General Discussion

slightlv

(4,419 posts)

51. The forced kidney donation example

Tue Oct 1, 2024, 05:49 PM

Oct 1

harks back to when we were arguing about this in the early days -- that corpses have more rights now than living, breathing women. You cannot take organs from a corpse or do anything to the corpse, unless paperwork has been filed prior to death. Women... not so much any more.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

53 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

'Women are not some piece of collectively owned community property' [View all] Jrose Sep 30 OP

Link to the order: Ocelot II Sep 30 #1

Thanks, Ocelot II for the link. I was having technical problems with that! Jrose Sep 30 #24

Yes! Thank you! ❤️ littlemissmartypants Sep 30 #33

Whatever has happened to the Fulton County case? Sogo Sep 30 #38

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 UpInArms Oct 1 #42

This is awesome. liberalmuse Sep 30 #2

This is so great! Timeflyer Sep 30 #3

Wow! DET Sep 30 #4

I always wonder how any normal person does that. efhmc Sep 30 #6

The judge has a way with understanding Tweedy Sep 30 #9

No kidding! ☹️ For those of us who practice "woo" white light this good judge, his workplace, home, and family. electric_blue68 Sep 30 #21

Excellent quote. efhmc Sep 30 #5

Finally! A jurist who understands autonomy and the right to privacy Tweedy Sep 30 #7

I hope many of us in this country will remember 2024 as the turning point Jrose Sep 30 #34

So well said. Can we replace one of our current SC Justices with this person? ms liberty Sep 30 #8

I think he just interviewed for the job cpamomfromtexas Oct 1 #50

Oh hell yeah AmBlue Sep 30 #10

The 19th amendment was necessary! dickthegrouch Oct 1 #48

"during this period when the fetus cannot survive outside the womb" Okay, so what happens at "viability"? WhiskeyGrinder Sep 30 #11

It's basically the same result as Roe v. Wade. Ocelot II Sep 30 #14

Which is why I say that Roe is the floor and we have to do better with whatever comes next. WhiskeyGrinder Sep 30 #15

Totally agree LearnedHand Sep 30 #20

At that point I think it becomes a medical decision with a physician. Joinfortmill Sep 30 #28

Yes. Tweedy Sep 30 #22

Agreed lonely bird Oct 1 #44

Absolute bs Tweedy Oct 1 #53

If the fetus is viable then it's called a birth VMA131Marine Sep 30 #35

. WhiskeyGrinder Sep 30 #37

when i offered to take a friend to get a abortion in the 70s... samnsara Oct 1 #43

Can we charge Rethug politicians with practicing medicine without a license? Seinan Sensei Sep 30 #12

Yes!!! Demovictory9 Sep 30 #13

Finally someone put into words senseandsensibility Sep 30 #16

"Oh, noes!!! rubbersole Sep 30 #17

I think that when President Harris is looking for candidates to fill new SCOTUS positions, flashman13 Sep 30 #18

Why didn't you post the link? littlemissmartypants Sep 30 #19

Sorry, was having tech glitches! 'Ocelot II' did thankfully post the link. Jrose Sep 30 #25

No need to apologize. Appreciate the post. Joinfortmill Sep 30 #30

Oh, no. Technical glitches are no fun. I hope you can get them ironed out. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Sep 30 #32

.... AKwannabe Sep 30 #23

Finally. GB_RN Sep 30 #26

Wow. Right on! Joinfortmill Sep 30 #27

WE ARE NOT GOING BACK, PERIOD. Clouds Passing Sep 30 #29

Finally, a freaking judge who "gets it!" slightlv Sep 30 #31

There's a cartoon going around GopherGal Oct 1 #49

The forced kidney donation example slightlv Oct 1 #51

Wow, I'm so happy with this order and this judge! ...the robustness and strong defense against the abortion ban. liberalla Sep 30 #36

At last! dlk Oct 1 #39

Wow. Just wow. Native Oct 1 #40

National Socialist Vance believes in the collectivization of white baby production. Production, not support Bernardo de La Paz Oct 1 #41

Robert McBurney For the Supreme Court malaise Oct 1 #45

This is beautiful ... n/t wackadoo wabbit Oct 1 #46

Wow. Beautifully said. Betty Boom Oct 1 #47

Not a Republican, I'm guessing. Morbius Oct 1 #52