Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

AloeVera

(2,131 posts)
28. Hmmmm... I see.
Sat Sep 21, 2024, 02:36 PM
Sep 2024

That's interesting. I've rarely seen the rejection of the plan used to imply Israel could then take lands designated for Palestinians under the Plan.

Which is what Israel did, in 1948. Israel was gifted 56% of mandate Palestine under the Plan, though comprising half the population of the majority Arabs who owned over 90% of the lands.

Seems like a good deal for Israel, not so good for Palestinians. Can't imagine why they rejected it.

But sarcasm aside, here's the icing on the cake. After declaring independence unilaterally and immediately after British withdrawal, and after having already expelled over 200,000 Palestinians from their homes, Israel was just getting started. By the end of the "War of Independence", over 700,000 Palestinians were expelled or fled, Israel captured and kept an additional 22% of Palestinian -designated territory, bringing its share of mandate Palestine to 78%.

The captured-and-kept (aka occupied) Palestinian lands included a large swath of what is now Northern Israel.

From your map, note also how big the West Bank and Gaza were under the Plan, compared to today.

The reality is that from the 44% of their OWN EFFING lands the Palestinians were "allowed" to keep under the Partition Plan, they are now reduced to less than 10% with towns cut-off and terrorized by the violent settlers and now even the IDF.

But getting back to my point - from the Palestinian POV, the Israeli people inhabiting the conquered north of Israel, the conquered environs of Gaza, and large swathes of the West Bank - are indeed "settlers". Because they are on lands designated by the UN for Palestinians.

I am sure you didn't mean to imply that rejection of Partition meant the loss of Palestinian rights and claim to any of their territory, a totally indefensible argument.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This piece of shit, now blown up pieces of shit, is responsible for many of my friends deaths MarineCombatEngineer Sep 2024 #1
I remember when that happened soandso Sep 2024 #2
Here, this explains it MarineCombatEngineer Sep 2024 #4
Thanks soandso Sep 2024 #6
You just described Lebanon back then perfectly. MarineCombatEngineer Sep 2024 #7
Sounded kind of cool soandso Sep 2024 #8
Is that one of the terrorists edhopper Sep 2024 #16
Not that I know of, MarineCombatEngineer Sep 2024 #17
Probably other terrorists then edhopper Sep 2024 #19
Such great news that he was killed. jimfields33 Sep 2024 #26
Failed to mention the soccer field missile here but still important info soandso Sep 2024 #3
And here is the Latini River soandso Sep 2024 #5
Why is the Lebanese army standing idly by allowing Hezbollah to attack Lebanon's neighbor? TheKentuckian Sep 2024 #22
Hezbollah is much stronger and better equipped than the Lebanese army. Beastly Boy Sep 2024 #31
"warned that the UK-trained Lebanese army would not "stand idly" by and watch if Israel launches a ground invasion" EX500rider Sep 2024 #25
On the Israelis from the north soandso Sep 2024 #9
"Settlers", "settlements" DavidDvorkin Sep 2024 #10
I know soandso Sep 2024 #11
Hmmmm... I see. AloeVera Sep 2024 #28
You are correct soandso Sep 2024 #29
Thank you. AloeVera Sep 2024 #30
Israel didn't take an inch of the land designated for the Palestinian state. Beastly Boy Sep 2024 #32
Were there such a thing as "Palestinians" back then? Mossfern Sep 2024 #33
The area was called Palestine soandso Sep 2024 #34
So the Jewish people living there were Palestinians too. Mossfern Sep 2024 #36
I don't know how they referred to themselves soandso Sep 2024 #37
Etymology of Palestine/Palestinian soandso Sep 2024 #38
Lebanese FM using the same word, making same threat soandso Sep 2024 #14
Hey Nasrallah, how about wiping every last one of you off the face of the Earth and salting the ground where TheKentuckian Sep 2024 #23
However one feels about this conflict soandso Sep 2024 #12
He keeps killing terrorists and it will change the Middle East! jimfields33 Sep 2024 #27
I've seen this news elsewhere, too soandso Sep 2024 #13
TY for all this information, soandso. Cha Sep 2024 #15
How would the US or any other country respond to a neighboring country firing thousands of rockets at its towns? EX500rider Sep 2024 #18
I've often asked that question, and the only answer I ever get is, "That's completely different!" DavidDvorkin Sep 2024 #20
We'd cry havoc & let slip the dogs of war...the JDAM's and Reapers would be overhead in hours EX500rider Sep 2024 #21
The same way, no doubt soandso Sep 2024 #24
Something needs to be done about these settlers soandso Sep 2024 #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»IDF kills Hezbollah's top...»Reply #28