Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

happybird

(4,954 posts)
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 08:59 PM Tuesday

Do you make your chili with or without beans?

A good friend and I argue every time the topic of chili comes up. I am firmly in the bean camp, he is just as firmly anti-bean. Making a pot now, and while straining the light red kidney beans and black beans, I wondered about the opinions of my DU family, and also any “secret ingredients” you may add.

Chili: Beans or No Beans?

49 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Do you make your chili with or without beans? (Original Post) happybird Tuesday OP
its good with bacon and or beans nt msongs Tuesday #1
Never have tried bacon in there... happybird Tuesday #21
With... Sane1 Tuesday #2
extra beans crud Tuesday #3
Loooove bacon! happybird Tuesday #22
I hate beans and thought I was the only one who made chili without them. :-) spooky3 Tuesday #4
With dweller Tuesday #5
Light, dark, & black beans SheltieLover Tuesday #6
Yes Duncanpup Tuesday #10
Beans: with chili, not in it. DinahMoeHum Tuesday #7
With. Floyd R. Turbo Tuesday #8
When I used to make chili, KarenS Tuesday #9
With--they make it "healthy" no matter what else you add. hlthe2b Tuesday #11
No beans LiberalLoner Tuesday #12
Plate Chili EarthAbides Tuesday #13
I use taco seasoning in mine :) happybird Tuesday #20
i do 2 versions built on my paternal grandma's. my aunt is allergic to beans. pansypoo53219 Tuesday #14
I love black beans! happybird Tuesday #30
my grandma made hers w/ kidney beans, pasta + potatoes. i don't like mixing taters + pasta. my other aunt is not a bean pansypoo53219 Yesterday #42
Beans! sorcrow Tuesday #15
That's a nice memory :) happybird Tuesday #23
With Freethinker65 Tuesday #16
With MiKenMi33 Tuesday #17
With ,,,, Sam Arnold's "Historic Jailhouse Chili" Hotler Tuesday #18
That sounds wonderful! happybird Tuesday #25
With beans subterranean Tuesday #19
I make both kinds chowmama Tuesday #24
omg, pineapple?!? happybird Tuesday #26
College cooking on a budget, what can I say? chowmama Tuesday #28
The Southwest style is more like a gravy or carne guisada, served on top of corn bread etc. LeftInTX 28 min ago #49
Usually w/dark/light kidney beans and multicolored peppers, mushrooms, sweet onion, fire-roasted diced tomatos, spices - Backseat Driver Tuesday #27
I use ranch style beans and ground turkey, Rotel tomatoes, Ilsa Tuesday #29
I loads thems beans right up. magicarpet Tuesday #31
mostly beans DBoon Tuesday #32
If no beans what, then? Not chili. An omelette? question everything Tuesday #33
I like the beans BlueKota Tuesday #34
Yes. diane in sf Tuesday #35
Beans, of course rocketdem1964 Tuesday #36
No... Mark.b2 Tuesday #37
Lentils Zambero Tuesday #38
Mild. With. Secret ingredient: Can. UTUSN Yesterday #39
Yeah Figarosmom Yesterday #40
Definitely no beans. LoisB Yesterday #41
gound beef( wheres the beef)? boil in a bag rice an frozen mixed veggies for a rounded meal :) AllaN01Bear 19 hrs ago #43
I make my chili with a pan and a can opener. JustABozoOnThisBus 19 hrs ago #44
make? Skittles 10 hrs ago #45
With beans. Paladin 10 hrs ago #46
With beans because I usually make Luciferous 10 hrs ago #47
With ProfessorGAC 9 hrs ago #48

DinahMoeHum

(22,289 posts)
7. Beans: with chili, not in it.
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 09:10 PM
Tuesday

For me, beans are a side dish to chili and eaten with either rice or cornbread. I like black beans.

Texas Red is my style, for beef or pork. I also make a white chili, with turkey and chicken, again without beans in it.

hlthe2b

(104,971 posts)
11. With--they make it "healthy" no matter what else you add.
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 09:14 PM
Tuesday

Plus. where would "Blazing Saddles" be without them!

EarthAbides

(65 posts)
13. Plate Chili
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 09:23 PM
Tuesday

We make chili with left over taco meat, red beans, black beans and pinto beans. Spoon the chili on a plate over shredded lettuce and then top the chili with black olives, chopped onion, chopped cucumber, grated cheese, avocado, pico de gallo and a dollop of sour cream. Plate chili! Yum!!

happybird

(4,954 posts)
20. I use taco seasoning in mine :)
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:10 PM
Tuesday

It started out as, “Oh no, I thought we had an envelope of chili seasoning in the cupboard, but here’s an envelope of taco seasoning…” and it turned out to be a happy substitution! McCormick Chicken Taco Seasoning and lots of chili powder.

pansypoo53219

(21,486 posts)
14. i do 2 versions built on my paternal grandma's. my aunt is allergic to beans.
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 09:33 PM
Tuesday

can of tomato sauce
can of stewed toms or can of whole toms
beef bouillon
i use 1/4c of ground beef amount up to you
1 onion
celery
pasta
chili powder as much as you like

bean version i like a mix of red + black beans
can tomato sauce
can of whole toms crushed
beef bouillon
onion
celery
potato
chili powder

happybird

(4,954 posts)
30. I love black beans!
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:28 PM
Tuesday

Never known anyone with a bean allergy, but then it occurred to me that it’s probably not uncommon: legumes, peanuts, etc. I am intrigued by including potatoes! I like chili over pasta or rice, bet it would be great over some diced, boiled potatoes, too.

pansypoo53219

(21,486 posts)
42. my grandma made hers w/ kidney beans, pasta + potatoes. i don't like mixing taters + pasta. my other aunt is not a bean
Wed Sep 18, 2024, 04:52 AM
Yesterday

fan.

sorcrow

(469 posts)
15. Beans!
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 09:39 PM
Tuesday

Beans for chili in a bowl. I saw an interesting recipe for a beans-free hot dog chili. Reminds me of the chili dogs from the Tastee Dog when I was a little kid. Used to sit at the counter with my mom, eat chili dogs, and listen to Ahab the Arab on the jukebox.

Best regards,
Sorghum Crow

Hotler

(11,812 posts)
18. With ,,,, Sam Arnold's "Historic Jailhouse Chili"
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 09:54 PM
Tuesday

Sam Arnold's Jailhouse Chili
Ingredients:
6 slices bacon
1/2 lb hot bulk pork sausage
2 pounds ground chili beef or
chopped stew meat
1 cup of chopped onions
2 mashed garlic cloves
2/3 cup chopped green pepper
4 tablespoons pure New Mexico red chili powder
2 teaspons of cilantro
1 teaspoon or leaf oregano
1/2 teaspoon cumin seed
2 cans of beer
1 12-oz can of tomato paste
3 cups cooked anasazi or pinto beans (canned beans may be used, but they're not nearly as good as cooking them from scratch!)
Preparation:
Cook bacon crisp, drain, cool and crumble, set aside. Brown sausage, drain, set aside. Keep 1/4 cup of the fat. Brown ground beef. Cook pepper, garlic and onion and combine with cooked beef, sausage. Add beer and tomato paste, and simmer at low heat (200 degree F) for two hours. Add beans, cook 20 minutes longer and serve with shredded cheese and chopped onion over the top. If you like it hotter, add finely minced serrano chilies (not jalapenos).

Acknowledgment:
This receipt was published in the Denver Post ~1997 or so. It comes from Sam Arnold's extensive cook book of special frontier receipts that he had researched. Many of which are used now at his family's "The Fort" restaurant located near Red Rock, Colorado, a southwestern suburb of Denver. If you are ever near by, you just have to dine at The Fort. It is a very unique dining experience.
https://inquestllc.com/Chili.php

happybird

(4,954 posts)
25. That sounds wonderful!
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:17 PM
Tuesday

I use ground chuck but would like to try stew meat. It would have a great texture.

chowmama

(463 posts)
24. I make both kinds
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:16 PM
Tuesday

Midwest chili with ground meat and beans, and Southwest chili with cubed meat and no beans. I love both of them.

I haven't seen very many variations on SW chili; it's still mostly dried chilis made into a paste for seasoning. I know there's some argument about if other veg can be included with the meat, and purists seem to object to even onion and garlic. Tomatoes are sometimes almost as much a heresy as beans. Not much room there.

My Midwest chili is fairly standard (chili powder, onions, beans, tomatoes, etc.), but my father borrowed a trick from some neighbors to extend the meat even further by including corn kernels. Weird, but tasty. 1 pound of meat made at least 12 servings, at a time when we could use the savings. DH decided he likes it that way, so I add corn, too. (But more meat and chili powder, so less savings.)

The weirdest Midwest chili I ever ran into was at college, at a theater pre-show potluck. That guy's family used all the usual additives, and then threw in elbow macaroni and pineapple tidbits. Not much seasoning, if I recall - it was just an odd hamburger bean stew, sort of like hot dish soup in a bowl, with pineapple. Hella cheap, though.

happybird

(4,954 posts)
26. omg, pineapple?!?
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:21 PM
Tuesday

That sounds … interesting.
😁

I do like my chili over pasta (penne or macaroni, anything hollow) and a dollop sour cream on top. And I have put corn in there a few times. The little pops of sweet are nice and satisfying. The SW chili people would judge me so hard, lol!

chowmama

(463 posts)
28. College cooking on a budget, what can I say?
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:27 PM
Tuesday

Some of those potlucks and after-show parties got pretty interesting. I remember the night we were doing tequila shots with salt and lime, and we ran out of limes. Somebody else had brought slightly scorched molasses ginger cookies, so we used them instead.

Of course, we'd gone through a fair bit of tequila by then.

Backseat Driver

(4,555 posts)
27. Usually w/dark/light kidney beans and multicolored peppers, mushrooms, sweet onion, fire-roasted diced tomatos, spices -
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:25 PM
Tuesday

shhh...it's a secret - a full dutch oven pot on top of range simmered a long time.

Ilsa

(62,091 posts)
29. I use ranch style beans and ground turkey, Rotel tomatoes,
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:28 PM
Tuesday

McCormick's chili seasoning, frozen cut onions and bell peppers (sautéed first), garlic, and tomato sauce for a quick chile.

I also like making chili by cutting beef down into small chunks (bean size) to sauté with onions, garlic, seasoning, etc. No beans necessary. More purist.

magicarpet

(15,815 posts)
31. I loads thems beans right up.
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 10:32 PM
Tuesday

Kidney beans,...

Pea beans,...

And Black beans.

Stewed tomatoes, tomato sauce, tomato paste, lots garlic, sausage, ground beef, onion, green pepper, jalapeño, chili powder, and ground pepper.

Great on cold snowy weather days.

rocketdem1964

(28 posts)
36. Beans, of course
Tue Sep 17, 2024, 11:05 PM
Tuesday

As a vegetarian, the beans are the best part. I also thrown in some homemade refried beans to get the thickness that I like.

Figarosmom

(720 posts)
40. Yeah
Wed Sep 18, 2024, 12:55 AM
Yesterday

It's the beans I like. I know a lot of people say chili is just meat, whatever. But to me if it's just meat why give it a name instead of just calling it boiled meat soup.

And I like V8 instead of plain tomato sauce. Lots of chili powder and jalapeños and onions. Beef bullion
and crushed red peppers. And always the bean juice from the can. I use one can dark kidneys and the rest are dried beans

Paladin

(28,597 posts)
46. With beans.
Wed Sep 18, 2024, 07:22 PM
10 hrs ago

Way too much argument over the beans/no beans chili issue. Eat it the way you prefer---end of story.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Do you make your chili wi...