256 posts)More than likely, he will try to kill more black men in prison. He can't be punished anymore than having life in prison. He has nothing to lose.
But let's look at it from a humanitarian prospective too. Your compassion says that we should not end his life because all life is important. How humane is it to lock a person in a cage knowing they will never get out, for the rest of their existence? Isn't the very idea of that cruel and unusual?
EL34x4
(2,003 posts)He told investigators that he almost got cold feet because the people in the church were so nice to him, but he went through with his murderous rampage anyways.
That tells the jury that he knew what he was doing was wrong, thought it over for a few moments, and started pulling the trigger killing 9 innocent people who had never done any harm to him.
There's people on death row for far less heinous offenses. How can a society that permits the death penalty spare Dylann Roof this punishment? They won't.
Logical
(22,457 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)evidently. May roof die screaming in pain.
Logical
(22,457 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)someone who will put down, metaphorically, socially, lethally, any racist if they attack me, you're right. Look you won't hurt my feelings or shame me because I'm not like you and know what must be done to a rabid animal and will do it. You're only fooling with yourself. LOL
cui bono
(19,926 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)roof was out of control and so are all his KKK, stormfront, confederate flag revering racists and bundyite cohorts. You dial it back. I meant what I wrote, I still do and will till he's dead.
heaven05
(18,124 posts)to a feeling that no human being has the right to commit terrorist acts that kill people and doesn't deserve to die. I am speaking of defending myself against animals like roof and the rest out there in society who would kill based on some skewed and superficial ideology that wants to make supremacy of a skin color the criteria to kill ALL those not of their skin color. Give me a break and turn your dial OFF. The noise is aggravating.
malaise
(279,487 posts)or NOT
cui bono
(19,926 posts)Or a thousand.
Wishing anyone to be tortured and executed is not what we are supposed to be about here.
SMH.
Quackers
(2,256 posts)I am 32 and I've taken life before. I know exactly what it is like. I know very well the consequences of my decisions. Just as this guy knew the consequences of his decision to kill those people. In my opinion, that should be the death penalty.
Logical
(22,457 posts)"I've taken life before" please explain!
About one person a year are released from death row because they are innocent.
I am sure you are clueless on this topic.
But revenge is your emotion, not logic.
Quackers
(2,256 posts)I won't waste anymore time on you.
heaven05
(18,124 posts)with these types that feel they always have the high ground and don't. I salute you!...welcome to DU....
Quackers
(2,256 posts)Quackers
(2,256 posts)Again, it's just my opinion. And for me, the death penalty isn't about revenge or violence. It's about protecting society as a whole. Some people are too far gone to rehabilitate. And even if he could be rehabilitated, how would that affect the families of his victims? If you say give him life in prison, what's the point? As strange as it sounds, I think the death penalty is more humane than life in prison.
Little Star
(17,055 posts)more humane. I also think that people are kept in supermax too long while awaiting death because it's so inhumane inside there. Yet many people have been proven innocent due in part because they were given that long time period. Lets face it, I'm just against supermax prisons because of the total inhumane treatment.
Logical
(22,457 posts)MoonRiver
(36,974 posts)contemplating what he did to his victims. Rot in jail, you POS.
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)He should have nothing to talk to except the four walls of his cell. Leave him there to his dying day, long past the time where he started talking to those four walls, and they started talking back...
MoonRiver
(36,974 posts)City Lights
(25,475 posts)Surya Gayatri
(15,445 posts)Until he starts hallucinating and they have to put him in restraints.
CBGLuthier
(12,723 posts)I do not want to spend the last 30 years of my life full of hatred. Where do we stop? There will always be more like him and more tragedies until we leave this world for good. America has cast its lot with death and hating the individual in a system biased towards hatred, death, and bigotry is tiring.
Glassunion
(10,201 posts)It's hard to forgive. But, it can be a great step in recovery and closure. It's easier not to forgive and hold on to the anger. But the great strength it takes to forgive is to me a great trait of character and grace.
ChazII
(6,326 posts)and your last sentence is one that I will try to practice.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)Because I foregive those who have wronged or cause great harm to me or others without any cause but their own spite or ambition ('for they have their reward') but I don't forget and allow them a second chance without a lot of supervision.
valerief
(53,235 posts)packman
(16,296 posts)It saves money. At the cost of incarceration being compared to an education at an ivy league school, it makes sense to the Repukes to be in favor of the DP. Besides , it plays well to the conservative blood and circus mind.
Logical
(22,457 posts)packman
(16,296 posts)You are right. Appears the costs of appeals, lawyers, etc. on death penalty decisions drive up the costs to almost a factor of 10.
Logical
(22,457 posts)1939
(1,683 posts)Logical
(22,457 posts)Is let off of death row
PCIntern
(27,086 posts)I'm not going to comment further...what I have to say would be construed by some as irreligious and vindictive, and I'm in no mood for one of THOSE arguments after this catastrophe.
bonniebgood
(952 posts)Historical significance to the African American community;? Please we are talking about a high school drop-out who probably can't read or write. Would a racist terrorist to the core use the words African American Community? Who believes what the police says anyway. The police that came up with this 'he said' are probably a member in the same hate group.
All this crap about his motives is nothing more than planting evidence in the public's mind that he acted alone. This MF should be waterboarded, and made to tell who his associations are. I certainly hopes the justice department gets to the bottom of this.
malaise
(279,487 posts)Don't be fooled.
Torture and the death penalty are against my convictions.
muriel_volestrangler
(102,744 posts)It does not produce reliable answers, just what a terrified victim thinks the torturers want to hear. It puts the state into the role of criminal. It encourages people, justifiably, to call the state the enemy. It's against the law and constitution. There's no urgency. He is already talking, apparently freely, to the police. They can investigate his background in the normal way.
Waterboarding him is the worst suggestion I've heard in this whole affair. It's worse than the people suggesting that it might not have been about race.
lunasun
(21,646 posts)Innocent shooting victims like 17 yr old Trayvon Martin got dragged though the mud
malaise
(279,487 posts)with that 'mud color' - don't yah know that???
heaven05
(18,124 posts)evil, his kind and the groups he revers being a threat to the black community, men women and children. I wouldn't be surprised if another Rosewood massacre wasn't being cooked up somewhere in this beloved land of ours.....in some sick GROUP of dylaan roofs.
Surya Gayatri
(15,445 posts)But, hell will be sub-zero before you'll get them to acknowledge that fact, much less to admit it.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)stands tall in this picture? The Rs are acting like idiots in their denials. But those families rose above the hatred. As they said "Hate is not going to win." And in their forgiveness hate lost because everyone watching was amazed and fully understood who was superior in this situation.
I do not think I could have done that but they had the strength to live their beliefs. These families are leaders.
malaise
(279,487 posts)on that we agree - way better than me.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)3catwoman3
(25,846 posts)...to be met is forgiveness for acts that, IMO, are unforgivable. I would not have it within me.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)I understand forgiveness to be about my feelings. The killer will still have to face charges and probably the death sentence. Forgiveness never keeps one from facing the consequences of his actions. Instead forgiveness lets the victims families know that the killer did not succeed in bringing them down to his level of hate.
BumRushDaShow
(145,167 posts)I got a NYT breaking and posted on LBN - http://www.democraticunderground.com/10141122744
The website was apparently registered under his name.
malaise
(279,487 posts)WTFF???
I only want to know who took all the photos.
BumRushDaShow
(145,167 posts)or he staged them with a tripod or similar.
Edit to add what came to mind to me was that hard rock group "Guns N' Roses", where apparently they had some nasty controversy with their lead singer and some of the songs.
JHB
(37,497 posts)No one else appears with him on any of the photos from the site.
Planntation pictures, confederate flag-waving, and neoNazi numerology, him burning one U.S. flag and stepping on another one.
But "we'll never know what drove him so do something like this".
MADem
(135,425 posts)I wouldn't be surprised if he took that one himself, by propping his iPhone up against something and setting the timer.
The angle looks a bit low for a photographer....
Takket
(22,701 posts)if a black man was photographed holding a gun like that, they'd be calling him a thug, so why not this thug?
BumRushDaShow
(145,167 posts)the black man with a gun would be a "thuggish 'gang banger'".
MADem
(135,425 posts)Jamastiene
(38,197 posts)those innocent people. He even went so far as to say he almost did not do it because they were so nice to him. That is some SERIOUS HATRED that he acknowledged how kind they were to him, spent an hour with them, then slaughtered them anyhow. That is one cold-hearted hatemonger.
malaise
(279,487 posts)Wonder if he still feels that way - too fugging late for this hater.
Spitfire of ATJ
(32,723 posts)heaven05
(18,124 posts)but hard to admit by some here. He didn't end up where he is without help.....Main Sham Media and others.
blm
(113,892 posts)being honest when they were 'warning' their voters about the 'takeover' of 'their' country by the black guy in the WH.
LittleBlue
(10,362 posts)When they execute him he will burn in hell
A HERETIC I AM
(24,658 posts)If you believe that then you likely believe in repentance.
Great thing Christianity has going.
Do ANYTHING you want except one thing, and as long as you say the magic words, you get to spend an eternity in paradise.
Pretty cool, eh?
Oh, BTW, the only unforgivable sin?
Blasphemy. I'm not worried though.
It's all nonsense anyway. When he's dead he be dead
The Jungle 1
(4,552 posts)lunasun
(21,646 posts)I am assuming that is what you meant
Lifelong Protester
(8,421 posts)Can't imagine what would possibly happen to a racist thug. In prison.
tblue37
(66,043 posts)http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/06/19/charleston-lesson-black-americans-live-with-terrorism-all-the-time.html
CHARLESTON LESSON: BLACK AMERICANS LIVE WITH TERRORISM ALL THE TIME
BY BARRETT HOLMES PITNER 06.19.1511:15 AM ET
<SNIP>
"He was big into segregation and other stuff. He said he wanted to start a civil war, said Roofs roommate Dalton Tyler. [Hed been] planning something like that for six months.
John Mullins, a former classmate of Roof, told the Daily Beast that Roof had that kind of Southern pride, I guess some would say. Strong conservative beliefs. He made a lot of racist jokes, but you dont really take them seriously like that. You dont really think of it like that. Essentially, according to Mullins and Tyler, condoned racism is a natural extension of white Southern pride.
The views of Roof still align with those of a rebel faction that was intent on fracturing America and oppressing black Americans. When he drove by the capital building and saw the Confederate flag, he received encouragement for his bigotry. When he made racist jokes, or discussed starting a civil war, no one severely reprimanded him or told him that those views are not tolerated <emphasis added>. He was given a handgun for his 21st birthday, and no one around him could imagine that he could use his bigotry and newly acquired ability to kill to inflict terror upon those he hates.
The African American community knew that this was a recipe for disaster, and they also know that the more they discuss injustices and the more they fight for equality, the greater likelihood that terror will befall them. My family was saddened and distraught by the shooting at Emanuel AME, but they were not shocked. We, and countless other black Americans, have lived through generations of terror <emphasis added>.
<SNIP>
Edited to add bold and to correct the mess I made in my attempt to copy-paste part of the article while on my 7" Nook tablet.
malaise
(279,487 posts)Good read
GeorgeGist
(25,463 posts)their abusers.
nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)he is a terrorist.
Semantics, I know.
malaise
(279,487 posts)Looks like I left out one critical word
A HERETIC I AM
(24,658 posts)"Tiny dicked"
This guy was disturbed in part because a black guy started dating a girl he fancied.
"You're raping our women"
Yeah..... Small dick, no doubt about it
malaise
(279,487 posts)Jamastiene
(38,197 posts)It's not called rape when she chose to date the black guy over his loser ass. It's called going out with the guy she really wanted to go out with.
All sorts of things are wrong with that guy's warped views. Whoever the woman was, she's lucky. Her life would have been horrid with someone as awful as him.
bluestateguy
(44,173 posts)The one thing he had in life, he believed, was that he was a WHITE MAN.
That's the only thing he had in life. Pathetic.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)Good lord, I'd feel so privileged if I lived like that. The kid had what only great wealth can buy.
What is with these people?
They have what most dream of having, like that suburban scum that went to town and ran over that factory worker.
What the fuck do they want?
As the fly on the wall, I have heard various incarnations of his rants for over fifty years. They used to be stomped on hard by the law, society, media. Now they get to organize (Faux News, GOP, Tea Party, 2nd Amendment Solutionists, militias, Bundies,. etc, etc.) and act out what was once called terrorism and organized crime.
Because that is what it is, since it's not longer First Amendment, but planning genocide.
Yes, there's stochastic terrorism in effect here - but also a lack of education and the will to do what is right and show respect.
There he was, with the people he despised, who gave him love and still forgave him.
He is scum. They are angels.
Burn the Confederate flag this coming Saturday to start to tell these jackasses that his and their sick mentality is no longer going to be accepted.
And America can never, ever, take the boot off the neck of these murderous groups. The Europeans learned. We had learned for a while, too.
And this is all being done to install a RWNJ government which will oppress all people. 'What goers around, comes around.'
cui bono
(19,926 posts)the forgiving. It's letting go of the negativity you hold inside you so you can move on. It doesn't mean you excuse what they've done.
Just as we can't let him off the hood as 'mentally ill' we can't just say he was an asshole racist without understanding how a human being who is born innocent learns to become such an ugly soul full of hatred. He is a product of his society, so while what he did was truly horrendous, other people made him learn to be that way. So if it helps the survivors deal with what happened by forgiving him and understanding that he became that way for a reason they should forgive him. And all of us should work to eradicate the circumstances that caused him to become that way.
I'm not religious by any means and I feel horrible about what happened and am not trying to diminish it in any way. In fact, I think that looking beyond this individual person and examining all the reasons he grew up to be how he was is more beneficial and constructive than holding onto the anger against just him.
I hope this isn't coming across the wrong way... it's difficult to speak about these things when emotions are running high.