Passover and the Constitution
By William A. Galston (the non conservative columnist of the WSJ)
(snip)
This year, as I prepare for the arrival of my extended family, something new has struck me. The focus of this Jewish holiday, more than any other, is freedom. Indeed, Passover is called the “festival of freedom.” But the celebration of the holiday is called the Seder, which is Hebrew for “order.” We are required not only to do the right things but to do them in the right sequence. Our conversation always returns to what we must do and when we must do it.
This raises a classic issue—the relationship between order and freedom. Some schools of thought view them as antitheses—the more order, the less freedom, and vice versa. Libertarians want to minimize government constraints to maximize liberty. Anarchists carry this thesis to its inevitable, and self-refuting, conclusion. In the Jewish tradition, by contrast, order makes freedom possible. In the absence of a framework—a law, a text, a tradition—we cannot act freely. Not only are we plunged into debilitating doubt, but our decisions also collide with those of others. The actions of others rarely coordinate harmoniously with our own. And when they don’t, all are prevented from acting as they choose. Without a framework of social order, every individual can seek freedom, but none can achieve it.
(snip)
The covenant at Sinai isn’t the same as what the modern philosophical tradition calls a “social contract,” but there is a resemblance. The idea of public endorsement—the consent of the people—is common to both. The Declaration of Independence was drafted by a handful of men, but it was accepted by most of the delegates gathered in Philadelphia and was praised when it was read to George Washington’s troops a few days later. It was, as Thomas Jefferson wrote a year before he died on the 50th anniversary of the Declaration’s signing, not an original argument but an “expression of the American mind.” The consensual basis of the Constitution is even clearer: If it had not been ratified by special constitutional assemblies in the states, it would have been a piece of parchment with no authority.
(snip)
Today, the erosion of this shared framework has deepened political divisions. Some “national conservatives” take the position that the Declaration of Independence set us on the path to a failed liberal individualism, while others claim that its abstract principles have nothing to do with the Constitution, which represents the continuation of the conservative British tradition. On the left, the Nation’s Elie Mystal declares that “The Constitution is kind of trash. . . . It was written by slavers and colonists, and white people who were willing to make deals with slavers and colonists.” No doubt many Americans agree with him.
As the consensual framework that gives order to American liberty frays, we become less secure in the exercise of liberty. We fear that others plot to take it away, and we squander our energy fighting one another rather than working to promote the common good. It is not only the Jews who need an annual festival of freedom to remind them what makes liberty possible. We all do, before the withdrawal of consent from the sources of our order undermines the freedom we cherish.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/passover-and-the-constitution-order-freedom-jewish-holiday-seder-tradition-framework-11649779474 (subscription)
= new reply since forum marked as read
