Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
Wed Mar 7, 2012, 09:54 AM Mar 2012

KONY 2012

http://www.democraticunderground.com/1002395235

I saw this plastered all over Youtube late last night and
by this morning it's been successfully spread to the far
corners of the Internet in a single day thanks to a concerted
Twitter campaign by activists, h?cktivists, and celebrities.

At first I wondered if it was a joke, but it's not:



They are asking people to retweet:

http://www.kony2012.com/sharefilm/ Joseph Kony is the world’s worst war
criminal. This film explains what he’s done and how to stop him #KONY2012


See thread for video link: http://www.democraticunderground.com/1002395235


[font color="white"]......[/font]PONY VS. KONY
41 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
KONY 2012 (Original Post) Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 OP
So, am I the only one seeing this? Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #1
K and R... sagetea Mar 2012 #2
I saw in on Facebook. Nt TBF Mar 2012 #3
Me too... ellisonz Mar 2012 #4
Did you see the video? Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #5
Didn't bother... ellisonz Mar 2012 #6
It's a deliberate attempt to educate people on the Internet. The video itself makes clear Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #7
I find it really hard to take internet memes all that serious... ellisonz Mar 2012 #8
You think they didn't bother to watch the video and are just retagging it? Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #9
People love memes. ellisonz Mar 2012 #10
I'm not sure you agree with the premise Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #11
Just saw the interview with the guy on Lawrence O'Donnell... ellisonz Mar 2012 #12
Ironically, he's being criticised for advocating a military solution Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #13
The whole region is a mess... ellisonz Mar 2012 #17
I supported ending Gaddafi's blood bath as well. UnrepentantLiberal Mar 2012 #26
BBC Reports,2011! "US to send troops to Uganda to help fight LRA rebels" KoKo Mar 2012 #29
Oh I know that we're there... ellisonz Mar 2012 #33
Thanks... KoKo Mar 2012 #37
TheWraith? UnrepentantLiberal Mar 2012 #41
Here's an article on it. UnrepentantLiberal Mar 2012 #24
Max Keiser Reports mentioned the Video KoKo Mar 2012 #14
The problem is, the only reason for the video is to make people aware of Kony and the LRA. Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #15
Leo...after I replied to you, I found this. KoKo Mar 2012 #16
Hmm, I am stuck between you and ellisonz on this. Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #18
Uh Oh....I just read ellisonz's post...just getting back here... KoKo Mar 2012 #19
Watch the Max Keiser............Gotta Go... KoKo Mar 2012 #20
Our teachers and students have been all over this. NYC_SKP Mar 2012 #21
What's the feedback you've been getting? KoKo Mar 2012 #22
I've been away but when I came back a speaker had visited the school and made a presentation... NYC_SKP Mar 2012 #23
A Letter From Uganda on #Kony2012--From "Truth Dig" (Good Read) KoKo Mar 2012 #25
Yeah, I agree with the first part, but the author is biased in the last sentence Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #27
Leo...she goes on in the article about the "tribal differences..North of Nile, South of Nile KoKo Mar 2012 #28
BTW: I just posted the BBC article ("Capture or Kill") in #29 to Ellinsonz... KoKo Mar 2012 #30
Thanks KoKo. I hope she understands it's national, not tribal Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #31
Who knows the truth of it. Probably too complicated. KoKo Mar 2012 #32
KoKo, here's a book everyone must read: The Scramble For Africa by Pakenham Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #34
Thanks for info...btw: KoKo Mar 2012 #35
It's a good book to have in trade paperback Leopolds Ghost Mar 2012 #36
Turnouts the filmaker is a creep: ellisonz Mar 2012 #38
Yeah...that was a Bizarre report about him... Hope it doesn't discourage KoKo Mar 2012 #39
Good points. ellisonz Mar 2012 #40

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
1. So, am I the only one seeing this?
Wed Mar 7, 2012, 10:35 AM
Mar 2012

Not much response on GD.

Here's another thread: http://www.democraticunderground.com/1002394758

Also, there's an argument on one of the forums it was posted on, Reddit, with
some folks claiming that the effort itself is great but that the nonprofit running
it isn't the best place to send $$$ to. Of course I don't normally put much stake
in Reddit:

http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/ql4oi/kony_2012/

Fortunately this April 20 effort is not about money, or is it?
They are apparently asking for an ongoing subscription in order to receive
a box with the materials for plastering posters etc. The whole "thousands
of boxes full of posters" idea makes me think of when I saw the movie
V for Vendetta and wondered how he got people to arrange shipping all
those outfits... you'd think it'd be more efficient to ask people to create
or make copies of their own posters for A20, like Occupy did.

sagetea

(1,439 posts)
2. K and R...
Wed Mar 7, 2012, 10:58 AM
Mar 2012

Like you, this one has moved me! It really needs to get out there.

Thank You, for putting it out there!

Ho,

Sage

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
5. Did you see the video?
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 01:56 PM
Mar 2012

What's y'all's opinions on the allegations made on Reddit that it's a forced meme to raise money for this guy's nonprofit and not a legitimately noncommercial op.

That being said the video is powerful.

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
6. Didn't bother...
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 01:59 PM
Mar 2012

I am laughing my ass off at the whole meme though considering I knew about the LRA like a decade ago.

I wouldn't give money to any charity that's not thoroughly reputable - like the Red Cross, UNICEF or Amnesty International.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
7. It's a deliberate attempt to educate people on the Internet. The video itself makes clear
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 02:06 PM
Mar 2012

That it is a forced meme. It's a video chain letter whose only goal is to make Kony famous.

I admittedly had never heard the name of the actual guy in charge of the LRA before, though I knew about him of course.

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
8. I find it really hard to take internet memes all that serious...
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 02:08 PM
Mar 2012

Obama sent like 100 U.S. Army Rangers a few months ago to assist the government of Uganda in fighting the LRA.

Those celebrating this don't really care...they just think Kony sounds cool.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
9. You think they didn't bother to watch the video and are just retagging it?
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 02:14 PM
Mar 2012

That doesn't make sense... also, the group behind this campaign claims to be responsible for lobbying to get Obama to send the advisors.

Of course, the LRA is no longer in Uganda so they should be calling for African Union, not Ugandan troops, unless of course they see it as an Israeli style foreign intervention (like the ones that stopped Idi Amin and the Tutsi genocide.)

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
10. People love memes.
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 02:35 PM
Mar 2012

I haven't seen it, but I don't give internet memes that much respect.

The African Union is pretty dysfunctional. With Gaddafi gone hopefully it will get better.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
11. I'm not sure you agree with the premise
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 03:02 PM
Mar 2012

Last edited Thu Mar 8, 2012, 03:58 PM - Edit history (1)

The guy is a documentarian of some sort... he specifically did this to draw attention to the issue. It's a 30 minute short film.

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
12. Just saw the interview with the guy on Lawrence O'Donnell...
Thu Mar 8, 2012, 11:11 PM
Mar 2012

Last edited Fri Mar 9, 2012, 06:00 AM - Edit history (1)

...and as touching as it is that after so long people are finally maybe giving a shit about Africa for a moment. He's a little bit out of it if he thinks Joseph Kony and the LRA are going to surrender. This is going to require a military solution, and frankly, it should have been done long ago. It certainly is an interesting development in the use of social media...but I question whether it will have any long running effect on people's consciousness. Color me a cynic on human rights.

I FB shared it with this message:

Spreading this with two caveats (1) The interview with Luis Moreno-Ocampo, Chief Prosecutor for the International Criminal Court highlights the fact that the United States of America is not party to the Rome Statute because it fears prosecution of its own politicians and military personnel (2) The reality on the ground is much more complex than portrayed, the Lord's Resistance Army operates not just in Northern Uganda but in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the Central African Republic, and Southern Sudan. Cooperation between the disorganized security forces of these countries is non-existent. Without a greater commitment of US forces including substantially greater amounts of US forces the odds that Kony himself will be killed, much less captured are not very good. The Northeastern DRC in particular, where Kony likely is headquarted, has a patchwork of militia and criminal elements. An estimated 5.4 million people have died in war or of war related causes in the the DRC since 1996, and this is despite a decade long UN military mission (MONUC) with thousands of personnel. It's a mess.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
13. Ironically, he's being criticised for advocating a military solution
Fri Mar 9, 2012, 04:57 PM
Mar 2012

But the implication of his vid is that he wants Uganda to go in Israel-style and extraordinarily rendit Kony. (is that a word?)

When the new Tutsi-backed Rwandan government (the one everypony praises for ending the genocide) did this in the Congo to "go after" the Hutu militia genocidaires, the result was not that good.

Not good at all. Like, collapse of the Congolese government and 2 million dead not good.

If anything, though, Kony could be used as an excuse for the US to intervene in the Congo to stop the crimes against humanity there, INSTEAD of going after Ghaddafi in Libya. Kind of like spending money on transit instead of roads, whoops! Can't do it, we've already done the latter so our priorities are set!

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
17. The whole region is a mess...
Tue Mar 13, 2012, 01:07 PM
Mar 2012

...I think it's pretty clear the United States does not care to intervene in sub-Saharan Africa (Remember 1994).

I remain a fervent internationalist and humanitarian who does believe that armed intervention is required - I don't have the luxury of pretending that things will just be better off if the world stays out of it - my mother's family made it through the Holocaust in Poland. If some wish to characterize me as a militarist and imperialist for believing that international law can and should be enforced so be it. But I supported our intervention in Libya and I would support greater intervention in the DRC - you must remember that the UN already has peacekeepers there, but they are not engaged in a military mission to suppress the militias. Joseph Kony should have been on the shit list more than a decade ago. I wish the United States would sign the Rome Statute and it puts money where its mouth is because having this sort of vague double standard is only causing confusion and is not supporting international law and human rights like we should be. I believe in the Truman Doctrine and I believe in the United Nations and the concurrent international conventions of genocide etc. I think we would see a lot less of this nonsense if we were as good as our words.

Gaddafi was scum and Libya and the world are better off without him. Gaddafi backed Idi Amin with Libyan troops, trained/financed Foday Sankoh and the RUF, backed the communists in Ethiopia, waged war against Chad and committed numerous atrocities against his own people. Fuck Gaddafi.

 

UnrepentantLiberal

(11,700 posts)
26. I supported ending Gaddafi's blood bath as well.
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 11:23 AM
Mar 2012

I don't think we can do much in the Congo. American troops will die but fighting in that region will continue. It's the heart of darkness.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
29. BBC Reports,2011! "US to send troops to Uganda to help fight LRA rebels"
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 05:28 PM
Mar 2012

ellisonz, this is my problem with what you say...why I have questions about this "Heart Tugging Video" and the rest..... We are Already there and Obama announced a "Kill or Capture" Mission.

As much as I find John McCain disgustingly duplicitous....his comment about Obama "ordering this" is exactly why I'm concerned. I didn't agree with Libya, either. But, I respect your opinion about this. I would hope for more discussion on it, even thought this doesn't seem like an OWS Topic...it's part of the root of our problems... The Military/Industrial/Media/Financial/Wall Street Complex. So...in a way it does fit...

Also, If I hear "Capture or Kill" from another American President...I'm gonna know that our Democracy is dead. I thought that ended with "Chimperor-in-Chief." What about BRINGING CRIMINALS TO JUSTICE.. JUSTICE ...TRIALS ...COURTS...NUREMBERG CONVENTIONS...

That's what my problem is with all of this. IMPERIAL KILLING... I hope you can try to understand my viewpoint.

Peace, regards...

-----------
FROM BBC, 2011!

US to send troops to Uganda to help fight LRA rebels

Africa
14 October 2011 Last updated at 19:17 ET

US President Barack Obama has said he is sending about 100 US soldiers to Uganda to help regional forces battle the notorious Lord's Resistance Army.

Although combat-equipped, the troops would be providing information and advice "to partner nation forces", Mr Obama wrote in a letter to US Congress.

A small group is already in Uganda, and the troops could later be deployed in other central African nations.


The LRA is blamed for mass murder, rape and kidnapping in the region.
'Kill or capture'

"I have authorised a small number of combat-equipped US forces to deploy to central Africa to provide assistance to regional forces that are working toward the removal of (LRA leader) Joseph Kony from the battlefield," Mr Obama wrote on Friday.

But he stressed that "although the US forces are combat-equipped... they will not themselves engage LRA forces unless necessary for self-defence".

Mr Obama did not provide any details about the deployment duration, but a US military spokesman later told the BBC that the "forces are prepared to stay as long as necessary to enable regional security forces to carry on independently".

The force will use hi-tech equipment to assist in what analysts say is a "kill or capture" policy, the BBC's Marcus George in Washington reports.


The deployment follows recent US legislation to help disarm the LRA and bring its leader to justice. The theory is, our correspondent adds, that without Joseph Kony, the movement will collapse from within.

Senator John McCain said Central Africa would be more stable if the threat of the LRA "under the sadistic leadership of Joseph Kony," would be "diminished".

But Mr McCain, a long-serving senator, former veteran and Mr Obama's opponent in the 2008 presidential election, expressed "regret" that the president did not consult with Congress on the decision to sent troops to Uganda.

"I remember how past military deployments intended to further worthy humanitarian goals, whether it was peace-keeping operations in Lebanon or Somalia, resulted in tragedies that we never intended or expected," Mr McCain said in a statement.]/b]

More of article at.........

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-15317684

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
33. Oh I know that we're there...
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 09:21 PM
Mar 2012

...but we're there very minimally. I understand and appreciate your position, but it's important to remember that Joseph Kony has been allowed to commit these crimes for so long because frankly the world does not give a damn. I would also point out that "imperial" has a very specific meaning and should not be used as a blanket term - countries conduct empire. Even though some argue that international organization is imperialist, it is my opinion that such claims are spurious. If the United States would sign the Rome Statute, it would not be the action of a single empire but of almost the entire world. Joseph Kony is #1 on the ICC wanted list and has been over a decade now. I don't approve of empire, but I do approve of internationalism.

I think it's worth remembering too that there are about 15,000 U.N. Peacekeepers in the DRC under MONUSCO that essentially have no authority and no mission. I would like to see a more coherent administration of international law such that the UN and the ICC work in tandem so that the ICC has punch and the UN has moral authority.

P.S. The SOP of this group is written as such as to while focus on OWS not discuss it exclusively, hence "share information." The only topics that are taboo are direct attacks on OWS itself.

P.P.S. I think you're a reasonable person and respect your opinion.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
37. Thanks...
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 04:24 PM
Mar 2012

we do have differences...but, we at least can discuss in civil way and share info.

"So far" this group is a model. But, then, I notice a hater had to be booted out. So...nothing is perfect. sigh..



KoKo

(84,711 posts)
14. Max Keiser Reports mentioned the Video
Tue Mar 13, 2012, 11:18 AM
Mar 2012

in today's report. He claims the video is a RW propaganda piece put together to get Obama to send troops in not to "save the people" but to make sure we get rights to Uganda's Oil and that we already have some troops in there but the LRA wants more and put this cute little boy out there to get sympathy. (He showed a small snip of video with the little boy)

It was in his segment about "The White Man's Burden" and how Oil is replacing gold as the world's currency and that's why the oil is so important to our financially imploding West which the Banksters have raided. Says we will be sending more troops into Africa to control it and he mentions Rudyard Kipling in coining the phrase "White Man's Burden."

I didn't see the Video you talked about and had no idea what KONY and the LRA were when I read your post. Since I didn't know ....I didn't reply.

But, if you watch RT then you know who Max Keiser is...so perhaps you will catch today's report about this.

If what he says is true and that it's right wingers pushing this video around on You Tube...it doesn't sound like a good thing to me. Although some might feel sympathetic if the YouTube is a tear jerker. I think I'll take Max's view over a viral video that makes people want to send troops in for more killing.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
15. The problem is, the only reason for the video is to make people aware of Kony and the LRA.
Tue Mar 13, 2012, 11:44 AM
Mar 2012

So when people who haven't seen the video say they don't know who the LRA is, and therefore aren't inclined to see the video because they are worried it's a RW plot, it makes me go



I mean, the major criticism of the video is that it wears its intention on its sleeve -- it says it's propaganda right out front and that the only purpose of the video is to make people aware of who Kony is (who's not in Uganda anyhow).

So while I think the intentions of the guy producing the video might be iffy, that's probably due to him being a stubborn minded character who is set in his ways about what the solution would be. But I for one, for instance, would rather have seen US send troops to Congo (where the LRA is) to stop the genocide there, NOT Libya, and Congo is loaded with natural resources.

Most of the people who supported our adventure to assassinate Ghadafi in Libya would line up to oppose going into Congo because the French own all the natural resources there and consider it their colony, which is why the US lets the genocide in the Congo (including the LRA) continue while we fund troops in Uganda and Rwanda (who helped initiate the violence in the Congo by invading that country, much as Nixon did when he invaded Cambodia). So we send troops to Libya and Uganda not the Congo where they might do some good.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
16. Leo...after I replied to you, I found this.
Tue Mar 13, 2012, 12:57 PM
Mar 2012
There's a video at site if you go to the link. These are comments by an activist in the area.

Can Kony 2012 Make a Difference for Ugandan Youth?

March 12, 2012 · By Emira Woods
The "Kony 2012" campaign went viral, while making a call for military to support for a failed regime in Uganda. Watch this discussion on social media and African politics in PBS NewsHour.

The "Stop Kony" campaign that's gone viral in recent days aims to spotlight the atrocities of warlord Joseph Kony in Uganda. Margaret Warner discussed the nonprofit Invisible Children's popular "Kony 2012" video and its ensuing criticism with the Institute for Policy Studies' Emira Woods and Porter Novelli's Dawn Arteaga.

"We have to keep in mind Joseph Kony came into power around the same time as Museveni, the president of Uganda, who has been around since the 1980s now.

And it was really a quest for political power couched in, again, Lord's Resistance Army, a lot of language around religion and around rights of people. But what we have seen is a real deterioration of rights, the abduction of children, as is, quite frankly, well-documented in the video.

I think what is not shown in the video is the other part of this picture, which is a Ugandan military that has also been tremendously abusive in terms of the rights of its own people."


Because of this dangerous and corrupt relationship, Woods said viewers should be careful to support any campaigns that might be perceived as support for the type of military intervention that has already been tried and failed:

"It was tried before back in 2008. It was called Operation Lightning Thunder, reported well in The New York Times and elsewhere, where the U.S., using military forces, went in, and what we -- working with the Ugandan military.

What we saw essentially was Ugandan civilians caught in the crossfire, huge escalation in deaths at that time, a military operation that, in fact, failed, was never reviewed, never scrutinized, and now a call for essentially young people to go all out and essentially support yet another attempt at a military intervention".


http://www.ips-dc.org/media/can_kony_2012_make_a_difference_for_ugandan_youth

On Edit:

The Max Keiser report I mentioned is here on DU's front page in the Video's Section. It's worth the watch about Gold/Oil and the Koney Video.

Here's the Link: http://www.democraticunderground.com/101716176#post1

Our AFRICOM Military Base in Italy has people involved in Uganda, already. I know because friend's son is there...and it's the next Theater for US involvment.. (remember PNAC) now that we've "helped out Libya and Yemen." We are there along with the French, it seems and also China. Just saying...I'd hate to see Religious Fundamentalists pushing videos to get more troops in there than we already have....plus using a video to whip up support from good intentioned young folks who might not be aware of the whole picture behind the video. Just saying...


Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
18. Hmm, I am stuck between you and ellisonz on this.
Tue Mar 13, 2012, 04:38 PM
Mar 2012

I can't support the assassination of foreign dictators in oil rich countries just because they are a thorn in our side when it comes to harvesting Africa for resources, and

I don't want the US to just sit back and say "it's OK to invade Libya because that's in our interests, it's not OK to send troops into the Congo because it's a hopeless mess there and it's in the interests of French and British secret services to keep the region in turmoil so they can continue to pillage the Congo's mineral resources."

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
19. Uh Oh....I just read ellisonz's post...just getting back here...
Tue Mar 13, 2012, 05:21 PM
Mar 2012

I don't have time right now to read the discussion ellinsonz was having...but, my read of his last post would say I'd be completely to the opposite of him in his last statement. His last statement is why I didn't want to come to DU-3.

So..I certainly don't want to get into some "between thing" about this...(because ellinsonz was nice enough to come back and semi-support DU-2 and I have much respect for him because of that.

I think ellsonz is focusing much on his Polish heritage and experiences. I tend to focus on my own heritage and experiences having family here since just after the Revolution (and a few before) ...but British, Irish and French in heritage. Also growing up in the SouthEast US...I would have a longer history with my immigrants who go back to that time.

This is too hard to think about...but, I will say that ellisonze is wrong that we ARE IN AFRICA...in a BIG WAY with Africon! (he's a big boy and can take my criticisim ...because he's also seemed to be fair and balanced in his reasoning in encounters I've seen with him)

Anyway...Gotta think more about this...gotta go.. I'll get back later.

But, as much as I respect ellisonz's post....I would tend to go with what you say and counter
ellisonz's post later. It's truly a discussion that we Dems need to have with each other and there's not a good way to do it out here on DU-3, imho. Ellisonz's views are more in sync with here....and he's a fair person...but, I would tangle with him outside of here. I could send him my and I think he would get the humor. But, his post is very serious to me...and shows me how far apart we Democrats on issues these days. But, DISCUSSION is good ...between the three of us...I think...somehow. I gotta go...got project.
..........
You say:

. Hmm, I am stuck between you and ellisonz on this.


I can't support the assassination of foreign dictators in oil rich countries just because they are a thorn in our side when it comes to harvesting Africa for resources, and

I don't want the US to just sit back and say "it's OK to invade Libya because that's in our interests, it's not OK to send troops into the Congo because it's a hopeless mess there and it's in the interests of French and British secret services to keep the region in turmoil so they can continue to pillage the Congo's mineral resources."


"I can't support the assassination of foreign dictators in oil rich countries just because they are a thorn in our side when it comes to harvesting Africa for resources, and I don't want the US to just sit back and say "it's OK to invade Libya because that's in our interests, it's not OK to send troops into the Congo because it's a hopeless mess there and it's in the interests of French and British secret services to keep the region in turmoil so they can continue to pillage the Congo's mineral resources."

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
22. What's the feedback you've been getting?
Wed Mar 14, 2012, 08:19 PM
Mar 2012

Are any of them questioning the backers of the Video? What do you think about it, yourself?

 

NYC_SKP

(68,644 posts)
23. I've been away but when I came back a speaker had visited the school and made a presentation...
Wed Mar 14, 2012, 08:36 PM
Mar 2012

...and the teacher who I work with the most and many of her students were all over this.

They explained to me the problem and then the solution, to shed light on this and hope that as enough people learn of the atrocities that some pressure will be brought to bear on forces that can do something about it.

One girl, however, was sad and said that her mom though that schools out to not be involving kids in this kind of thing.

I don't hold any opinions about the backers of the video--

I started a conversation today with someone, though, about how most of these oppressive regimes have some resource (oil, diamonds, water) behind them. Other conflicts are religious and a few might be tribal but even these are often caught up in a commodity, a resource, and often it's a Western First-World power that indirectly bears some responsibility.

I've just been too busy to look more deeply into it, and now I'm kind of sick, a cold or something.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
25. A Letter From Uganda on #Kony2012--From "Truth Dig" (Good Read)
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 10:04 AM
Mar 2012

(This is a five page read....so, these snips only give a little of her perspective. BTW, Truth Dig has other articles up about KONY at the link)

----------
A Letter From Uganda on #Kony2012
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/a_letter_from_uganda_on_kony2012_20120315/
Posted on Mar 14, 2012

By Sara Weschler

Editor’s note: Sara Weschler lives in Gulu town, not far from where Joseph Kony was born. She has been involved with northern Uganda and LRA advocacy since 2005, and moved to the region after college. She works as a communications officer for Information for Youth Empowerment Programme (www.IYEPuganda.org)—a small local NGO founded by LRA returnees and other war-affected youth to promote peace and post-conflict recovery. After a video about the Lord’s Resistance Army became an international phenomenon, Weschler wrote this letter to share her perspective and set the record straight.


The Illusion of Military Intervention as Panacea

I may, however, be getting a bit sidetracked. A number of bloggers have in recent days made the case that the greatest flaw in the #KONY2012 video is that the narration leads viewers to believe the war is ongoing in Uganda itself. To be honest, I find this film less misleading on that particular point than many of IC’s earlier productions. And regardless of whether or not the movie distorts the realities of the LRA’s current location, the fact remains that the rebel group does continue to subject civilians in South Sudan, DRC and CAR to horrific dangers and brutality. My problem with the campaign lies much more with the “solution” it advocates, with its claim that all we need to end these atrocities is a military intervention under the guidance of U.S. forces.

The video seems to suggest that no action of this sort has ever before been taken. It quietly sidesteps the fact that prior to the deployment of the 100 U.S. special forces last autumn, the American government has had an unspecified number of troops from U.S. Africa Command (AFRICOM) stationed in Uganda for years. More significantly, a military strike of the sort that Invisible Children is advocating has already taken place.

For a number of reasons (not least of all because the operation was vociferously and boastfully discussed in the preceding weeks), Kony and his troops were aware of the attack well before it started. By the time airstrikes began, the LRA had almost entirely evacuated its bases in Garamba. In the month that followed, the rebels retaliated in spectacular fashion—not against the armies that launched Lightning Thunder, but against the civilians living in the areas affected by the operation. Over the course of four weeks, in a series of attacks loosely referred to as the Christmas Massacres, the Lord’s Resistance Army slaughtered more than 900 villagers in northeastern districts of the DRC. In addition, it abducted an estimated 700 civilians—about 500 of who are believed to have been children.

In light of this, the #StopKony campaign’s Dec. 31 deadline for military action is both utterly arbitrary and potentially dangerous. The U.S. is in an election season—a period when candidates running for office feel the greatest need to pander to voters. And while I would hope that politicians would put sound policy ahead of popular appeal, it is not inconceivable to me that, given enough (well-meaning but misguided) pressure from constituents, certain people in government may push for attacks without truly gauging all facets of the situation. Were this to happen, were a strike to occur before all the necessary preparations are in place, we may well find ourselves facing a repeat of 2008’s botched operation and ensuing loss of civilian lives.

Even putting all this aside, though, there is a fundamental flaw in the assumption that catching Kony would in and of itself bring an end to this conflict. At present, the LRA is scattered across three nations, with its highest-ranking officers strategically divided among the army’s various subgroups. If Kony were to be taken out of the equation, it is entirely likely that another senior commander—say, for example, Dominic Ongwen—could step into the void and fill his leadership position.
Moreover, the entire Kony-centric premise of this campaign ignores the fact that the history of extremist militant opposition in northern Uganda does not begin and end with Joseph Kony.

The Fallacy of the Senseless Rebellion

The #StopKony campaign plays into the all-too-popular and compelling myth that this is an utterly senseless war, that it has been waged for all these years by a band of madmen fighting without rhyme or reason. While it is true that the LRA of today fights primarily for its own survival, this was not always the case. The movement is horrendously violent and appallingly cruel, but it did not come out of nowhere. Any genuine understanding of the LRA conflict requires an analysis of Acholi marginalization throughout Ugandan history. While I will spare you the intricacies of British colonial policy in Acholiland, and the details of the Acholi ethnic group’s plight under Idi Amin, I do feel it necessary to give you an overview of the Acholi experience in recent times.

MUCH MORE at...........
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/a_letter_from_uganda_on_kony2012_20120315/

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
27. Yeah, I agree with the first part, but the author is biased in the last sentence
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 02:12 PM
Mar 2012

Acholi perpetrated horrendous massacres on the people of the Bugandan heartland when they were in power. While it's true Museveni used child soldiers, most were from Buganda (the region around the capitol, i.e. the historic kingdom of Uganda) and the previous president of Uganda (a Western-educated professional with a doctorate degree) took no pains in brutalizing them. They called it the Kampala Triangle (a triangle of death)

People first need to understand that Uganda is a federation of three or four separate countries / precolonial kingdoms, like Nigeria. Buganda was the hegemonic kingdom in the region.

I suppose we could sit back and say "these people" all hate each other but I don't think that's a solution. And in any event she is going on about problems in Uganda (basically anti-Museveni activism) when the issue is the LRA (and other genocide) currently taking place in another country (the Congo). The problem is that I don't think there is any "democratic" movenent in Uganda that wants to overthrow Museveni.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
28. Leo...she goes on in the article about the "tribal differences..North of Nile, South of Nile
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 05:04 PM
Mar 2012

and a history of British Colonialism in the region in the next part of the article after which I had to cut and snip. It's worth the long read of the whole thing.

I have no idea what to think of all of this, but, am trying to read more to understand. You seem to have been following the situation in Uganda closely and your opinion is good to know.

I'm only working with your links and questions about the Viral Video and why or how it would be appealing to masses of young people.

I took the contrarian view...that I wanted to see more facts and try to learn about the situation before young people are duped or taken advantage of by someone with hidden motives...(either wanting funding or to push Obama further into Africa). I was suspicious as one who didn't believe the trumped up charges against Iraq or that Afganistan Taliban/Osama bin Laden took down the WTC when Saudi Arabians seemed to be the bulk of the WTC/Pentagon/maybe WH Attackers.

I'm just trying to learn. The article is a long read...but has interesting background.

I'm still not sure what to think about it.

BTW...there's a link to BBC article from 2011 at "Truth Dig" about Obama ordering a "Capture or Kill" mission in Uganda which also talks about the AFRICON mission in Uganda (which I said I knew about because friend's son is in there based in Italy and I know that we have heavy presense there already). The Video bothered me in that it seemed "Tugging Heart Strings Propaganda" which we Americans have had TOO MUCH OF...in the past Decades since WWII!

Anyway.. Thanks for posting this and I hope you understand that I'm still trying to learn about this and I appreciate your postin about it and replying about what you think about it.

We need to think about this more. I don't know what it has to do with OWS Movement...but, "Occupy US State Department" might be something thinking about going forward! Just saying.

and thanks again for calling attention to this.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
30. BTW: I just posted the BBC article ("Capture or Kill") in #29 to Ellinsonz...
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 05:42 PM
Mar 2012

We are there... It's from the Truth Dig's links. (They are following the Kony)

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
31. Thanks KoKo. I hope she understands it's national, not tribal
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 08:33 PM
Mar 2012

The provinces of Uganda were separate kingdoms for hundreds of years before the British sponsored their colonization by the Protectorate of the Kingdom of Buganda. Buganda, Bunyoro, Ankole (where the cattle come from), Acholi. With its huge capital city of Mengo (pop. 250,000?), now Kampala, Buganda was the largest kingdom, covering the present day province of Buganda, and the British were unable to colonize it except by exploiting differences between missionaries (the French missionaries sought to convert it to Catholicism, Islamic missionaries sought to convert it to Islam.) There were a great many martyrdoms that occurred because of this.

Whereas Rwanda was always a unified kingdom so the Belgians exploited class and racial differences between the Hutu and the ruling Tutsi instead.

About all I know is what I read in college on the subject, though.

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
32. Who knows the truth of it. Probably too complicated.
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 08:57 PM
Mar 2012

the "Powers that Be" are going to do what they do. We can try to keep informed but it's probably well out of our hands at this point.

Anyway...we can move back to OWS and focus there ...where perhaps we CAN make a difference.

My head is starting to hurt from too much thinking about UGANDA and KOBY... Maybe some will read over the weekend, if they are interested to sort through the weeds.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
34. KoKo, here's a book everyone must read: The Scramble For Africa by Pakenham
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 09:28 PM
Mar 2012

You won't find it at a local retailer, so...

Buy it from Powell's Online Bookstore in Portland Oregon:

http://www.powells.com/biblio/1-9780349104492-4

It's a layman's history of the conquest of Africa, I'd put it up there with
the famous book about the fall of the Aztec Empire.

By The Way, when you search Google for "powells" + name of book,

It gives you AMAZON LINKS ONLY and says "did you mean powell's?"
you have to click on the hatnote to get any links at all to Powell's City of Books.

Google is completely corrupt (and tracks all your activity and e-mails under their new policy).

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
35. Thanks for info...btw:
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 09:41 PM
Mar 2012

I switched to BING. Read that if a site uses Google Search (like DU) then use BING for Search...

Also vice-versa. If you are on a Microsoft Browser use Google for search.

I used Bing to search and Powell's Books came right up. BING also gives you a choice to "clear" or "turn off" search History.

I had forgotten about Powell's books. Used to know them long ago in dead tree publishing. We have a B&N Nook...which one of us uses a lot. But, we are still book buyers from the used book stores these days for stuff we can't find. I'll put "The Scramble of Africa" on my list. But, right now I did too much research on the KOBY current issue...so my head is still hurting. Maybe good Summer read...since it's probably the next "Theater" (as Bush/Cheney called it) on our Empire's "To Do List." (sorry for being so cynical.)


Thanks for the tip.

Leopolds Ghost

(12,875 posts)
36. It's a good book to have in trade paperback
Thu Mar 15, 2012, 10:08 PM
Mar 2012

It has occasional maps and so forth, and you can flip between chapters.

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
38. Turnouts the filmaker is a creep:
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 08:03 PM
Mar 2012
Jason Russell Arrested: Co-Founder Of Invisible Children, 'Kony 2012' Creator, Detained In San Diego

Last edited Fri Mar 16, 2012, 04:24 PM USA/ET - Edit history (1)
NBC San Diego is reporting that Jason Russell, the co-founder of Invisible Children, the advocacy group behind the "Kony 2012" viral video, was detained at 11:30 am on Thursday morning for allegedly masturbating in public.

According to TMZ, Russell was allegedly under the influence of alcohol. Police also told TMZ that he was vandalizing cars.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/16/jason-russell-arrested-invisible-children-kony_n_1354455.html


Discuss: http://www.democraticunderground.com/1002432688

KoKo

(84,711 posts)
39. Yeah...that was a Bizarre report about him... Hope it doesn't discourage
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 08:22 PM
Mar 2012

weekend readers from discussing the issues that were brought out on Leo's post.

(Namely the discussion between Leo, You and Myself) with articles and opinions posted on all sides about this.

Just because this guy got off his meds or was pervert in real life or whatever...the point is: His and his Partner's Video went VIRAL and influenced many Young Folks who didn't realize what was going on in Africa. Those young people will find this article very disillusioning to what they were awakened to, as what they thought was a very just cause. And, it may be a "just cause" or it may be that a group getting money was just another part of the money grubbers involved with folks who influence our Govt. for profit ...but, it's important to still keep reading and learning.

Leo gave a link about a book he found interesting to read about Kony's background and Sub-Saharan Africa and I gave links to someone who has served in Uganda who had problems with KONY 2012 and some other links.

We need to not give up on reading about what could be "Next US Theater of War after Syria and Iran" just because some guy went off his meds...or whatever and now many are going to become disillussioned and never finish checking out whether what they said was true, a full picture, propaganda, a swindle or something inbetween.

Just saying... My 2 cents worth.

ellisonz

(27,739 posts)
40. Good points.
Fri Mar 16, 2012, 09:05 PM
Mar 2012

I think the biggest enemy we have is indifference, and that is coupled with a sort of soul-crushing cynicism that is pervasive among our culture. We see it our low voting rates, in our low consumption of knowledge, and even on the internet where more often than not the answer to challenges posed such as KONY 2012 is: who cares or we can't do anything anyways. Nothing could be further from the truth, we can always do something, and we should do something when confronted with the problems of our world. We cannot just crawl inside our shells and hideout, that is a message that both Occupy and Invisible Children share.

That's what really means.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Occupy Underground»KONY 2012