Religion
Related: About this forumWho determines what is sin?
Who gives anyone the right to condemn the actions of another if those actions are not going to cause harm to a third party? Think about it. In some cultures, a woman flashing an ankle is sinful, elsewhere albinos are from the devil. It is sinful to drink in some cultures, sinful to get an education if you are a girl in others. In some places it is sinful to choose you own spouse, and in others it is sinful to love someone of the same sex.
So, let me ask you the question: Who are we to determine what is sinful and what is not? We would all agree, I am sure, that someone who believes it is sinful for a woman not to cover her face needs to re-examine his/hers values? However, every day we hold people to a standard that does not compute.
Is someone harming you by their actions? Yes or No? If No, how do you come to the decision that that action is sinful? Surely that decision should be left to a higher power than us mere mortals? And even if you do decide that by your individual moral code the action of another is sinful what is it that allows people to try an impose that belief on the wider community? Surely it is sinful to try and do that?
PJMcK
(22,892 posts)Work hard. Be nice.
NRaleighLiberal
(60,509 posts)uriel1972
(4,261 posts)If we don't call things sinful how can we control other people's behaviour if we want to?
oh where, oh where is that sarcasm taggie... (sarcasm)
packman
(16,296 posts)Simple - works in ANY religion, any cult
Do no harm
Major Nikon
(36,900 posts)So theres no disputing it.
Meanwhile the bible has nothing bad to say about child rape, spousal abuse, slavery, or polygamy. Funny how that works.
edhopper
(34,880 posts)but the question then is who determines what God is?
NeoGreen
(4,033 posts)...I am neither, sin dosen't apply.
Iggo
(48,286 posts)Iggo
(48,286 posts)guillaumeb
(42,649 posts)Who determines what constitutes a crime?
The legal authorities in a society.
Does every society have the right to create a legal code defining unlawful behavior?
uriel1972
(4,261 posts)guillaumeb
(42,649 posts)your just making that up.
It's used in jargon for vice and "sin taxes" but there is no legal equivalence in general.
guillaumeb
(42,649 posts)Call it crime, or vice, or sin. It is a violation of group norms.
edhopper
(34,880 posts)show me where the legal codes talk about sin?
There are so many things considered sin by the religious that are perfectly legal.
Sin is a religious term, specifically Christian.