Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

question everything

(48,812 posts)
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 12:48 PM Jun 2022

I Rented an Electric Car for a Four-Day Road Trip. I Spent More Time Charging It Than I Did Sleeping

I thought it would be fun. That’s what I told my friend Mack when I asked her to drive with me from New Orleans to Chicago and back in an electric car. I’d made long road trips before, surviving popped tires, blown headlights and shredded wheel-well liners in my 2008 Volkswagen Jetta. I figured driving the brand-new Kia EV6 I’d rented would be a piece of cake. If, that is, the public-charging infrastructure cooperated. We wouldn’t be the first to test it. Given our battery range of up to 310 miles, I plotted a meticulous route, splitting our days into four chunks of roughly 7½-hours each. We’d need to charge once or twice each day and plug in near our hotel overnight. The PlugShare app—a user-generated map of public chargers—showed thousands of charging options between New Orleans and Chicago. But most were classified as Level 2, requiring around 8 hours for a full charge.

(snip)

Over four days, we spent $175 on charging. We estimated the equivalent cost for gas in a Kia Forte would have been $275, based on the AAA average national gas price for May 19. That $100 savings cost us many hours in waiting time. But that’s not the whole story. New Orleans, our starting point, has exactly zero fast chargers, according to PlugShare. As we set out, one of the closest is at a Harley-Davidson dealership in Slidell, La., about 40 minutes away. So we use our Monday-morning breakfast stop to top off there on the way out of town.

(snip)

After the Birmingham suburbs, our journey takes us along nightmarish, dark mountain roads. We stop for snacks at a gas station featuring a giant chicken in a chef’s costume. We lean heavily on cruise control, which helps conserve battery life by reducing inadvertent acceleration and deceleration. We are beat when we finally stumble into our Nashville hotel at 12:30 a.m. To get back on schedule, we are up and out early, amid pouring rain, writing the previous day off as a warm-up, an electric-car hazing. For the most part, we are right. Thanks to vastly better charging infrastructure on this leg, all our stops last less than an hour.

(snip)

Leaving Chicago after a full night of sleep... As intense wind and rain whip around us, the car cautions, “Conditions have not been met” for its cruise-control system. Soon the battery starts bleeding life. What began as a 100-mile cushion between Chicago and our planned first stop in Effingham, Ill., has fallen to 30... We feel defeated pulling into a Nissan Mazda dealership in Mattoon, Ill. “How long could it possibly take to charge the 30 miles we need to make it to the next fast station?” I wonder. Three hours. It takes 3 hours. I begin to lose my mind as I set out in search of gas-station doughnuts, the wind driving sheets of rain into my face.

(snip)

Back on the road, we can’t even make it 200 miles on a full charge en route to Miner, Mo. Clearly, tornado warnings and electric cars don’t mix. The car’s highway range actually seems worse than its range in cities. Indeed, highway driving doesn’t benefit as much from the car’s regenerative-braking technology—which uses energy generated in slowing down to help a car recharge its battery—Kia spokesman James Bell tells me later. He suspects our car is the less-expensive EV6 model with a range not of 310 miles, as listed on Turo, but 250. He says he can’t be sure what model we were driving without physically inspecting the car.

(snip)

To save power, we turn off the car’s cooling system and the radio, unplug our phones and lower the windshield wipers to the lowest possible setting while still being able to see. Three miles away from the station, we have one mile of estimated range. “Charge, Urgently!” the dashboard urges. “We know!” we respond. At zero miles, we fly screeching into a gas-station parking lot. A trash can goes flying and lands with a clatter to greet us. Dinner is beef jerky, our plans to dine at a kitschy beauty shop-turned-restaurant in Memphis long gone.

(snip)

The following week, I fill up my Jetta at a local Shell station. Gas is up to $4.08 a gallon. I inhale deeply. Fumes never smelled so sweet.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/i-rented-an-electric-car-for-a-four-day-road-trip-i-spent-more-time-charging-it-than-i-did-sleeping-11654268401 (subscription)

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I Rented an Electric Car for a Four-Day Road Trip. I Spent More Time Charging It Than I Did Sleeping (Original Post) question everything Jun 2022 OP
So, basically, cilla4progress Jun 2022 #1
Certainly in many parts of the country question everything Jun 2022 #2
That was one of provisions in the BBB bill that... brush Jun 2022 #7
That's why I think hybrids are a better choice for now. LisaM Jun 2022 #3
Good to know, LisaM cilla4progress Jun 2022 #4
Yes we bought a used Honda Civic from a friend. LisaM Jun 2022 #6
Hybrids help a lot toward the global warming issue. KS Toronado Jun 2022 #5
Totally agree. I had a Prius V and "only" got 38 mpg... If I had it to do over again I would get mitch96 Jun 2022 #14
WSJ Casady1 Jun 2022 #8
was hoping someone noticed that rurallib Jun 2022 #9
See my reply, below. question everything Jun 2022 #11
Did you know that Biden published an op-ed last week in the WSJ? question everything Jun 2022 #10
There are much more accurate reviews Casady1 Jun 2022 #13
I was not interested in investigating EVs. I found this report amusing question everything Jun 2022 #15
Do your Casady1 Jun 2022 #16
No, I don't. No one does when just posting a story with the source question everything Jun 2022 #18
I like to provide Casady1 Jun 2022 #19
When all else fail, go personal. End of discussion question everything Jun 2022 #20
Wall streets have no street smarts. pwb Jun 2022 #12
+1...A lot of planning is required for a four-day trip in an EV Shermann Jun 2022 #21
charging costs money? I thought EV just plugged in for free Demovictory9 Jun 2022 #17

brush

(57,556 posts)
7. That was one of provisions in the BBB bill that...
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 01:26 PM
Jun 2022

that the reublicans and Manchin/Sinema defeated.

I think it's best to hold off on buy and EV for now, unless it's just for city driving.

LisaM

(28,604 posts)
3. That's why I think hybrids are a better choice for now.
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 12:55 PM
Jun 2022

If you're stranded in an EV and someone has to come tow you, that defeats the whole purpose.

We get great mileage in our hybrid and I don't even pay attention to the price of gas (I'm not trying to downplay that high gas prices are a huge problem for a lot of people, but we don't use half the gas that a lot of people do).

LisaM

(28,604 posts)
6. Yes we bought a used Honda Civic from a friend.
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 01:18 PM
Jun 2022

If I had bought new I would likely have gone with an American brand, but it's done well for us. Mileage is over 53 mpg. And we don't have range anxiety.

mitch96

(14,658 posts)
14. Totally agree. I had a Prius V and "only" got 38 mpg... If I had it to do over again I would get
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 04:10 PM
Jun 2022

a plug in hybrid. 40 miles on "E" juice is about what I would need for around town stuff.
Plug it in for the evening and then repeat the next day. Long trip? you have a gas engine to go the distance.
Until you can go 300 miles and an electric "fill" in the same time a gas engine can do it, it's gonna be a long road for pure electric. YMMV
m

question everything

(48,812 posts)
11. See my reply, below.
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 02:26 PM
Jun 2022

And.. you may want to open your mind. Just a little?

Would you throw away a recent WSJ poll how most support abortion?

https://www.democraticunderground.com/1016324147

question everything

(48,812 posts)
10. Did you know that Biden published an op-ed last week in the WSJ?
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 02:24 PM
Jun 2022

That Sander? Sherrod Brown?

Very unfortunate to find on these pages limited vision of real reports.


 

Casady1

(2,133 posts)
13. There are much more accurate reviews
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 04:06 PM
Jun 2022

of driving long distance with an EV on youtube. This guy tries many types and discusses driving long distance with an EV. By the way your "name" should be used when using the WSJ for an accurate review of driving an EV long distance.

https://www.youtube.com/c/OutofSpecReviews/videos

question everything

(48,812 posts)
15. I was not interested in investigating EVs. I found this report amusing
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 05:28 PM
Jun 2022

and thought of sharing it here. Perhaps I should have posted in the Lounge where lighter minds reside.

question everything

(48,812 posts)
18. No, I don't. No one does when just posting a story with the source
Sat Jun 4, 2022, 07:34 PM
Jun 2022

It is up to you, if so desire, to rebut the facts. But too many here, too lazy to rebut just say Oh, the WSJ not worth reading.

And this is supposed to be a place of independent and critical thinking. Obviously not by everyone.

Shermann

(8,647 posts)
21. +1...A lot of planning is required for a four-day trip in an EV
Sun Jun 5, 2022, 12:03 PM
Jun 2022

If there aren't enough fast chargers along the route, your trip is going to suck. If you take the trip to that destination anyways, that outcome shouldn't be a surprise.

In fairness, there were some unforeseeable events which exacerbated the situation.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Automobile Enthusiasts»I Rented an Electric Car ...