Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

highplainsdem

(52,786 posts)
35. Generative AI, which is the most harmful tech in recent decades, with only a few areas where it's
Mon Aug 26, 2024, 08:09 AM
Aug 2024

actually helpful. Incredible waste of investment money. Damaging to the environment. Far and away the biggest theft of intellectual property ever. Seriously polluting our information ecosystem, and it might never be possible to remove the tsunami of AI slop, both text and images, from the internet. Teachers being pressured by admins to use it more and more, with the aim in many cases the replacement of teachers with AI, though the increase in cheating is more and more obvious; OpenAI's CEO merely suggested we change the definition of cheating so it won't include AI.

The error/hallucination problem is apparently unsolvable, so genAI can never be trusted to give a correct response (so you get fake quotes with fake citations, the wrong number of fingers on hands, scientific illustrations that are complete lunacy and would be hilarious if the AI-generated article they're in hadn't somehow been missed and published in a journal). But the AI companies are still determined to shove genAI into everything possible anyway.

Even though its main use is fraud, from students cheating to people using AI to pretend to have knowledge and abilities they don't have, whether with writing, coding, visual art or music. You can prompt an AI image generator to spit out images of something you'd never heard of when you have no idea what it might look like - say, you choose a few Latin scientific names from a long list - in an art style you never heard of before and have no knowledge of, and the AI will come up with something, even if you have no clue whether the image or the art style is correct. That doesn't make the AI user an artist or knowledgeable, any more than a student using ChatGPT to write an essay about a book the student hasn't read has somehow gained any knowledge. GenAI is the ultimate dumbing-down and de-skilling tech.

I saw one AI peddler on Twitter tell students in a recent post to simply cheat their way through school, and then genAI would be their "superpower" after they got the degree.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Internet maveric Aug 2024 #1
Back in the late 80's in an academic setting, it was all that. Shermann Aug 2024 #4
There's plenty of good on the internet. Unfortunately, some bad as well. Most depends on How you Use it... electric_blue68 Aug 2024 #18
It was the same with television. Disaffected Aug 2024 #14
Anybody who expected that was living in denial Zoomie1986 Aug 2024 #30
I can't imagine being without DU Kaleva Aug 2024 #34
A word about driverless vehicles. Demobrat Aug 2024 #2
A lot of this is perception Shermann Aug 2024 #7
AI. Accompanied by, and the possible benefits of overwhelmed by, Artificial Stupidity. nt eppur_se_muova Aug 2024 #3
The hype cycle is going to hit AI hard Shermann Aug 2024 #5
Artificial stupidity gets my vote iemanja Aug 2024 #26
Yes! This! bobalew Aug 2024 #27
Generative AI, which is the most harmful tech in recent decades, with only a few areas where it's highplainsdem Aug 2024 #35
I forgot about the energy demand/enviro cost. That for crypto too -- horror stories from neighbors of crypto farms. eppur_se_muova Aug 2024 #49
Thanks for the reply - and for the reminder of what an environmental nightmare crypto is as well. highplainsdem Aug 2024 #50
I actually use Copilot a lot these days. Shermann Aug 2024 #59
Even decades after the greatest invention of all-time it's a hard act to follow. The impact on humanity can't easily brewens Aug 2024 #6
I can't see setting up the coffee pot the night before when I can procrastinate and make it in the morning! nt Shermann Aug 2024 #10
But your new coffee maker will be connected to the internet where artificial stupidity will program it. Angleae Aug 2024 #51
The Galaxy deflector ray. GreenWave Aug 2024 #8
Humans? Getting dumber and less aware by the day dutch777 Aug 2024 #9
I beg to differ on 3D tvs... bcool Aug 2024 #11
I'd say those are in the hype cycle Phase 3: Trough of Disillusionment Shermann Aug 2024 #17
I have one also and love Avatar on it Tree Lady Aug 2024 #21
flying car that folds into a briefcase when you arrive at your destination. aka the jetsons. AllaN01Bear Aug 2024 #12
No flying cars PERIOD! GoCubsGo Aug 2024 #36
indeed. AllaN01Bear Aug 2024 #37
Well, they're hyping these so-called flying cars Xavier Breath Aug 2024 #40
You forgot to include the Segway! robbob Aug 2024 #13
Yeah, the Segway was disappointing Shermann Aug 2024 #15
Standing is much, much harder on your joints than walking! LeftInTX Aug 2024 #28
You should change it to crypto currency. Blockchain's used in many other applications that have nothing to do w/ crypto. Celerity Aug 2024 #16
I love autonomous vehicles Polybius Aug 2024 #19
Social media NameAlreadyTaken Aug 2024 #20
the fucking algorithms. uncle ray Aug 2024 #22
AI ........ Artificial intelligence Trueblue1968 Aug 2024 #23
I watched a Waymo parking flamingdem Aug 2024 #24
A ship named after the father of a friend of ours DFW Aug 2024 #25
The problem was the shipbuilders design haele Aug 2024 #39
Trust the Bath Iron Works to cut corners like that. DFW Aug 2024 #42
I met the Admiral of whom you speak. haele Aug 2024 #46
That he would have. DFW Aug 2024 #48
it's really a late 20th C invention, but I think anonymous posting on the internet is a bad move Bucky Aug 2024 #29
For the first time I have a fridge that makes ice cubes by itself. betsuni Aug 2024 #31
I teach writing for a living. Straw Man Aug 2024 #32
Agree completely. See my reply 35. I read a lot of teachers' posts on Twitter, and the only ones highplainsdem Aug 2024 #38
Semi-retired writing prof here too. AI is just another tool JCMach1 Aug 2024 #47
Cures for things like ALS. So far disappointing. JanMichael Aug 2024 #33
Has to be autonomous vehicles Renew Deal Aug 2024 #41
I am not a doom and gloomer...it is still a pretty great world with much to see and do. Demsrule86 Aug 2024 #43
That we're still using rockets to get into space and there are no hologram phones. BannonsLiver Aug 2024 #44
Cell phones orthoclad Aug 2024 #45
What? You don't like the 21st century version of the zombie apocalypse? Angleae Aug 2024 #53
Shambling, shambling along orthoclad Aug 2024 #65
Woohoo! I get to talk to the person I'd like to be with instead of the person I'm actually with at the moment! nt Shermann Aug 2024 #58
While driving an SUV orthoclad Aug 2024 #66
Yeah, that distant voice is SO much more important orthoclad Aug 2024 #67
Self driving vehicles... Historic NY Aug 2024 #52
Streaming tv JackSabbath Aug 2024 #54
Streaming. On demand TV & movies with the click of a button. CrispyQ Aug 2024 #55
Roku does a pretty good job of standardizing the controls across applications. Shermann Aug 2024 #57
Clamshell packaging Ping Tung Aug 2024 #56
Well at least you can recycle...err...never mind. Shermann Aug 2024 #64
I am loving my new self driving car. Jk23 Aug 2024 #60
Those are really ADAS (advanced driver-assistance system) features and not autonomous driving features. nt Shermann Aug 2024 #61
EVs, Solar. Mosby Aug 2024 #62
Fusion energy (which I failed to list) is WAY more disappointing than solar! nt Shermann Aug 2024 #63
"Internet of things" is just a way for marketers to ... surrealAmerican Aug 2024 #68
I have an IoT pool pump Shermann Aug 2024 #69
Vote supression. eppur_se_muova Oct 7 #70
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»What's the most disappoin...»Reply #35