Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

haele

(13,712 posts)
21. Officers can only be purged by the President during time of War
Tue Nov 12, 2024, 10:30 PM
Nov 12

Other than that, they're either removed from command for lack of confidence (but not purged) or they're discharged under the UCMJ by either courts martial or vote of Congress.

His "Warrior Board" can't really do shit. Joint Chiefs, maybe can remove a general or Admiral from a command, but they can't be "fired" and removed from service. And there's billets that need to be filled by qualified officers, otherwise, the Military slowly grinds to a halt.
This ain't WWII Germany with a limited number of senior officers from "Good Families" and a social caste system that guaranteed pretty much all officers were raised from an isolated childhood to be officers.
This is the USA, where officers come from all walks of life through several different methods, even through the enlisted ranks, and non-commissioned officers are trained to command units if they have to.
A "Warrior board" suggests that a very subjective and narrow criteria will be used that would not meet the actual needs of a successful military infrastructure. I also wonder how it would affect non-combatant units that are necessary to support all those "warriors" out in the field.

Haele

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Putin does not want the US military to be the envy of the world. Irish_Dem Nov 12 #1
Trump keeps emulating Hitler C_U_L8R Nov 12 #2
He kept Mein Kampf on his bedside table MiniMe Nov 12 #3
This book had a gun on the bedside table C_U_L8R Nov 12 #4
Actually, it was a book of hitler's speeches. niyad Nov 12 #6
Russia is losing 1,300 soldiers a day fighting Ukraine because... surfered Nov 12 #5
Of Course It Does Blue Jean Nov 12 #13
Not the only one xuplate Nov 12 #7
Yes, it's a living nightmare apparently headed for Cha Nov 12 #8
Will the generals do the right thing and resist the Orange dick-tator? Let's hope so. Magoo48 Nov 12 #9
The following Hitler's Generals were involved in the several different plots to assassinate Hitler: surfered Nov 12 #10
Wasn't Rommel complicit in the July 1944 Ilsa Nov 12 #17
Yep. kerry-is-my-prez Nov 12 #19
Apparently, most Americans don't care. sinkingfeeling Nov 12 #11
It's not that we don't care... Trueblue Texan Nov 12 #15
I've been posting all this in my Facebook but don't seem to get many responses. kerry-is-my-prez Nov 12 #20
I wonder what role the courts can play in this? Can he fire generals he deems non loyal yes, can he force a PortTack Nov 12 #12
Don't forget what happened to the students shot and killed at Kent State. kerry-is-my-prez Nov 12 #22
He told you he was going to do this. Why are you so surprised? Tansy_Gold Nov 12 #14
For those that do not know what DEFCON..........means turbinetree Nov 12 #16
This is downright scary. He also wants the House to pass a bill kerry-is-my-prez Nov 12 #18
Officers can only be purged by the President during time of War haele Nov 12 #21
Just proposing such a pledge is treasonous. Kid Berwyn Nov 12 #23
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»NEW: VoteVets Responds To...»Reply #21