General Discussion

standingtall

(2,994 posts)

16. Adding States would make it very hard for republicans

Wed Sep 25, 2024, 01:16 PM

Sep 25

get the majority without moving to the center. Making a carve out for Voting rights and Women's health could just as easily be repealed by a future republican majority anyway and a future republican majority could make their own carve out exceptions. The best way to go is to end the filibuster completely and add States. Btw Trump talked about ending the filibuster to repeal the ACA, but it was a moot point, because they didn't have a majority vote to repeal it thanks to 1 republican John McCain voting against it. So the ACA would've survived the Trump Presidency even if there was no filibuster.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

21 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

If Democrats win the Presidency, House, and remain in control of the Senate, should we eliminate the filibuster? [View all] Polybius Sep 25 OP

yes absolutely RJ_MacReady Sep 25 #1

If I could eat all the chocolate I want without ruining my teeth or gaining weight Prairie Gates Sep 25 #2

White chocolate is good too Polybius Sep 25 #3

White chocolate is trash Prairie Gates Sep 25 #7

Post of the Day krawhitham Sep 25 #15

Yes and here's my main reason themaguffin Sep 25 #4

Heck yes dsc Sep 25 #5

I know why we want to do this.... Dorian Gray Sep 25 #6

Yes but not doing it could also backfire on us standingtall Sep 25 #11

Yes, it's abused. Liberal In Texas Sep 25 #8

This election is still quite close FBaggins Sep 25 #9

If we put the cart before the horse, will it improve steering? maxsolomon Sep 25 #10

The filibuster does not rise to the 'original intent' bar sanatanadharma Sep 25 #12

The Senate itself "goes against democracy" tinrobot Sep 25 #13

It would be a very bad idea krawhitham Sep 25 #14

Adding States would make it very hard for republicans standingtall Sep 25 #16

I totally see your point Polybius Sep 26 #20

Kill it dead, Dead, DEAD, then burn it and shoot the ashes into space. Fiendish Thingy Sep 25 #17

Yes, but beware of the Law of Unintended Consequences when things don't always work out like you hope. elocs Sep 25 #18

It doesn't need to be modified. It needs to be unmodified. GoCubsGo Sep 25 #19

Flip the rules MurrayDelph Sep 26 #21