Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DAngelo136

(314 posts)
85. The Canadian British Economist
Mon Nov 11, 2024, 07:55 AM
Nov 11

Umair Haque broke this all down, in an article, that was linked to here in DU, 4 years ago titled: America’s Problem is That White People Want It to Be a Failed State Can America Solve the Problem of the White American Voter? Published in
Eudaimonia and Co Nov 1, 2020

He wrote the following:

"White Americans want America to be a failed state — and that is its fundamental, deep, and long standing problem. That is how America ended up here — more than half a century of white hostility to any kind of social progress whatsoever — which resulted in social collapse, and culminated in Trumpism. White people made America a failed state."

America’s problem is that white Americans as a social group, its majority social group, want America to be a failed state. They don’t want to live in a modern, civilized democracy, and never have.



Who voted, over and over again, to have worse lives? No healthcare, retirement, affordable education, childcare — no public goods of any kind whatsoever? White Americans did. What the? The question baffles the world. Why would anyone choose a worse life? The answer is that white Americans would not accept a society of true equals. “I won’t pay for those dirty, filthy peoples’ educations, healthcare, retirements! Why, their grandparents were my grandpappy’s slaves!” White Americans chose to retain power, supremacy, superiority, even in a failing society. They chose staying on top of decline and ruin, rather than prospering as equals.

It confounds people from all over the world. "How?" "Why?" they ask. The reason is very, very obvious.
White Americans are the rich world’s most hostile, ignorant, violent, cruel, and selfish social group — by a very long way. “Voting conservative” after all doesn’t mean nearly the same thing in Europe or Canada. There, even conservative parties agree on the basics — people should have healthcare, education, retirement, that the only point of the public purse isn’t endless war and death machines. Conservatism in America is off the charts, and so “voting” that way carries a very different meaning. It means that White Americans are the rich world’s most regressive, ignorant, and self-destructive political bloc — by such a long way that they might as well not be in the rich world at all.(ibid)


This is the fundamental blind spot that Rev. Barber, Bernie Sanders, every so called "progressive", Liberal and yes, even Leftists refuse to see.
When pundits talk about "messaging", the only message that white Americans will ever respond to will be the repeal of the Voting Rights Act. That's what it would take. LBJ KNEW what was going to happen when he signed the bill in 1964 that the Democrats would lose the South for at least a generation; that's what Nixon's Southern Strategy was all about. And dammit, it worked. "It's the RACISM and now the MISOGYNY!"

The economy is the fig leaf rationale that covers the actual reason. Because white Americans' self image of themselves contradicts their very ugly actions, they gaslight themselves and others into believing the lie. But, actions speak louder than words, don't they?

Since 1964, no Democrat has won the majority of white votes. Now, what politically seismic event happened in 1964? Look at the voting patterns
https://www.americanprogress.org/article/what-about-white-voters/
Hello?

W.E.B. DuBois, who was a Socialist, who read Marx, observed that white Americans do not identify along class lines but racial ones:
"It must be remembered that the white group of laborers, while they received a low wage, were compensated in part by a sort of public and psychological wage. They were given public deference and titles of courtesy because they were white. They were admitted freely with all classes of white people to public functions, public parks, and the best schools. The police were drawn from their ranks, and the courts, dependent upon their votes, treated them with such leniency as to encourage lawlessness. Their vote selected public officials, and while this had small effect upon the economic situation, it had great effect upon their personal treatment and the deference shown them. White schoolhouses were the best in the community, and conspicuously placed, and they cost anywhere from twice to ten times as much per capita as the colored schools. The newspapers specialized on news that flattered the poor whites and almost utterly ignored the Negro except in crime and ridicule."From "Black Reconstruction in America: An Essay Toward a History of the Part Which Black Folk Played in the Attempt to Reconstruct Democracy in America, 1860–1880" (1935)
-

What did LBJ say? "If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you."
And they did, didn't they? He was basically robbing them and they voted for him anyway.

Face it, America. This is a country of white supremacists, misogynists, bigots and racists. White America has spoken. They chose, consistently, white male mediocrity over female and Black excellence. Black folks, especially Black women are done with maintaining the charade that Americans are serious about peace and prosperity. White Americans got us into this, only white Americans can fix it. But y'all got to get over your delusions, first.

“If you don't understand white supremacy/racism ,everything that you do understand will only confuse you..”― Neely Fuller, Jr., The United Independent Compensatory Code System Concept a textbook/workbook for Thought, Speech and/or Action for Victims of Racism







Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I think it's hard to pin it on any one thing. Elessar Zappa Nov 10 #1
I agree that it wasn't just one thing, but I'm reading a lot of analyses Ocelot II Nov 10 #4
It wasn't just one thing. It also wasn't just one constituency. InstantGratification Nov 10 #18
Yes I don't buy the economy claim Tribetime Nov 10 #70
I agree except... Trust_Reality Nov 11 #89
I just want to say godblessyou for this post n/t BaronChocula Nov 11 #81
I agree with this assessment.nt jfz9580m Nov 10 #16
Don't forget racism! Native Nov 10 #17
it was the misogeny and the racsim Ray Bruns Nov 10 #38
This white man is proud to have went for Harris EnergizedLib Nov 10 #2
It wasn't the economy. That was an excuse. CousinIT Nov 10 #3
Bingo. My point exactly. Ocelot II Nov 10 #5
+1, the German economy was doing relatively well when Nazi part won 37% or parliament. The excuse that it was the ... uponit7771 Nov 10 #7
JoJo from Jerz's mom didn't raise no idjits. soldierant Nov 10 #41
☝🏾THIS!!☝🏾 Robison was ***JUST LIKE*** Trump without crime and MAGA dropped him like a hot rock and he lost !! uponit7771 Nov 10 #6
"She is for they/them. He is for you." Duncan Grant Nov 10 #8
"Culture war" krkaufman Nov 10 #24
I like the way you put it Ohioboy Nov 11 #76
They ran that gender-affirming care for incarcerated trans people commercial relentlessly. Shermann Nov 10 #34
I have this feeling that MAGA, having got what they wanted ismnotwasm Nov 10 #9
Repugs are the dogs that caught the car again. Trouble is they won't know what allegorical oracle Nov 10 #15
I JUST sent that to a friend; "they caught the car, lets see what they do with it" hootman Nov 10 #32
True. But we are here to point out, that this, is exactly what they voted for ismnotwasm Nov 10 #36
I think it's the latter. calimary Nov 11 #90
We need to wear T-shirts that say "Don't blame me for this, I voted for Kamala" FakeNoose Nov 10 #31
Yup! ismnotwasm Nov 10 #35
My neighboor flew a big ass flag that read " don't blame me , I voted for trump" during President Biden's term. debm55 Nov 10 #42
It wasn't the economy Jrsygrl96 Nov 10 #10
I think it's a lot more than Black and Latino men. Katinfl Nov 10 #30
White women as well DemonGoddess Nov 10 #40
Black Men voted for Harris in very similar percentages as they voted for Biden (77% vs 79%) Wiz Imp Nov 10 #46
Don't say Black men. Yavin4 Nov 10 #62
I'm not buying that entirely Ontheboundry Nov 11 #82
If Trump was non white like the crazy North Carolina candidate JI7 Nov 10 #11
"It's the economy, stupid." Carville's mantra. cachukis Nov 10 #12
"No, it's about YOUR economy, stupid. Mine is really good!" Jit423 Nov 10 #55
I think you missed my point. cachukis Nov 10 #57
Yes, that explanation doesn't sit well with me Mike 03 Nov 10 #13
white women who voted for him were probably living lives of quiet desperation of some degree, IMO. CTyankee Nov 10 #19
White women vote white first, class second, women third. TheKentuckian Nov 10 #58
I know SO many white women who voted for him & I cant understand it. hootman Nov 10 #33
I don't think it was ALL about the economy, but I do think it was PARTLY about the economy In It to Win It Nov 10 #14
My current favorite quote: TxGuitar Nov 10 #20
The economy was a cover story for Russia & Elon Musk's attack on our voting systems. Botany Nov 10 #21
Just like we saw in 2016 much of their economic anxiety is already receding TheKentuckian Nov 10 #22
I think the answer is pretty obvious..this country is too racist and misogynistic to elect a FE president PortTack Nov 10 #23
Economists overwhelmingly agree Trump's policies will INCREASE inflation Martin Eden Nov 10 #25
Democrats never defended the economy strongly enough. kentuck Nov 10 #26
A brilliant, short piece about what voters were thinking Akakoji Nov 10 #27
It was misinformation disinformation misinformation disinformation oldmanlynn Nov 10 #28
Yes, an avalanche of disinformation... Trust_Reality Nov 11 #91
The Repukes said it was "all about the economy" FakeNoose Nov 10 #29
40+ years of trickle down economics has poli-junkie Nov 10 #37
Have to address the stupid part of that Akakoji Nov 10 #48
The economy is booming PennRalphie Nov 10 #39
Chump won on a positive message is a tough sell. TheKentuckian Nov 10 #59
One of the other things which played into it DemonGoddess Nov 10 #43
No, it WASN'T about the economy. And IMO, saying so just B.See Nov 10 #44
Disagree Akakoji Nov 10 #49
Well I don't think it was mainly the economy B.See Nov 10 #56
But What Is The Trump Plan For Cheap Eggs? DallasNE Nov 10 #45
I'm not buying the economy BS. If that's the case, you have no effin morals, no effin principles tulipsandroses Nov 10 #47
The bulk of voters vote with what's poli-junkie Nov 10 #50
It wasn't the economy Dlpger61 Nov 10 #60
Tariffs, tax cuts for the super rich, austerity, vaccine hokum, 7 trillion of empty debt, mass deportations are going to TheKentuckian Nov 10 #61
Plus a gazillion. love_katz Nov 10 #69
It was about inflation and Republican propaganda Emile Nov 10 #51
Ocelot II FTW. madaboutharry Nov 10 #52
It was all about maintaining the white anglo male power base GoreWon2000 Nov 10 #53
I think it's an after-the-fact cover story morillon Nov 10 #54
It isn't about the ones who voted for Harris. Ms. Toad Nov 10 #63
"And that is largely pocketbook economy and Gaza" TheKentuckian Nov 11 #78
It was about the economy, get over it. Xolodno Nov 10 #64
"Get over it"? Ocelot II Nov 10 #65
Simple. They didn't show up. Xolodno Nov 10 #66
More fucking stupid. TheKentuckian Nov 11 #75
Amazing, isn't it? dpibel Nov 11 #77
Mindblowing indeed. TheKentuckian Nov 11 #80
If you are going to sell your nation and daughters for a dozen eggs TheKentuckian Nov 11 #72
This here... Xolodno Nov 11 #103
You identify where I'm wrong and I will earnestly consider it. TheKentuckian Nov 11 #104
Well, let me put it this way. Xolodno Nov 11 #105
I know full well. I've been homeless for crying out loud. TheKentuckian Nov 11 #106
Understood. And I sympathize. Xolodno Nov 11 #107
Thank you. I feel the argument is they behaved in a justifiable fashion so I'm glad TheKentuckian Nov 11 #108
False. Jobs grew under Biden. yardwork Nov 11 #93
You demonstrated my point perfectly. Xolodno Nov 11 #99
You didn't say anything about low wages. yardwork Nov 11 #100
I have in other posts... Xolodno Nov 11 #101
What bugs me about that claim is that it was really the stupid misogyny, the hatred of women Hekate Nov 10 #67
You are 100% correct. oasis Nov 10 #68
Sometimes, I am embarrassed to be a white woman. BlueKentuckyGirl Nov 11 #71
A sister from another mister. BattleRow Nov 11 #73
economy, racism, misogyny, other bigotries... Kali Nov 11 #74
"all about the Economy" is just racist misogynistic code for... MrWowWow Nov 11 #79
Guessing nobody saw the NPR interview Friday Ontheboundry Nov 11 #83
Of course it was "the economy stupid" FBaggins Nov 11 #84
They are much more stupid than racist or sexist. TheKentuckian Nov 11 #110
The Canadian British Economist DAngelo136 Nov 11 #85
It's not about the economy. In 3 months were going to be hearing that the economy is great. n/t D23MIURG23 Nov 11 #86
By the end of January MAGA will be bragging to beat the band TheKentuckian Nov 11 #111
Not the economy Linda ladeewolf Nov 11 #87
Just a question bdamomma Nov 11 #88
Of course! yardwork Nov 11 #92
The threat of Trump's tariffs is already impacting how businesses operate, steering money away from bonuses and raises LetMyPeopleVote Nov 11 #94
Not buying the economy either. Sexism/racism. 58Sunliner Nov 11 #95
It WASN'T The Economy PaulnFortWorth Nov 11 #96
IN MY BRAIN It was All About National Security , Trump wanted the Office & the Office wanted bonniebgood Nov 11 #97
Democrats lost the vote of people making under $50k for the first time iemanja Nov 11 #98
Of course Opbrg Nov 11 #102
It was NEVER about "the economy" Blue_Tires Nov 11 #109
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Ya know what bugs me abou...»Reply #85