Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

erronis

(17,180 posts)
19. I'm working through the whole article and am amazed that so many Democrats signed the Southern Manifesto
Sun Apr 28, 2024, 08:04 PM
Apr 2024
And a great many did not. Leaders of the slaveholding South called the Declaration “a most pernicious falsehood.” South Carolina’s John C. Calhoun called the very idea of equal rights a “false doctrine.” They believed in democracy, but only if it was an exclusively White democracy. When democracy turned against them in 1860, they rebelled and sought an exit from the system. That rebellion never ended. It has been weakened, suppressed — sometimes by force — and driven underground, but it has never gone away. Although the South was militarily defeated and deprived of its special advantages in the Constitution, its hostility to the Founders’ liberalism did not abate. As Southern writer W.J. Cash observed in 1941, if the war had “smashed the southern world,” it had nevertheless “left the essential southern mind and will … entirely unshaken” and Southerners themselves determined “to hold fast to their own, to maintain their divergences, to remain what they had been and were.” In 1956, almost a century after the Civil War, a fifth of Congress, almost all Democrats — signed the “Southern Manifesto” calling on states to refuse to obey the Supreme Court’s 1954 decision to end segregation in public schools. Nothing had changed. Are we so surprised that for many Americans, nothing has changed even today?

Nor has anti-liberalism only been about race. For more than a century after the Revolution, many if not most White Anglo-Saxon Protestants insisted that America was a Protestant nation. They did not believe Catholics possessed equal rights or should be treated as equals. The influential “second” Ku Klux Klan of the 1920s was anti-Catholic and anti-Jewish as well as anti-Black, which was why, unlike the original Klan, it flourished outside the South. Many regard today’s Christian nationalism as a fringe movement, but it has been a powerful and often dominant force throughout America’s history.

Of course these were southern Democrats back in the '50s where party allegiances were murky.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Thank you for posting this.... Think. Again. Apr 2024 #1
That's a great idea! He is very thorough. CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #5
This part in particular jumped right out and grabbed my attention. Ligyron Apr 2024 #49
There is a new documentary out called "Bad Faith" that traces some of the root causes of this mess BlueWaveNeverEnd Apr 2024 #2
Yeah, I think one thing is missing Farmer-Rick Apr 2024 #46
Robert Kagan is an American neoconservative scholar. He is a critic of U.S. foreign policy and a leading advocate of Celerity Apr 2024 #62
I had no idea the writer was a Neocon Farmer-Rick Apr 2024 #63
the Kagan family are/were a nest of neocon war hawks Celerity Apr 2024 #64
Thanks for the info. Farmer-Rick Apr 2024 #65
I have only read the part you posted so far senseandsensibility Apr 2024 #3
I have long had a nagging fear..... lastlib Apr 2024 #21
Exactly senseandsensibility Apr 2024 #23
+1. we have been spoon fed a steady diet of demonizing and distrust stopdiggin Apr 2024 #52
Yes , I'm afraid that this is another thing that our side senseandsensibility Apr 2024 #59
A worthwhile read, even if it mostly confirmed my worst fears. nt eppur_se_muova Apr 2024 #4
Good read malaise Apr 2024 #6
Well worth the read. American social history cachukis Apr 2024 #7
Thanks! It is the ignorant and lazy led by the Pied Piper Elites StClone Apr 2024 #8
Alas, only the first paragraph is visible at the link. n/t TygrBright Apr 2024 #9
You sure? I just read it, no problem. n/t malthaussen Apr 2024 #11
I'm so sorry, my dear TygrBright! All of it shows up when I click it. It's a gift link and it all should be there.nt CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #12
When I tried the OP link, I got a pop up wnylib Apr 2024 #18
It seems like it's blocked, but it's not. Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #36
No, there was no way to close it. But I was able to read the article via wnylib Apr 2024 #40
Yes, I that cache link works. I trick! But you really Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #41
I expected that there would be an x, searched for one, but, none was visible on my phone screen. wnylib Apr 2024 #42
That's super perplexing. It *is* very small. Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #43
Oh, I did just notice what might be the problem! Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #44
hey, try this link orleans Apr 2024 #16
That works! Thank you so much, orleans. n/t TygrBright Apr 2024 #17
you're welcome & in the future orleans Apr 2024 #20
Cool! Thanks for that! Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #37
Works! Thank you Amaryllis Apr 2024 #51
I couldn't get it either. n/t lastlib Apr 2024 #22
Orleans has a link the post right above yours that should work. Give it a try! His post #20. CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #25
But you can click through. They are asking Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #35
I had this problem too: only the 1st para, no popup or gift notice scipan Apr 2024 #61
It's a good summary. malthaussen Apr 2024 #10
I hope you're right, my dear malthaussen! nt CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #38
But it only takes a small number of his Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2024 #39
"Well-trained," forsooth? malthaussen Apr 2024 #54
Thank you bdamomma Apr 2024 #13
Bookmarking to read later! LeftInTX Apr 2024 #15
I'm working through the whole article and am amazed that so many Democrats signed the Southern Manifesto erronis Apr 2024 #19
I think, JFK kind of "put them" to sleep, and LBJ followed to "open their minds" Justice matters. Apr 2024 #56
Excellent essay, Peggy. Thank you for posting. peggysue2 Apr 2024 #24
removed by author Stuart G Apr 2024 #26
So many thoughts. mtngirl47 Apr 2024 #27
KNR and bookmarking. Thank you for sharing. niyad Apr 2024 #28
Brilliant piece. I NEVER EVER post anything political onmy FB wall. HUAJIAO Apr 2024 #29
Thank you for posting it on Facebook, and for making me smile, my dear HUAJIAO! ♥ nt CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #30
Thank you Peggy. That might be the best description I've read nolabear Apr 2024 #31
I believe that things will get better, my dear nolabear, but first we must decisively win this election! CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #32
Thanks for this informative piece by Robert Kagan, one of the best Bundbuster Apr 2024 #33
Good night, my dear Bundbuster! See you tomorrow . . . CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #34
Thank you plcdude Apr 2024 #45
Thanks CaliforniaPeggy justaprogressive Apr 2024 #47
Thanks for posting this MustLoveBeagles Apr 2024 #48
Kicking this article bdamomma Apr 2024 #50
Kagan's article is the best summary of what we're up against Bundbuster Apr 2024 #53
Superb article! Wild blueberry Apr 2024 #55
Thank you for posting this. CBHagman Apr 2024 #57
thanks for posting this, peg.... Gato Moteado Apr 2024 #58
Federalist No. 10 SARose Apr 2024 #60
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»This is quite a long arti...»Reply #19