Despite inflation, U.S. consumers are 5% better off than in 2019--here's why they don't feel that way

[mahatmakanejeeves]

Commentary·inflation
Despite inflation, U.S. consumers are 5% better off than in 2019—here’s why they don’t feel that way

BY Philipp Carlsson-Szlezak and Paul Swartz
Philipp Carlsson-Szlezak is Global Chief Economist and Paul Swartz is senior economist at Boston Consulting Group. They are the authors of Shocks, Crises, and False Alarms: How to Assess True Macroeconomic Risk (HBR Press, 2024).

October 23, 2024 at 1:42 PM EDT

The public debate about inflation has caught on to what economists have long known: Price change—aka inflation—and prices are not the same thing. Though inflation has fallen back sharply over the last two years, prices have not dropped—they have merely risen more slowly. And while politicians promise lower prices on the campaign trail, the dirty little secret is that nobody wants prices to fall across the board. Falling prices constitute deflation, inflation’s ugly cousin.

So, are American voters stuck on a plateau of higher prices? Not quite. Wages matter just as much as prices. If the prices of all goods doubled in one year, consumers would face dire circumstances. But if wages also doubled, any financial injury would be largely psychological. What ultimately matters is price affordability—the ratio of prices and wages.

Price affordability in America

Since 2019, consumer prices are up nearly 20%, a painful surge after years of tame price growth in the pre-pandemic era. However, wages are up more than 25% over the same period. As a result, price affordability in aggregate is actually 5% better than it was in 2019. ... At inflation’s crescendo in 2021-22, affordability slumped when wages did not keep pace. But since the middle of 2022, wages have been growing faster than prices. They’ve made up lost ground and are now inching ahead.

U.S. consumption data proves this point. While public discourse continues to paint U.S. consumers as cash-strapped and on the verge of folding, that narrative does not line up with the evidence. Total consumption has held up remarkably well despite gyrations in prices and wages, delivering strong growth and punting away persistent fears of recession. At an annualized pace of 2.9% in the second quarter, consumption is nowhere near recessionary conditions.

{snip}

[MichMan]

1. My Social Security didn't go up 25%

[The Mouth]

2. That OP is as wrong as can be.

Crock. Of. shit. As *ANYONE* on a fixed income knows.

2021-2024 have been the worst economic years for the people I know and grew up with, since the late 1970's.

I understand quite well that the Biden administration has had to play the hand delt it, but claiming that a massive amount of damage hasn't been done, and probably will never be undone, to a lot of us in our 60's and over is pissing on my back and telling me it;'s raining.



It seems like the attitude of both parties is 'fuck you old people, here's your cola that is one-third of how much food and heating went up'.

Yeah, voting blue, but not happily; we need energy at the same price as 2015-2019, gasoline and diesel and electricity, then worry about climate change or whatever.


You can show me 5000 pages of statistics and data, I know what my bills look like and that is what matters, not how the data is massaged.