Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

pat_k

(10,883 posts)
60. Forgot all about that! The 1/2 Hour News Hour in 2007
Mon Oct 28, 2024, 01:34 AM
Oct 2024
https://www.popmatters.com/1-2-hour-news-hour-joel-surnow-fox-news-failed-foray-into-satire-2500322998.html

...
For example, the pilot episode featured a sketch with Rush Limbaugh as the president and Anne Coulter as his vice president. At one point the commander-in-chief asks if the VP would like to join him in a cigar.

“Isn’t the White House a smoke-free zone?” Coulter asks.

“Not anymore,” Limbaugh replies with his trademark smugness. Cue the laugh track...

However, the bigger problem might have been that Surnow et al misunderstood the function and form of political satire altogether...

To its credit, The ½ Hour News Hour strove for laughs, and some of the jokes were genuinely funny. “Illinois Senator Barack Obama admits that as a teenager he sometimes used cocaine,” says Kurt McNally (Kurt Long), one of the show’s cohosts, in one faux-news bit. “The news sent Obama’s approval rating among Democrats plummeting to an all-time low of 99.9 percent.”...

...successful satire must move beyond laughter alone. It should offer a critique of persons, places, institutions, and/or ideas that pose some threat to society. In a sense, it weaponizes humor in an effort to draw attention to a problem.

This is why historically, satire has been a tool of the powerless and the marginalized. We mock world leaders, governments, and oppressive traditions not only because it’s amusing, but because it’s a way of calling out corruption and incompetence among those who have the most control over our lives.

...satire entails a considerable power imbalance between speaker and target and usually comes from the bottom up. This is why, as Jezebel writer Lindy West points out, at company parties it’s the boss who’s roasted, not the custodian. For people in positions of power to mock their subordinates isn’t funny, it’s tasteless.




Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

How close was the margin in Pennsylvania in 2020? MissB Oct 2024 #1
Also epreic01 Oct 2024 #2
He needs Black and Latino men to come out big for him. Quiet Em Oct 2024 #3
Do you really think that Puerto Ricans or the Latino/Latina communities or the black population will just say... Gaytano70 Oct 2024 #4
I guess the singer in Puerto Rico who just endorsed Harris is considered as popular as Taylor Swift there Tribetime Oct 2024 #14
Bad Bunny & Ricky Martin Gaytano70 Oct 2024 #20
Bad Bunny 45.6 million Tribetime Oct 2024 #23
Jennifer Lopez joined them, too. She has 250 million spooky3 Oct 2024 #30
Yes newdeal2 Oct 2024 #5
repukes have been crapping on them for decades Skittles Oct 2024 #39
Why have you come to spread nihilism.and defeatism? Defeatism can only help Trumpism. Maru Kitteh Oct 2024 #6
ExFuckingZactly.. TY!! Cha Oct 2024 #9
It's already moved Bad Bunny MaryMagdaline Oct 2024 #7
He's as big as Taylor Swift there Tribetime Oct 2024 #16
"There" is here. Gaytano70 Oct 2024 #21
Yes Tribetime Oct 2024 #24
That's your Opinion. Puerto Rican Bad Bunny just Endorsed Harris. Cha Oct 2024 #8
Rick Scott clearly is super concerned it's gonna hurt him in his Senate race. Wiz Imp Oct 2024 #10
Ricky Martin just endorsed Kamala tavernier Oct 2024 #11
Oh wow.. TY! Do you have a link? Cha Oct 2024 #15
Earlier on DU tavernier Oct 2024 #18
Mahalo, tavernier! 💙 I just kicked it. Cha Oct 2024 #19
thanking Mr. Martin Skittles Oct 2024 #38
The margin in 2020 was a few tens of thousands of votes in a few states, RockRaven Oct 2024 #12
Unrec. nt LexVegas Oct 2024 #13
Sorry to tell you, but it absolutely will n/t kcr Oct 2024 #17
Message auto-removed Name removed Oct 2024 #22
Speaking of comedians... TwilightZone Oct 2024 #25
Message auto-removed Name removed Oct 2024 #34
Interesting. You do realize that your Username GP6971 Oct 2024 #35
Post removed Post removed Oct 2024 #42
Just remember to give a generous tip to our driver. GP6971 Oct 2024 #44
For anyone who has seen any of Trump's recent rallies, it was right in the ballpark. TwilightZone Oct 2024 #36
Welcome to DU. Interesting Username. GP6971 Oct 2024 #27
Well, it's spot on. TwilightZone Oct 2024 #29
If that's their intent, they'll have to get in line. GP6971 Oct 2024 #31
That won't be happening. TwilightZone Oct 2024 #32
On the contrary. My theory is B.See Oct 2024 #33
You're not wrong about Hinchcliffe. ShazzieB Oct 2024 #45
Wouldn't one need to be part of the insulted community BootinUp Oct 2024 #26
As Elie Mystal said, Trump dropped a tape explaining how he assaulted women and was still elected. OrlandoDem2 Oct 2024 #28
It's an enthusiasm election - and Trump just motivated some people Sympthsical Oct 2024 #37
As I noted in another response, the campaign almost certainly had to pre-approve content. TwilightZone Oct 2024 #40
There's an art to being edgy Sympthsical Oct 2024 #41
Excellent point. TwilightZone Oct 2024 #43
Forgot all about that! The 1/2 Hour News Hour in 2007 pat_k Oct 2024 #60
"Donald Trump's Racist NYC Rally Was Vile. It Was Also Political Suicide" Ellipsis Oct 2024 #46
The Daily Beast isn't an unbiased observer. TwilightZone Oct 2024 #49
Agreed, on they crossed a line. I was just thinking the exact same thing when I read it. Ellipsis Oct 2024 #50
TY & I don't care if they're "unbiased" or NOT.. They're Reality BASED. Cha Oct 2024 #55
You mean TZ I assume. I edited my response. Ellipsis Oct 2024 #56
No, I was thanking you for the headline from The Daily Beast. Cha Oct 2024 #57
Well thank you then. Ellipsis Oct 2024 #58
Best to you, Ellipsis! Cha Oct 2024 #59
No Rainman4u2C Oct 2024 #47
Der Fuhrer you mean, yes? Welcome to DU. Ellipsis Oct 2024 #48
No, they screwed up with this one. Nt Quixote1818 Oct 2024 #51
Nah, this is gonna make a difference. How much difference? We'll have to wait and see... 0rganism Oct 2024 #52
Agree. If anything it will spur some lazy rubes to vote. But at this point, the racists Silent Type Oct 2024 #53
Yup, will inure to the benefit of V.P. Harris/Walz, and every black, latino, Puerto Rican in and around the U.S. elleng Oct 2024 #54
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Will the racist black and...»Reply #60