Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Quemado

(1,262 posts)
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 05:58 PM Jan 2020

Buy an EV, or, never buy another car?

Stanford economist Tony Seba predicts that by 2030, 95% of people won’t own a private car. https://cleantechnica.com/2017/05/12/tony-seba-2030-95-people-wont-private-car-automaker-death-spiral-coming/

I want to buy an EV because I want to drive a car that has no emissions. Yes, I am aware of the various factors that make EVs not totally environmentally friendly, so, please, do not go there.

Another negative factor about EVs is their cost. I am able to purchase an EV for up to $60K, but, I don't want to make the purchase if the cost of using ride-sharing companies with self-driving EVs is less than ownership.

My current vehicles: a 2018 hybrid and a 2012 ICE car. Both cars are in good, if not great, shape with plenty of miles left in them, but they both use fossil fuel. If I buy an EV, the ICE car will be sold and the hybrid will be kept.

If you were me, what would you do? Buy an EV, or never buy another car and wait for ride sharing companies to offer self-driving EVs with costs less than ownership?

Thanks


5 votes, 0 passes | Time left: Unlimited
Buy an EV.
4 (80%)
Never buy another car.
1 (20%)
Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll
22 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Buy an EV, or, never buy another car? (Original Post) Quemado Jan 2020 OP
use the 2018 and save your money Fresh_Start Jan 2020 #1
That depends on what other options Phoenix61 Jan 2020 #2
The same for me exboyfil Jan 2020 #3
Are those the only two choices? PoindexterOglethorpe Jan 2020 #4
No, there are at least two other choices. Quemado Jan 2021 #20
I don't want to wait another ten years or more PoindexterOglethorpe Jan 2021 #22
I'm thinking about buying a used EV kimbutgar Jan 2020 #5
I was considering a hybrid for my next car a Toyota RAV4. The ICE RAV4 gets 38 MPG doc03 Jan 2020 #6
Give the market time to sort out.. Mopar151 Jan 2020 #7
My husband often says this Freddie Jan 2020 #8
I read that GHG emissions to build a car (either EV or ICE) are about the same as what an ICE car progree Jan 2020 #9
Even in regions with mostly a coal powered grid Miguelito Loveless Jun 2020 #11
I'm trying not to buy another car at all, because the GHG emissions to build a car are about half progree Jun 2020 #12
Then I would recommend a used EV Miguelito Loveless Jun 2020 #13
I'm struggling with the used car thing, I feel even if I buy it used, I am still responsible progree Jun 2020 #14
All valid points, and I would like to make plain Miguelito Loveless Jun 2020 #15
If I buy, it will be used, and I'll certainly look at EV's. However, the homeowner association progree Jun 2020 #16
If we get the current troll out of office Miguelito Loveless Jun 2020 #17
Yeah, uh, I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for those robotaxis Calculating Jan 2020 #10
Agreed, but with one nitpick Miguelito Loveless Jun 2020 #18
I'm sold on EV's mac2766 Jan 2021 #19
OP here: My wife and I ordered a Tesla Model Y. Quemado Jan 2021 #21

Phoenix61

(17,704 posts)
2. That depends on what other options
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 06:17 PM
Jan 2020

are available in your area. There is, for all intents and purposes, no public transport where I live so going carless is not an option.

exboyfil

(18,017 posts)
3. The same for me
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 06:36 PM
Jan 2020

My 2002 Cavalier just died (I am mourning its loss). My daughter, who had been driving my Cavalier, went out and bought a $20K+ used car (I cannot even fathom it), but she has to have something reliable and that can handle the snow because she is a nurse and just can't call in. She has been working for two years driving my car and living at home so it is not an unreasonable purchase.

Right now my wife and I are sharing a 2009 HHR. My mom wants to help me buy a car (she doesn't have the money for that), and my son in law is pushing me to get a newer car.

If I could go without a car, I would happily do it. I think I can manage getting to work by walking when the snow and ice finally go away, but right now my wife is bringing me to work (about four miles). We started doing it when I broke my foot, and my daughter started driving my car. It works for us.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(26,773 posts)
4. Are those the only two choices?
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 06:45 PM
Jan 2020

For me, until an EV has the range of a gas vehicle, and can be recharged as quickly as I can fill up a gas tank, I won't be buying one. No doubt those things will eventually come about, although given my current age (71) I may have stopped driving by then. Perhaps I will some day relocate to a city with much better public transportation, or move to an independent/assisted living place and be driven everywhere.

Meanwhile, I take several long driving trips every year, which is why I need the range and ease of refill of a gas car. There's no need to own two cars. Oh, and I cannot even begin to imagine paying $30k for a vehicle, let alone double that. So until they come down in price to that of, say, a second hand Honda, I (and a lot of other people) won't be even considering an EV.

My current car is a 2017 Honda Fit, which I purchased September, 2019. It replaced a 2004 Honda Civic I'd owned since 2007, so I do tend to keep cars a long time.

Quemado

(1,262 posts)
20. No, there are at least two other choices.
Sun Jan 31, 2021, 12:00 PM
Jan 2021

1. Using robotaxis. Unfortunately, this might not be a reality for a few more years.

2. Live in an area with short walking distances to shops and stores and places of employment, and excellent public transportation, where car ownership is not necessary.

Perhaps in 2031, after owning the Fit for 12 years, there will be EVs under $30k that can re-charge in 10 minutes and can go 500 miles on a single charge.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(26,773 posts)
22. I don't want to wait another ten years or more
Sun Jan 31, 2021, 01:11 PM
Jan 2021

for the EV that's under $30k (which is still about $10k more than I've ever paid for a car), recharges in 10 minutes, and can go 500 miles on a single charge. While I'm currently not making long drives, they will be happening again much sooner than 2031.

At an earlier time in my life I was without a car for seven years, and only finally got one when I wanted to return to school and the logistics of taking public transportation just wouldn't work.

I am constantly astonished at how much money people think is necessary to spend on a car. $30k? Really?

kimbutgar

(23,460 posts)
5. I'm thinking about buying a used EV
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 06:50 PM
Jan 2020

Was told you can get great deals on older models. 2017 fiat for under $10,000

doc03

(36,813 posts)
6. I was considering a hybrid for my next car a Toyota RAV4. The ICE RAV4 gets 38 MPG
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 07:05 PM
Jan 2020

highway and the Hybrid RAV4 gets 41MPG highway. I drive about 12000 miles per year so at $2.50 a gallon for gas I
would save $58 a year in gas. But Ohio just implemented a $100 a year tax on hybrid vehicles so it would cost me $42 more a year
for the hybrid not including the $1500 to $2000 extra I would pay for the hybrid. In addition hybrids all have a CVT transmission instead of gears. The CVTs have a lower towing limit, that tells me they are not built for hill country.

Mopar151

(10,185 posts)
7. Give the market time to sort out..
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 08:38 PM
Jan 2020

Even a couple years, will mean lower prices and better cars, as some of the "majors" (i.e. VW) are introducing new product lines of EV's.

The Tesla model of customer service, is very similar to modern farm or construction equipment - ONLY THE FACTORY CAN TOUCH IT - the owner has no "right to repair". According to said factory.... I'd try to stay off that anthill, myself.

Freddie

(9,725 posts)
8. My husband often says this
Sun Jan 26, 2020, 09:13 PM
Jan 2020

In a few years there will be Uber and other such services everywhere and not many people will have cars. I disagree. We live in a pretty spread-apart exurb, there is nothing within walking distance and absolutely no public transportation. We’re used to getting in our cars for *everything* when we want to, not waiting for a ride. Maybe that will be true in cities and closer suburbs but not out here.

progree

(11,463 posts)
9. I read that GHG emissions to build a car (either EV or ICE) are about the same as what an ICE car
Mon Jan 27, 2020, 05:35 AM
Jan 2020

emits driving an average amount over the car's lifetime. So if you can figure out how to do without a car, that would be a big deal for the environment (though if you use taxis or Ubers one has to figure that the car use per trip in miles is as much as double what it would be if you had a car -- because the Uber driver has to drive to your place, and then when done with you, drive to its next pickup point, and I read that about 1/2 of an Uber driver's mileage is other than carrying a customer. Or was it 60%?

On most U.S. electric grids, an E.V. is not much cleaner as far as GHG emissions than an ICE car, given the low 30-40% efficiency of the electric power plants, and that the load-following plants on an electric power system are mostly fossil fueled. But that will change with time, but right now EV's are not that much cleaner when all that -- and transmission line losses from the power plant to where you charge your car -- are considered.

But if you charge mostly overnight, and are on a grid with a sizable amount of wind energy, I think the picture is much improved because a lot of wind is dumped during low-load nighttime hours by utilities -- and by charging at night, that's that much less wind energy that is dumped. An environmental freebie.

During higher-load daytime hours, the wind energy is used to the maximum of its capacity, likewise solar; and any increment of the utility's system load (such as caused by charging a car) will come from fossil-fueled plants. (I worked in the planning and the system operations departments of an electric utility).

Miguelito Loveless

(4,679 posts)
11. Even in regions with mostly a coal powered grid
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 02:08 PM
Jun 2020

an EV has longer lifetime emissions than an ICE. That said, the grid is getting greener over time, as coal plants are being retired at an accelerating rate. We used to have a Leaf and a Volt. We would rotate cars leaving one at home to charge during the day using our solar array, taking the other one to work. The Volt was our "distance" car, which we sued when we went on vacation or business trips. We went from burning 800+ gallons a year with two ICE cars, to 48 gallons with the Leaf/Volt. In 2018 we replaced the Volt with a Model 3, and have not burnt a drop of gasoline since.

progree

(11,463 posts)
12. I'm trying not to buy another car at all, because the GHG emissions to build a car are about half
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 02:21 PM
Jun 2020

of what an ICE car burns in fuel being driven over its lifetime. Whether the car is an EV or an ICE.

If this is true, an EV on a perfectly clean grid would still be half as bad as an ICE over the full lifecycle that includes producing the materials to build the car, and building the car). Any grid dirtiness adds to that 50%. (And grids will always be somewhat dirty -- even 100% solar + wind + batteries require a substantial amount of GHG to construct.)

I don't say don't buy an EV -- if the choice is between an EV and an ICE -- a reduction of up to 50% over the full lifecycle compared to an ICE is obviously better than no reduction at all.

Miguelito Loveless

(4,679 posts)
13. Then I would recommend a used EV
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 02:36 PM
Jun 2020

Last edited Wed Jun 17, 2020, 04:05 PM - Edit history (1)

as the carbon cost is already there, so you are not creating demand for a "new" vehicle.

I would also point out that EVs are on track to have much longer road life, since they have several orders of magnitude fewer moving parts. Electric motors can easily last up to 500K miles before failure, and battery packs are good for 80% capacity at 200K miles (there are some exception in early model Leaves (2011-2014).

After the battery pack is no longer suitable for an EV, it can have another decade's reuse powering a house, or for grid storage. So, you would have to amortize the carbon footprint over that time as well. After than, it can be recycled to recover graphite, cobalt, copper, manganese, aluminum and lithium.

Solar PVs do require GHG to create, but once created last 25+ years producing up to 80% of their rated capacity (they lose 1%-2% their first year, then about 0.5% a year thereafter. Also, there are tech upgrades in the work which will mean increased efficiency, longer life with lower degradation, and greener power source as manufacturing facilities begin using their own product. A prototype wind turbine made of layered interlocking wood is being set up in Sweden, and if successful, would dramatically lower the energy used to build and transport them.

progree

(11,463 posts)
14. I'm struggling with the used car thing, I feel even if I buy it used, I am still responsible
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 03:09 PM
Jun 2020

for part of the construction emissions. Since virtually all cars are run until they are essentially worthless, whether thay have one owner or multiple owners. I just don't think I can put all the construction emissions on the first owner, and feel guiltless because I wasn't the original purchaser. By being a second or third owner, I'm part of what makes a car valuable to the first owner, because (s)he can then sell it to someone else after the "newness" wears off. It's all part of a chain or market that 2nd and 3rd buyers make possible.

One thing for sure, I won't be buying an EV. A year or two ago, the economics was that cost wise, including gasoline or electricity, and including maintenance (where yes, ICE costs more to maintain than EV), it was economically break even only if driven like 15,000 miles/year or more for the car's lifetime in order to break even with the higher purchase cost.

I drive less than 1,000 miles/year. I know that's pathetic, I know that's not "real man", I know it proves I don't have a life and all that. But it is what it is. I really believe we have to start living way differently if we're going to have a snowball's chance in hell of arresting global warming. I know that makes me sick, nut, whacko, flake, kook, and ding-dong. But it is what it is.

Anyway unless I see different numbers than I've seen, it would cost way more for me to buy an EV than it would save in "fuel" and operating costs. I think that extra money would be better spent in other directions. For example, I gave my farm away to Population Connection (full disclosure: in exchange for a charitable gift annuity, but I still figure it was a net $125,000 gift even considering the present value of the annuity plus the tax savings and no selling costs). IOW, I'm willing to spend money to save the planet, I just don't think buying an EV is the most effective per dollar way to do it for me.

Edited to add: I also live in a townhome association that is about as green as Exxon. They aren't going to rewire our garages to support charging plug-in hybrids or EVs, and individual owners doing that isn't feasible, so they say. And it would be a huge huge huge huge multi-year project to sell this place and move, and I'm just not going to do that.

Or I would have to fight with the homeowner association for years and years with little chance of success. One thing about homeowner associations is that they are just about the most dictatorial governing entity that's ever been conceived.

Miguelito Loveless

(4,679 posts)
15. All valid points, and I would like to make plain
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 03:35 PM
Jun 2020

I understand and agree with the analysis. We bought used until recently, and then made sure that our cars went to folks in need of reliable and cheap transport afterwards. With ICE cars we were usually the 3rd owner, with EVs the 2nd. In the face of plummeting gas prices, the cost per mile is harder to make, though when you factor in maintenance EVs still come out ahead. My wife and I are older, have paid off our house, and are using some of our savings to pollute less. The ROI of what we have built, has probably gone from 7 years to 10 years with falling oil prices, but, a war in the ME could reverse those savings fast. However the GHG breakeven point is about 5 years for our EVs and our solar. Excess power we don't use during the day is powering multiple houses on my block. A neighbor down the street stopped by in January to ask me a bunch of questions about our panels. He installed his own array a month ago, so between us we are producing about 90-150kWh a day. Another neighbor has also been asking questions, so perhaps I've started something.

To us, it is about clean air, and freedom from gas stations (which are really quite smelly and grimy once you spend a few months away from them), and freedom from power outages (we are in tornado/hurricane country).

I would not think to impugn your masculinity or humanity because you only drive 1000 miles a year. I would point out though, that there are a number of used EVs, under $10K, that could handle such a light driving load.

progree

(11,463 posts)
16. If I buy, it will be used, and I'll certainly look at EV's. However, the homeowner association
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 03:43 PM
Jun 2020

makes that impossible until something changes. (My stuff on the homeowner's association was a late edit to my #14). So pricing EVs would be just for my curiosity.

That breakeven thing in #14 was based on $2.50/gallon gas.

Yes, I think electricity prices are more stable and more likely to be stable in the future than gasoline prices.

PV's aren't anywhere on the horizon for this homeowner's association either.

Miguelito Loveless

(4,679 posts)
17. If we get the current troll out of office
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 03:49 PM
Jun 2020

we (our renewable advocacy group) hope to get a law passed overriding HOA about solar and EVs.

All that said, if you get a chance, drive one. It actually makes driving fun again, like it was when you first get your license and will grab any excuse to drive anywhere fun.

Calculating

(2,996 posts)
10. Yeah, uh, I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for those robotaxis
Thu Jan 30, 2020, 03:10 PM
Jan 2020

Nor would I want to depend on Uber for everything. The self driving car thing is still in the infant stage, and nobody really knows when or if it will be ready for prime time. As for ev's, they actually emit more carbon than ice if you're not charging them with green energy. I wouldn't recommend them unless you have rooftop solar. Better to just drive a fuel efficient ice vehicle right now.

Miguelito Loveless

(4,679 posts)
18. Agreed, but with one nitpick
Wed Jun 17, 2020, 04:02 PM
Jun 2020

I am a huge EV fan, and robotaxis are WAY overhyped.

However, the Union of Concerned Scientists studied GHG emission from EVs for their entire life cycle, even factoring in different grid fuels, and EVs still pollute less.

https://evtool.ucsusa.org/

In my neck of the woods, using grid power means 104g/mile for my EV (an M3), versus 381 for an ICE car, and 194 for a plug-in hybrid.

As we use solar to charge it, our actual GHG emissions is probably under 10g/mile factoring in the life of the car and the PV panels.

 

mac2766

(658 posts)
19. I'm sold on EV's
Sun Jan 31, 2021, 11:04 AM
Jan 2021

We're driving a 2010 pickup and a 2016 SUV. Both ICE vehicles. I feel very confident that the truck is going to last me another 5 years or so... hopefully more. both cars have been paid off for quite some time. I hate pumping gas into my truck. As much as 50 bucks a week some weeks.

We've agreed that we will never buy an ICE vehicle again.

We have a 10kW solar system. When we go to the EV's I'll install another battery on my system for EV charging. I'm hopeful that EV to Grid is accepted by then. It would be very nice to be able to take advantage of the EVs battery when the sun goes down.

Quemado

(1,262 posts)
21. OP here: My wife and I ordered a Tesla Model Y.
Sun Jan 31, 2021, 12:09 PM
Jan 2021

Yes, I know, the car has a carbon footprint from its manufacture.

When charging from home, the car will draw electricity from a grid that gets its part of its power from coal. However, my electricity provider, as of 2019, gets 44% of its power from renewable sources. And the provider intends to phase out coal completely by 2042: https://www.pnm.com/energy-sources

2019 - 44% emissions free generation
2032 - 86% emissions free generation
2042 - 100% emissions free generation

I agree with the previous post about robotaxis in the future. I’m not holding my breath waiting for robotaxis. Eventually robotaxis will make their way into the transportation marketplace. The question is: what is the cost of using robotaxis vs the cost of owning a car? Would you want to use a robotaxi during a pandemic? Would the robotaxi be sanitized after each use? I think sanitizing a robotaxi after each use would significantly increases costs that would be passed along to the customer.

Latest Discussions»Support Forums»Frugal and Energy Efficient Living»Buy an EV, or, never buy ...