General Discussion

Voltaire2

(14,878 posts)

12. In a curious evolution of language

Fri Nov 22, 2024, 09:55 AM

Nov 22

The term antisemitic has become ‘anti semitic people who are culturally Jewish’.

It is understood that the term does not apply to Palestinians, for example, even though many such people have distant Jewish ancestors.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

67 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Netanyahu says that those who say he is committing a war crime by bombing and starving the civilians of Gaza..... [View all] MMBeilis Nov 22 OP

Isn't it claudette Nov 22 #1

In deductive logic, this maneuver is called "Begging the Question". no_hypocrisy Nov 22 #2

Uh no that is not begging the question Voltaire2 Nov 22 #7

Point taken. no_hypocrisy Nov 22 #8

Straw man ananda Nov 22 #9

It is more a bit of non-sequitur and ad hominem Voltaire2 Nov 22 #11

Agreed. Warmonger Netanyahu calls anyone criticizing his action an anti-semite. brush Dec 2 #52

It's the kind of B.See Dec 2 #54

Not to mention that people who are Arabs ARE SEMITES!! AND...what part of things does he NOT understand that YOU DON'T The_REAL_Ecumenist Nov 22 #3

When you apply the term Semitic to Jews and Arabs as an ethnicity sarisataka Nov 22 #19

The average person isn't going to know all that soandso Dec 1 #33

This should be watched by everyone who has an opinion about Israel and the Palestinians, especially the apologists.... MMBeilis Dec 2 #57

No Cirsium Dec 1 #28

People who make that "semite" point are usually antisemites JoseBalow Dec 1 #37

So, are you telling me that I'M AN ANTISEMITE? ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!! YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW ME!! The_REAL_Ecumenist Dec 2 #47

I find that people that throw out that 'anti semite' tripe canuckledragger Dec 2 #59

I DON'T care what you THINK it applies to...We've ALL heard the pejoratives calling people who are Arab OR have Arabic The_REAL_Ecumenist Dec 2 #46

I know Cirsium Dec 2 #56

No doubt that Bibi is commiting war crimes. No doubt that Hamas & Hezbolla are... electric_blue68 Dec 2 #61

Palestinians are semitic. So he's being antisemitic. Blue Full Moon Nov 22 #4

In a curious evolution of language Voltaire2 Nov 22 #12

Actually ...... Mossfern Nov 22 #16

They have the same DNA. Religion is what split them. Blue Full Moon Nov 22 #22

There are more genetic differences within multigraincracker Dec 1 #36

I am anti-Zionist malaise Dec 1 #25

Right you are. History of Zionist Terrorism. multigraincracker Dec 3 #66

You might want to avoid applying the racist term semitic to the Palestinians sarisataka Nov 22 #20

This may be D.U.'s original "opening a can of worms". MMBeilis Dec 1 #24

Ok Macrophylla Nov 22 #5

Of course not. Regarding Netanyahu our expectations are limited to more arrogance and self righteous and nothing more. MMBeilis Dec 1 #40

Guess I'm anti-Semitic then. Aussie105 Nov 22 #6

"The term 'anti-Semitic', being so overused to mean 'complaining about Israeli action' holds no meaning anymore." Rigpa108 Dec 1 #34

Out of the same playbook... 2naSalit Nov 22 #10

Okay so that makes me antisemitic. I agree with the ICC, what he has done is war crimes. Autumn Nov 22 #13

Add me malaise Dec 1 #26

The boy who cried wolf peregrinus Nov 22 #14

They are Zeitghost Nov 22 #15

Judging war crimes based on the ethnicity of the perpetrator is fucking stupid. Iggo Nov 22 #17

It that true? Look at all of the warrants for the perpetrators of the genocide in Sudan... sarisataka Nov 22 #21

Let's not forget there was a warrant for Ibrahim Al-Masri too, I hear he is just broken up in pieces that he won't tritsofme Nov 22 #18

It's too late to persuade anybody. yardwork Nov 22 #23

White Christians voted overwhemlingly for dump also. Eko Dec 1 #29

Thats not true Mosby Dec 1 #30

Huh. Eko Dec 1 #32

Bibi's sweeping generalization is a sweeping fail sakabatou Dec 1 #27

Absolutely true. The entire Middle East conflict is built upon sweeping generalizations. MMBeilis Dec 1 #43

Yep, "..even when done in one's own self-defense.." like Coates said, there is no justification for apartheid uponit7771 Dec 1 #31

How convenient. ZonkerHarris Dec 1 #35

Yeah, you can't criticize bibi or the atrocities against Palestinians Lunabell Dec 1 #38

The irony of his statement. Xolodno Dec 1 #39

Some may share ancestors soandso Dec 2 #48

Let's not forget the Khazars... Xolodno Dec 2 #49

Same people soandso Dec 2 #53

Interesting that my original post gets lost in a bunch of bullshit (my words) about who is a semite. We know.... MMBeilis Dec 1 #41

Netanyahu's actions STRENGTHEN anti-semitism, worldwide. Jack Valentino Dec 1 #42

This message was self-deleted by its author Behind the Aegis Dec 2 #44

thread winner Celerity Dec 2 #50

Post removed Post removed Dec 2 #45

Rich enid602 Dec 2 #51

I wonder what the excuse for this will be soandso Dec 2 #55

They will say "She was Hamas" Bettie Dec 2 #58

Not just Netanyahu. (n/t) Iggo Dec 2 #60

When you wake up a hibernating big Bear and then, the pissed-off bear starts kicking your ass... chouchou Dec 2 #62

Hibernating? Every day West Bank settlers mistreat Palestinian arabs. You did get..... MMBeilis Dec 3 #63

Hamas has been at their throat fo generations. Isreal is fed up with the Up-the-population-until-we-take-over-everything chouchou Dec 3 #65

Again, the settler families are doing their part having huge families and the government is subsidizing them. MMBeilis Dec 3 #67

This term, antisemitic-ism is over used and losing the meaning it once had. It not stands for Jit423 Dec 3 #64