One cookie must go--oatmeal raisin,,, chocolate chip,, ,peanut butter....sugar cookie with/without frosting

[debm55]

[2naSalit]

1. The sugar cookie...

They are the least appealing, frosted or not.

[debm55]

2. Thank you 2nSalit.

[sdfernando]

3. Toss out the chocolate chip

The others are much better.

I eat chocolate, sure, but I'm not a big fan. If I never had chocolate again in my life, I doubt I would really miss it.

Yeah, I know, to some that is SACRILEGE!

[debm55]

5. I don't eat cc either. Thank you sdfernando.

[Permanut]

4. Every cookie with almonds..

Anyone putting almonds in cookies should be arrested and heavily fined for cookie abuse.

[debm55]

7. Edited Thank you Permanut. I am so sorry that happened to you.

Last edited Wed Oct 23, 2024, 05:31 PM - Edit history (2)

:hug

[lapfog_1]

17. yes, I'm allergic

someone once gave me an oatmeal cookie... they put crushed walnuts in it... result was quick trip to the ER... and now I carry an Epi pen.

And yes I asked if they baked it with nuts in it. They said "no"...

[debm55]

19. Again I am so sorry that happened to you

[4TheArts]

6. Be gone sugar cookies.

Besides that, they could all be replaced with homemade Scottish shortbread.

[debm55]

9. HAHAHHAHHAHHAHH/ thank you 4The Arts.

[Basso8vb]

8. I like them all!

[debm55]

10. But Basso8vb. which one is your least favorite.

[LoisB]

11. Peanut butter for sure.

[debm55]

13. Thank you LoisB. for your choice.

[AltairIV]

12. Oatmeal Raisin

Sorry the oatmeal raisin has got to go. Love the oatmeal, not a fan of raisins.

[debm55]

14. Thank you AltairIV for your choice.

[Luciferous]

15. This is an easy one, the sugar cookie

[debm55]

16. Thank you Lucoferous

[sakabatou]

20. Raisin will ALWAYS go into the trash bin

[debm55]

22. Thank you sakabatou.

[ravjav]

21. Peanut Butter. NT

[debm55]

23. Thank you ravjav.

[ProfessorGAC]

24. Sugar

Especially the ones with frosting.
I think the peanut butter cookie is the one I choose if you said I could only keep one. Especially with the little toffee bits on top! Yum!

[debm55]

31. Thank you ProfessorGAC.

[sinkingfeeling]

25. Peanut butter cookies, ugh.

[debm55]

32. Thank you sinkingfeeling.

[PoindexterOglethorpe]

26. I have a chocolate chip cookie that could bring about world peace.

It's a recipe from a 1930something cookbook that belonged to my mother. Because it's so old, the amount of sugar is significantly less than in a modern recipe. And they come out of the oven an exquisite combination of crispy and chewy.

[debm55]

33. The only time I like CC is when they are fresh out of the oven with a cold glass of milk thank you.

[PoindexterOglethorpe]

40. Bingo. Fresh out of the oven.

For me, as soon as my cookies have cooled down to room temperature they may as well be stale.

[catbyte]

27. Oatmeal raisin

I really like oatmeal cookies, but the raisins, blecch. I've never been fond of raisins and only really like them in Raisin Bran for some reason.

[debm55]

34. Thank you catbyte.

[The Blue Flower]

28. Sugar cookie

Unless it has almond flavoring in it.

[debm55]

35. Thank you The Blue Flower.

[WestMichRad]

29. Let the oatmeal-raisin cookies go with me!

I love ‘em. Youse gals and guys can fight over the rest.

[debm55]

36. Thank you WestMichRad. So do I

[biophile]

30. Oatmeal raisin

There isn’t any recipe that raisins can’t ruin

[debm55]

37. Thank you biophile.

[biophile]

47. Glad you're back! ☺️

[debm55]

48. Thank you.

[electric_blue68]

38. BAAAAHAHAHAHAAAAAA! 😄

Laffing out loud here!

When I was playing in our park as a kid most times my Mom would raise her arm when I was near by, wave her hand w a little box of Sunmaid's Raisins in it.
Blargh!

I didn't dislike them soooo much that I'd gag on them (unlike licorice first and only time I ever had a black jelly bean 😄😬Gak!), but I really disliked them!

I can eat them a bit now like raisin bran, or little pumpernickel rolls with raisins, and walnuts. And Ukrainian Easter bread. That's it.

[biophile]

46. I can eat raisins but not cooked

Anytime they are in something and get re-hydrated , they are just disgusting. Can’t do it! 😏

[debm55]

67. Thank you, I understand.

[electric_blue68]

70. I'm not sure I've ever had them like that! Off hand I can't think of any dishes....

Perhaps....

I avoided them? 😄

Almost positive my mom never made any. Don't think I recall anyone else cooking, or bringing a dish like that.

[electric_blue68]

39. Oatmeal raisin.

I don't think I'd ever had a sugar cookie with frosting.

Love the PB Cookies.
Chocolate chip near addict as long as the chips are at least semi sweet. Prefer bittersweet. 😍🍪😍

[debm55]

42. Thank you electric_blue68

[pansypoo53219]

41. i wanna say butter cookies. i have an awesome oatmeal raisin/craisin/marachino cherry recipe.

i got a great sugar cookie recipe of course, when i crushed peanuts + added it to the sugar cookie recipe, they were the best peanut cookies. i also put coffee grounds, coconut + such in that recipe. i let my aunt make the choc chip cookies.
then there's the shortbreads...

[debm55]

43. Thank you pansypoo53219

[Xavier Breath]

44. A sugar cookie without frosting is just about useless.

Well, I suppose you can let them harden and then use them as poker chips, or maybe to shore up an uneven table leg.

It was my birthday and I was seven, and as I was leaving for school my Mom told me she was making snickerdoodles for the occasion. She had never made them for me before so I was unfamiliar with that cookie. But, I was (a newly minted) seven, so when she said 'snickerdoodle' I of course thought that they were made with chocolate, peanuts, caramel and nougat. In other words, a Snickers. It seemed a miracle that such a cookie would exist. Imagine my disappointment when I arrived home only to find a god damn sugar cookie.

I've never touched them since. Miss you Mom, despite the sugar cookie incident.

[debm55]

45. Thank you for your post, Xavier Breath I agree.

Last edited Thu Oct 24, 2024, 12:26 PM - Edit history (1)

[Emile]

49. Chocolate chip

Don't get me wrong, I love the others maybe just a tiny bit more than chocolate chip. Now my wife prefers chocolate chip over any of them.

[debm55]

50. Thank you Emile

[OLDMDDEM]

51. Sugar cookie without frosting.

[debm55]

52. Thank you OLDMDDEM

[Phoenix61]

53. Sugar cookie goes.

I love oatmeal raisin but few folks do so I make oatmeal chocolate chip.

[debm55]

57. Thank you Phoenix61 Your recipe sounds great. Thank you.

[iamateacher]

54. Definitely peanut butter

Should go!

[debm55]

58. Agree. Thank you iamateacher.

[kimbutgar]

55. Peanut butter cookies ugh

Thought it’s my sons favorite cookie!

[debm55]

60. I agree with you too kimgutgar. Thank you

[Bristlecone]

56. Sugar

[debm55]

61. Thank you very much Bristlecone.

[IA8IT]

59. I make oatmeal raisin bread at least once a month so out goes the oatmeal raisin cookie.

Toasted with butter and honey........It's not cheating

[debm55]

62. HAHAHAHAHAH thank you IABIT

[Different Drummer]

63. Oatmeal raisin.

I don't dislike any of the cookies on your list, Deb, but oatmeal raisin is the one I like the least.

[debm55]

65. Thank you Different Drummer.

[TexasBushwhacker]

64. Sugar cookie

Not a fan of sugar cookies by themselves, but I make a fresh fruit "pizza" on a round pan and use sugar cookie dough for the "crust".

[debm55]

66. Thank you TexasBushWhacker. I have seen the done and they are great.

[ailsagirl]

68. Oatmeal raisin

Nothing wrong with oatmeal cookies, just that I like all the others more. 🍪

[debm55]

69. Thank you ailsagirl.

[area51]

71. Oatmeal raisin.

[debm55]

72. Thank you area51.