Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

iemanja

(54,923 posts)
46. I'm tired of all the complaining about the polls
Thu Nov 3, 2022, 03:24 PM
Nov 2022

(I know the OP isn't doing this. I'm responding to some of the responses in this thread and many other posts throughout DU).

Either pay attention to them or not, but this claim that 538 is a right-wing conspiracy is absurd. 538 aggregates polls, and it has a statistical model for weighting them based on reliability. That is ALL it does. For ANY poll to have much significance, the results need to be twice the margin of error. Very few polls show those kinds of results since the margins of votes in this country is so narrow. That speaks to the limitations of polls. One can certainly choose to dismiss polls for that reason or because we've seen so much inaccuracy in recent elections. But to claim a polling aggregator is a right-wing plot is ridiculous. People didn't have problems with 538 in the past, but now we are supposed to believe the site is out to get Democrats. It's a transparent excuse.

The election results will be what they are. We will know on Tuesday or Wed. You'll find out then if the polls were right or wrong, but regardless of the outcomes, there is no basis to claim the entire polling industry--and aggregators like 538-- are out to get you.

What there is, legitimately, is a problem in the media about how they report polls. They underplay the importance of margins of error and pretend that the polls are absolutely predictive. The media, and with it the public, have little understanding of statistics (count me among them), so they greatly overestimate what small differences in polls mean. They do the same thing every election cycle, even when they mistakenly overstated Democrats election changes. They may be doing to the same with Republicans this year--or not--but that's because of how the media handles polls, not because they (including, supposedly, MSNBC) have suddenly become MAGA. It's because they always do the same thing with elections and NEVER reconsider their approach when proven wrong.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

538 polls are not reliable. Joy Reid explained why on her show a few days ago. onecaliberal Nov 2022 #1
My understanding is that 538 isn't a poll. It's an aggregator of polls. yardwork Nov 2022 #3
Right wing skewed polls. onecaliberal Nov 2022 #4
They aggregate all polls... BlueCheeseAgain Nov 2022 #33
That is why Nate is basically saying...hey these are the numbers for the Midterm...but if the polls Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #9
He's saying what I've said a lot - this is a particularly difficult election to model Amishman Nov 2022 #21
Honestly, I have no idea what will happen on Tuesday... I keep thinking we may win but who Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #49
538 does no polling, it's not really a poll aggregator either Deminpenn Nov 2022 #20
The context is still correct, "538 polls" are not reliable, as in 538 includes shady R polls skewing themaguffin Nov 2022 #32
👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻 onecaliberal Nov 2022 #36
Again, not defending 538, but they do make an attempt Deminpenn Nov 2022 #39
If you can find the Joy Reid show from a few days ago, they had a guest on that explained onecaliberal Nov 2022 #45
538 tries to correct for that bias, but still it has the GIGO Deminpenn Nov 2022 #38
Thanks for that explanation! That makes sense. yardwork Nov 2022 #54
Um... Pollsters are statisticians. The real ones, no less. Genki Hikari Nov 2022 #56
ignore the polls and VOTE RussBLib Nov 2022 #2
Exactly... Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #10
It isn't guaranteed but I think a polling error favoring Dems is far ColinC Nov 2022 #5
With Roe and Medicare...I do too...time will tell! Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #12
Early numbers, for the most part seem to be looking cgood ColinC Nov 2022 #13
We will know when we know. I'm imagining a LOT of women Scrivener7 Nov 2022 #6
I think you are right...there will red areas that go for the Democrats...they have missed the Roe Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #18
Some people like to believe their preferred outcome Scrivener7 Nov 2022 #30
This! moonscape Nov 2022 #41
I have done GOTV forever and if people think we will lose that is when they don't turn up... Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #44
Kansas was a real eye opener wryter2000 Nov 2022 #26
The conclusion of this analysis seems to be prodigitalson Nov 2022 #7
Exactly. Scrivener7 Nov 2022 #31
Well, there's only three possibilities Polybius Nov 2022 #8
Ah but you missing an important fact...more than half of polls are cheap shitty right wing polls lik Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #19
If they are proven wrong again, I hope 538 and RCP banns them Polybius Nov 2022 #25
50% chance of rain. Yavin4 Nov 2022 #11
I have to wonder if there is a bit CYA going on...he has to know that some of the polls being used Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #22
You can be wrong in CA wryter2000 Nov 2022 #27
I think bookmarking is the key. Baggies Nov 2022 #14
This is some world-class hedging EarlG Nov 2022 #15
That is what I think...I am not giving up...going to get the vote out...I am walking later and the Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #23
For sure Deminpenn Nov 2022 #40
Polls in just about every high-profiled race are so close that any movement can change things. Beautiful Disaster Nov 2022 #16
And the Roe effect to tip the elections in our favor. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #24
In summary. Polls are useless now. So why is there so much time wasted on them? bullimiami Nov 2022 #17
I just take all polls with a grain of salt, good or bad. Elessar Zappa Nov 2022 #28
It's close and could go either way Sympthsical Nov 2022 #29
I say they lose the house because of Roe...women know you need both houses to codify Roe. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #43
Not sure why they have Warnock with less of a chance of winning. All the polls that would be PortTack Nov 2022 #34
Non-partisan polls show Warnock winning but there many partisan shit polls Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #35
They are trying to cover their asses budkin Nov 2022 #37
Is that it...biggest CYA ever...hmmm Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #42
I'm tired of all the complaining about the polls iemanja Nov 2022 #46
+1. May be crystal balls but only crystal balls we've got :) Laura PourMeADrink Nov 2022 #48
I don't disagree with you. Nate doesn't run the polls but he is warning that despite best efforts Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #50
Virtual phone bank this sunday and monday. Flash953 Nov 2022 #47
Since all polls are considered and factored, and the GOP has flooded the market with polls to skew lees1975 Nov 2022 #51
So true yankee87 Nov 2022 #53
Stop. Genki Hikari Nov 2022 #57
Bad Polls yankee87 Nov 2022 #58
I just don't get how the GOP can run Herschel Walker without shame and maybe get away with it renate Nov 2022 #52
Yup...I know. Hershel Walker is mentally ill and not smart IMHO...and unqualified for the Senate. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #55
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Polls could be off an...»Reply #46