AP: 14 March 2017

[NeoGreen]

http://theatheistpig.com/index.php/comic/enough-faith/




Grammar Police, shouldn't it have been written as "what you need are..." and not "is"?

[Volstagg]

1. I would agree it should be "are"

but I love Atheist Pig something crazy so I'll forgive him.

[NeoGreen]

2. Me too (nt)

[mountain grammy]

3. Ignorance is bliss until it smacks you right in the face.

[SwissTony]

4. I would argue that "is" is appropriate

because what Pig is doing is presenting a list of things needed. A list is singular even though its contents are plural. Had Pig said "The things you need...", then we've gone onto plural.

Having said that, I have to inform you that my major was mathematics.

[NeoGreen]

5. Well in that case...

...I would humbly suggest there is a missing colon, and a proper sentence would read:

"What you need is: critical thinking skills, the desire for knowledge, a dose of healthy skepticism, and a willingness to always question the answers."


Emphasis added because...REASONS! (a Borderlands 2 reference)


Added for full disclosure: My major was neither Math nor Grammar.

[SwissTony]

6. I would disagree. I'd never say...

"I'm going to the supermarket to get: bread, cheese, coffee and jam." I've never seen anyone else use such a construction.

Sorry, I don't get the Borderlands reference (not much of a television(??) watcher.

Added for even fuller disclosure: I was kicked out of the Boy Scouts as a kid.

[NeoGreen]

9. I guess we're just separated by denominational differences...

...the "Is-a-listers" and "Are-wellians".



Fullest disclosure: I never was a comedian either.

More fullest disclosure: Borderlands 2 isn't even a TV show, it is merely a video game:

[rurallib]

7. Thank you so much for introducing me to the atheist pig

I am learning so much over here.

[NeoGreen]

10. My pleasure...

...enjoy

[beam me up scottie]

8. The pig gets it.