Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Beastly Boy

(11,311 posts)

22. Then,

Reply to al bupp (Reply #1)

Thu Dec 5, 2024, 02:50 PM

Dec 5

the US claims to the same are not credible (https://www.ynetnews.com/article/sjvqmuynjx)

and Amnesty's own members' claims to the same are not credible (https://www.barrons.com/news/amnesty-israel-branch-rejects-genocide-report-calls-to-probe-serious-crimes-aee7ad58)

But what do they know, right?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

43 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Amnesty International Investigation Concludes Israel Is Committing Genocide [View all] al bupp Dec 4 OP

Israel's Claims Are 'Not Credible' al bupp Dec 4 #1

Then, Beastly Boy Dec 5 #22

Amnesty Israel has no credibility on the topic of genocide in Gaza al bupp Dec 11 #23

Daniel Brodsky has no credibility Beastly Boy Dec 12 #24

Why shouldn't he advocate for Palestinians? al bupp Dec 12 #25

He should if he wants to. Beastly Boy Dec 12 #26

If that's true al bupp Dec 12 #27

If what you say were true, then Beastly Boy Dec 13 #29

Your comparison of the report to the Nuremburg trials is spurious at best and ridiculous on its face al bupp Dec 13 #32

It is Daniel Brodsky who is calling himself partial, not me. Beastly Boy Dec 13 #33

Maybe it's "rant" to you al bupp Dec 14 #37

Actually, al bupp, Amnesty International has a long and sordid history of demonizing Israel. madaboutharry Dec 4 #2

Amnesty International is a highly credible human rights organization. ColinC Dec 4 #3

Was a highly credible organization. That was last century. Beastly Boy Dec 4 #7

Just because you don't like what they say doesn't suddenly change their credibility ColinC Dec 5 #16

It's not what I like. It's what they say and how they say it. Beastly Boy Dec 5 #19

Here we go peregrinus Dec 4 #4

When all criticism of Israel is deemed antisemitic al bupp Dec 4 #5

What happens when only certain criticism of Israel is deemed antisemitic, and others are not? Beastly Boy Dec 4 #8

I think AM would make similar accusations against any country al bupp Dec 4 #9

I am not holding my breath waiting for Amnesty to hurl an analogous accusation against any other country. Beastly Boy Dec 4 #10

Since the UK and US give so much to Israel al bupp Dec 5 #15

Another false equivalency, as expected Beastly Boy Dec 5 #20

Let's see... al bupp Dec 12 #28

HRW cites jack shit. It offers only the opinions and interpretations that support their predetermined conclusions Beastly Boy Dec 13 #30

No, HRW offers cited facts al bupp Dec 13 #31

A link to a source with no content does not constitute a citation of facts. Nor does it constitute a fact. Beastly Boy Dec 13 #34

Just one source of many that HRW does not control al bupp Dec 14 #36

Actually Avalon Sparks Dec 4 #11

One can easily debunk AJC first point. Eko Dec 5 #13

Amnesty International has hated Israel for years, decades DeepWinter Dec 5 #21

Newsflash iemanja Dec 14 #41

Duh! malaise Dec 4 #6

If Israel wanted to commit genocide... ZRB Dec 5 #12

Sorry, it's ethnic cleansing bordering in genocide Trish6521 Dec 5 #17

What Israel could have just nuked Gaza, is that what you're saying? al bupp Dec 14 #39

And the West Bank and Syria? iemanja Dec 14 #42

Durned Humanitarian organizations keep on opposing war crimes and genocide. Ping Tung Dec 5 #14

Good David__77 Dec 5 #18

While I think that AI's statements are probably valid Crunchy Frog Dec 13 #35

AI is ignoring genocidal acts that Russia is carrying out in Ukraine, hmm al bupp Dec 14 #38

Not a word about genocidal intent or rhetoric. Crunchy Frog Dec 14 #40

Ok, let's dig into this a bit al bupp Dec 14 #43