General Discussion

Jit423

(429 posts)

64. This term, antisemitic-ism is over used and losing the meaning it once had. It not stands for

Reply to MMBeilis (Original post)

Tue Dec 3, 2024, 04:42 AM

Dec 3

re-frame the issue and stop any criticism of what Israel is doing now.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

AloeVera

67 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Netanyahu says that those who say he is committing a war crime by bombing and starving the civilians of Gaza..... [View all] MMBeilis Nov 22 OP

Isn't it claudette Nov 22 #1

In deductive logic, this maneuver is called "Begging the Question". no_hypocrisy Nov 22 #2

Uh no that is not begging the question Voltaire2 Nov 22 #7

Point taken. no_hypocrisy Nov 22 #8

Straw man ananda Nov 22 #9

It is more a bit of non-sequitur and ad hominem Voltaire2 Nov 22 #11

Agreed. Warmonger Netanyahu calls anyone criticizing his action an anti-semite. brush Dec 2 #52

It's the kind of B.See Dec 2 #54

Not to mention that people who are Arabs ARE SEMITES!! AND...what part of things does he NOT understand that YOU DON'T The_REAL_Ecumenist Nov 22 #3

When you apply the term Semitic to Jews and Arabs as an ethnicity sarisataka Nov 22 #19

The average person isn't going to know all that soandso Dec 1 #33

This should be watched by everyone who has an opinion about Israel and the Palestinians, especially the apologists.... MMBeilis Dec 2 #57

No Cirsium Dec 1 #28

People who make that "semite" point are usually antisemites JoseBalow Dec 1 #37

So, are you telling me that I'M AN ANTISEMITE? ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!! YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW ME!! The_REAL_Ecumenist Dec 2 #47

I find that people that throw out that 'anti semite' tripe canuckledragger Dec 2 #59

I DON'T care what you THINK it applies to...We've ALL heard the pejoratives calling people who are Arab OR have Arabic The_REAL_Ecumenist Dec 2 #46

I know Cirsium Dec 2 #56

No doubt that Bibi is commiting war crimes. No doubt that Hamas & Hezbolla are... electric_blue68 Dec 2 #61

Palestinians are semitic. So he's being antisemitic. Blue Full Moon Nov 22 #4

In a curious evolution of language Voltaire2 Nov 22 #12

Actually ...... Mossfern Nov 22 #16

They have the same DNA. Religion is what split them. Blue Full Moon Nov 22 #22

There are more genetic differences within multigraincracker Dec 1 #36

I am anti-Zionist malaise Dec 1 #25

Right you are. History of Zionist Terrorism. multigraincracker Dec 3 #66

You might want to avoid applying the racist term semitic to the Palestinians sarisataka Nov 22 #20

This may be D.U.'s original "opening a can of worms". MMBeilis Dec 1 #24

Ok Macrophylla Nov 22 #5

Of course not. Regarding Netanyahu our expectations are limited to more arrogance and self righteous and nothing more. MMBeilis Dec 1 #40

Guess I'm anti-Semitic then. Aussie105 Nov 22 #6

"The term 'anti-Semitic', being so overused to mean 'complaining about Israeli action' holds no meaning anymore." Rigpa108 Dec 1 #34

Out of the same playbook... 2naSalit Nov 22 #10

Okay so that makes me antisemitic. I agree with the ICC, what he has done is war crimes. Autumn Nov 22 #13

Add me malaise Dec 1 #26

The boy who cried wolf peregrinus Nov 22 #14

They are Zeitghost Nov 22 #15

Judging war crimes based on the ethnicity of the perpetrator is fucking stupid. Iggo Nov 22 #17

It that true? Look at all of the warrants for the perpetrators of the genocide in Sudan... sarisataka Nov 22 #21

Let's not forget there was a warrant for Ibrahim Al-Masri too, I hear he is just broken up in pieces that he won't tritsofme Nov 22 #18

It's too late to persuade anybody. yardwork Nov 22 #23

White Christians voted overwhemlingly for dump also. Eko Dec 1 #29

Thats not true Mosby Dec 1 #30

Huh. Eko Dec 1 #32

Bibi's sweeping generalization is a sweeping fail sakabatou Dec 1 #27

Absolutely true. The entire Middle East conflict is built upon sweeping generalizations. MMBeilis Dec 1 #43

Yep, "..even when done in one's own self-defense.." like Coates said, there is no justification for apartheid uponit7771 Dec 1 #31

How convenient. ZonkerHarris Dec 1 #35

Yeah, you can't criticize bibi or the atrocities against Palestinians Lunabell Dec 1 #38

The irony of his statement. Xolodno Dec 1 #39

Some may share ancestors soandso Dec 2 #48

Let's not forget the Khazars... Xolodno Dec 2 #49

Same people soandso Dec 2 #53

Interesting that my original post gets lost in a bunch of bullshit (my words) about who is a semite. We know.... MMBeilis Dec 1 #41

Netanyahu's actions STRENGTHEN anti-semitism, worldwide. Jack Valentino Dec 1 #42

This message was self-deleted by its author Behind the Aegis Dec 2 #44

thread winner Celerity Dec 2 #50

Post removed Post removed Dec 2 #45

Rich enid602 Dec 2 #51

I wonder what the excuse for this will be soandso Dec 2 #55

They will say "She was Hamas" Bettie Dec 2 #58

Not just Netanyahu. (n/t) Iggo Dec 2 #60

When you wake up a hibernating big Bear and then, the pissed-off bear starts kicking your ass... chouchou Dec 2 #62

Hibernating? Every day West Bank settlers mistreat Palestinian arabs. You did get..... MMBeilis Dec 3 #63

Hamas has been at their throat fo generations. Isreal is fed up with the Up-the-population-until-we-take-over-everything chouchou Dec 3 #65

Again, the settler families are doing their part having huge families and the government is subsidizing them. MMBeilis Dec 3 #67

This term, antisemitic-ism is over used and losing the meaning it once had. It not stands for Jit423 Dec 3 #64