CISPA Wouldn't Actually Solve The Reasons Congress Is Giving For Why We Need CISPA

[Fire Walk With Me]

techdirt ?@techdirt

CISPA Wouldn't Actually Solve The Reasons Congress Is Giving For Why We Need CISPA
http://dlvr.it/2xswff
Retweeted by Black Swan •


http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130214/02084321967/why-wont-anyone-explain-why-we-need-cispa.shtml?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter

As expected, Representatives Mike Rogers and Dutch Ruppersberger have reintroduced CISPA, exactly as it was when it passed the House last year. Incredibly, we've been hearing that they've brushed off the massive privacy concerns by claiming that those were all "fixed" in the final version of the bill that got approved. This is highly disingenuous. While it is true that they made some modifications to the bill at the very end before it got approved, most privacy watchers were (and are) still very concerned. They did convince one organization to flip-flop, and they seem to think that's all they need.

But, here's the thing that no one has done yet: explain why this bill is needed. With President Obama's executive order in place, the government can more easily share threat info with companies, so really the only thing that CISPA piles on is more incentives for companies to cough up private information to the government with little in the way of oversight or restrictions on how that information can be used. And given how frequently the government likes to cry "cyberattack" when it's simply not true, it's only a matter of time before they start using claims of "cyberthreat!" to troll through private information.

And they still refuse to explain why this is needed. We hear lots of scare stories, but no explanation for how this bill helps. For example, Ruppersberger has written up an oped for the Baltimore Sun in which he lays out the reasons we need CISPA, but it's all scare stories, without a single explanation for how CISPA would help. And that's because it wouldn't.

March: Hackers allegedly steal the credit card numbers from 1.5 million Visa and MasterCard customers by breaking into the computer systems of the company's payment processor in New York. The thieves stockpiled the stolen credit card numbers for months before beginning to use them.

(More at the link.)

[Demeter]

1. Because

If TPTB were really honest about why they wanted those powers, there would be a revolution.