Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

In It to Win It

(9,501 posts)
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 09:50 AM Oct 2022

Voters have the power to oust four far-right FL Supreme Court justices on Nov. 8. Will they use it?

Florida Bulldog

The midterm elections could transform the Florida Supreme Court, but probably won’t.

Next month voters can choose to evict up to five of the court’s seven justices. In theory, Floridians could respond to the court’s regressive designs by firing most of the designers.

They could do what the Sun Sentinel urged in an editorial last week: Remove Justices Charles Canady, Ricky Polston, Jamie Grosshans and John Couriel, all key players in the court’s “harsh new majority.” The newspaper recommends keeping moderate Justice Jorge Labarga, “whose principled but lonely dissents in high-profile cases have exposed the majority’s radical activism.”

Yet it will be astonishing if any of the four conservatives lose at the polls.In the 44 years that Florida voters have been empowered to retain or reject appellate judges, they’ve never once dropped a Supreme Court justice.

This campaign season, editorials in some major newspapers call for rejecting the four arch-conservative justices, arguing they’ve broken trust with the public. Traditional media aren’t as far-reaching and influential as they used to be, however.

Proven vote-getting techniques like splashy advertising productions, social media saturation and a vigorous ground game seem to be reserved for the many higher-profile campaigns in the run-up to Nov. 8. It’s hard to compete for airtime with Gov. Ron DeSantis versus Charlie Crist or Rep. Val Demings versus Sen. Marco Rubio.

PARIENTE’S SPOT-ON PREDICTION

The justices told the Orlando Sentinel editorial board that the smear campaign was part of then-Gov. Rick Scott’s plot to reshape the court in his own partisan image.

“I think it’s a smokescreen for the real issue, which is a political party wanting to control all three branches of government,” Pariente told the board.

The counterattack worked. The justices won retention with 67-68 percent of the vote.

But their mandatory retirement at the end of 2018 let incoming Gov. DeSantis finish the job of transforming the court from majority-liberal to supermajority-conservative.

Today, as Pariente foretold, Republicans dominate all three branches of Florida government.

Karl said the high court’s post-midterm agenda is obvious.

“I fully anticipate that the Florida Supreme Court will uphold the 15-week abortion ban,” he said, “and reverse the 1989 case [the In re: TW decision] that found our Florida constitutional right to privacy guarantees the right of a woman to make her own health care decisions.”
7 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Voters have the power to oust four far-right FL Supreme Court justices on Nov. 8. Will they use it? (Original Post) In It to Win It Oct 2022 OP
Florida rso Oct 2022 #1
When replacement to be worse? jimfields33 Oct 2022 #2
We're on the same page. I won't be shocked with the possibly batshit crazy replacements In It to Win It Oct 2022 #3
Same. I've heard so many Floridians say how great DeSantis is. jimfields33 Oct 2022 #4
I intend to vote against all sitting Judges (in Fl), however, it is just tilting at windmills. Chainfire Oct 2022 #5
I usually look to see who appointed the judges, but this year I followed the St. Johns County dameatball Oct 2022 #6
Wasn't sure who snowybirdie Oct 2022 #7

rso

(2,446 posts)
1. Florida
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 09:54 AM
Oct 2022

My family and I are all voting against retention of these judges, and the Democratic Party has sent info via mail on these judges to registered voters, so I’m hopeful.

jimfields33

(18,696 posts)
2. When replacement to be worse?
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 10:15 AM
Oct 2022

When replacement to be worse? That’s my concern. DeSantis can pick their replacement. Crist chose moderates according to many. I’ll still vote then out. Just don’t be shocked with the replacements.

In It to Win It

(9,501 posts)
3. We're on the same page. I won't be shocked with the possibly batshit crazy replacements
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 10:24 AM
Oct 2022

I'm aware of the 'fight' I chose.

I'm not entirely confident that these judges will lose their retention election. If they do lose, DeSantis can appoint their replacement. Like you, I will vote 'no' on them regardless. It really hinges on the belief that Charlie Crist can pull out a win. Truthfully, I'm not entirely confident on Crist winning either but I'll vote for him anyway.

jimfields33

(18,696 posts)
4. Same. I've heard so many Floridians say how great DeSantis is.
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 10:28 AM
Oct 2022

I was look at them with pity for how dumb they are. I live in a red area so go figure.

 

Chainfire

(17,757 posts)
5. I intend to vote against all sitting Judges (in Fl), however, it is just tilting at windmills.
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 10:38 AM
Oct 2022

The same goes for the Constitutional amendments and county referendum. If the Republicans got it on the ballot, I don't want it.

dameatball

(7,602 posts)
6. I usually look to see who appointed the judges, but this year I followed the St. Johns County
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 10:47 AM
Oct 2022

Democratic Party recommendations. In this state I doubt that either approach will prevail. My vote was mailed in last week, so we shall see.

snowybirdie

(5,607 posts)
7. Wasn't sure who
Wed Oct 12, 2022, 12:20 PM
Oct 2022

to pick, so I googled them all. Didn't vote for any Deathsantis appointees. We received no literature from any Democratic party here in SW Florida. That is if one exists!

Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Florida»Voters have the power to ...