Why I Am Resigning as a Brown Trustee - Joseph Edelman, WSJ

[question everything]

As a member of the Brown University board of trustees, I disagree with the upcoming divestment vote on Israel. I am concerned about what Brown’s willingness to hold such a vote suggests about the university’s attitude toward rising antisemitism on campus and a growing political movement that seeks the destruction of the state of Israel.

I find it morally reprehensible that holding a divestment vote was even considered, much less that it will be held—especially in the wake of the deadliest assault on the Jewish people since the Holocaust. On Oct. 7, 2023, Israel was invaded and brutally attacked by Palestinian terrorists. Twelve hundred innocent people were slaughtered, some of them raped and burned alive, and more than 250 were abducted to Gaza and held as hostages. Israel, like all nations, has a moral duty to defend its citizens from terrorist attacks, and that is exactly what it has been doing. It is revealing that of all the countries in the world, only Israel is expected to restrain itself because of the civilian lives that will tragically be lost in war.

I don’t wish to imply that any real principles informed Brown’s decision to hold a divestment vote: It was made not based on facts or values but based on weakness toward student activists. The university leadership has for some reason chosen to reward, rather than punish, the activists for disrupting campus life, breaking school rules, and promoting violence and antisemitism at Brown.

(snip)

It’s no coincidence that leading pro-boycott groups have ties to terrorist organizations that seek the annihilation of the Jewish people. In the end, that is the goal of the BDS movement, and I can’t accept the treatment of a hate movement as legitimate and deserving of a hearing. Brown’s policy of appeasement won’t work. It’s a capitulation to the very hatred that led to the Holocaust and the unspeakable horrors of Oct. 7.

How can Brown lend credence to these antisemitic voices, who notably began protesting in support of violence against Jews before Israel had even responded to the Oct. 7 attack? It’s as if the Brown board has agreed to vote on whether Israel has a right to defend itself, whether Israel has a right to exist, and even whether Jews have a right to exist.

More..

https://www.wsj.com/opinion/why-i-am-resigning-as-a-brown-trustee-gaza-antisemitism-protesters-1479f433?st=36pmn5xchwg8ei4&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink

(free)

Mr. Edelman is CEO of Perceptive Advisors. This is adapted from his letter of resignation as a Brown trustee, a position he has held since 2019.

[Mark.b2]

1. We need more people like Mr. Edelman...

Many face having no choice, and still few make the right call.

[JoetheShow]

2. Mr Edelman uses the standard propaganda technique of equating any critism of Israel as antisemitism. It is not.

I once strongly supported Israel. The image of plucky Israel trying to survive in a sea of Arabs desperately trying to push them into the sea appealed to my sympathy for the underdog. But somewhere along the way, little by little, Israel lost my sympathy. Surviving became an excuse for domination and slaughter. The oppressed became the oppressors. Voicing opposition to the massive killing in Gaza is not antisemitism, just as supporting Israels right to live peacefully does not mean I oppose Islam. We need to get beyond the black and white thinking and admit that Israel and Palestine need peace and security.