Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bluetus

(301 posts)
38. I didn't take the hippocratic oath. :)
Fri Nov 22, 2024, 10:53 PM
Nov 22

And I respect all the medical people who do honor that code, regardless of a person's ethnicity, education level, economic status, or tendency toward self-destruction. However, we also learned there were hundreds of thousands of people in the medical profession who didn't give a shit about protecting people during COVID.

Personally, I would have a lot of trouble going the extra mile for a person who spent a lifetime making all the worst decisions, bringing on their own demise or bad fortune.

On a serious note, if we could set aside the ethical questions for just a moment, I do think there is a legitimate argument that there is a significant risk in intervening with people who are too foolish to come in from the rain. I mean, evolution depends on those with the better assets (judgment, intelligence, whatever) having a higher survival rate. When we intervene, we really are messing with evolutionary process. I know medical ethics don't leave any room for such thinking, but I do believe it is worth pondering, in the same sense that one ponders whether the beat of a single butterfly could alter the course of the universe.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Equitable health care in the USA? Diamond_Dog Nov 22 #1
Equitable health care is like equal justice under the law. LudwigPastorius Nov 22 #21
Yep Diamond_Dog Nov 22 #22
I have 400-lbs patients with their teeth rotting out of the heads Aristus Nov 22 #2
Gatorade -- it's got electrolytes! Zorro Nov 22 #3
I've actually had patients say that to me. Aristus Nov 22 #5
No Gatorade! But try to design a menu that meets potassium requirements rainin Nov 22 #14
Bananas, cantaloupe, apricots, lentils, kidney beans, Aristus Nov 22 #23
Getting a list of "high" potassium foods is elementary. Creating a menu that actually provides enough rainin Nov 22 #30
Well, I don't know what to tell you. Aristus Nov 22 #32
See reply 33. highplainsdem Nov 22 #34
It is hard to get the recommended levels in diet Meowmee Nov 22 #37
Except for bananas, those aren't foods Americans are likely to eat almost daily. A baked potato with skin, highplainsdem Nov 22 #33
So: easily accessible and palatable potassium. Aristus Nov 22 #35
Yes. Most people, I've found, automatically think of bananas for potassium and stop there, and never highplainsdem Nov 22 #36
True, unless they live on Top Ramen and Cup-O-Noodles. Exp Nov 22 #16
Idiocracy comes to life Stuckinthebush Nov 22 #6
It is a Polkyannaish fairytale and we can only hope TheKentuckian Nov 22 #26
Nice analysis. Stuckinthebush Nov 22 #28
It's what plants crave! EYESORE 9001 Nov 22 #8
Totally agree. talking-liberally Nov 22 #18
The great tragedy of this country is the way... ananda Nov 22 #24
Darwin serves a useful purpose Bluetus Nov 22 #27
Except that these are my patients and I love them. Aristus Nov 22 #29
I didn't take the hippocratic oath. :) Bluetus Nov 22 #38
You dont get to 400 lbs drinking gatorade and most fat people go for coke etc.. berkerly6240 Nov 22 #39
No. There's more to it than that. Don't get hung up on the Gatorade. Aristus Nov 22 #40
Wealthy areas attract more and better doctors and medical facilities bucolic_frolic Nov 22 #4
That's a feature in zero sum/ownership capitalism, not a bug. haele Nov 22 #7
The National Institute of Health says that 42 percent of American adults are obese or severely obese. LaMouffette Nov 22 #9
I pretty much live on junk food and I have never been overweight Skittles Nov 22 #31
Maybe the Federal government should have banned menthol cigarettes instead of stalling for a over a decade MichMan Nov 22 #10
FDA Old Okie Nov 22 #12
The FDA does not require the approval of Congress to ban menthol cigarettes MichMan Nov 22 #15
Affordable Care might turn out to be a BFD. Let's ask that nice young man Obama before his hair goes gray Hekate Nov 22 #11
Imagine what it's going to be when Brain Worm and his conspiracy goons ban vaccines. Initech Nov 22 #13
The Pine Ridge Reservation markodochartaigh Nov 22 #17
That's the real gap Johnny2X2X Nov 22 #19
Not surprising, area51 Nov 22 #20
Republicans knew Blue Full Moon Nov 22 #25
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Life expectancy gap in U....»Reply #38