Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(146,035 posts)
21. Well they most likely take the assignment of the one being replaced
Wed Nov 2, 2022, 01:09 PM
Nov 2022

although in some cases, they might have been born/raised in and/or went to school in one of the states they have jurisdiciton over.

For example, when native Floridian Brown-Jackson came in, she replaced Breyer (a Harvard Law grad) who had jurisdiction over the 1st Circuit (that includes some New England states and Puerto Rico). However both went to Harvard and thus spent time in MA. There was a mention on SCOTUSBlog about that here and her having clerked for judges on the 1st Circuit.

Some other kin examples might be Sonia Sotomayor, who covers the 2nd Circuit which includes NY (and she was born and raised as a NYer), and Alito does the 3rd Circuit, which covers here in PA, as well as NJ & DE (and he is from NJ).

SCOTUSBlog did a nice little ditty on this when there were changes a couple years ago per this (because they do move them around as necessary each session) -

Court issues new circuit assignments
By Amy Howe
on Nov 20, 2020 at 12:06 pm

(snip)

Sotomayor’s move to the 2nd Circuit, which had previously been assigned to the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg (who grew up in New York City and lived there before moving to Washington to become a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit), kicked off a game of musical circuits among the justices. Sotomayor had previously been responsible for the 10th Circuit, which is now assigned to Gorsuch, as well as the 6th Circuit, which is now assigned to Justice Brett Kavanaugh. Kavanaugh, who had previously been assigned to the 7th Circuit, also took on the 8th Circuit, ceding the 7th Circuit to Barrett.

(snip)

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Well, well, well Sanity Claws Nov 2022 #1
Thomas is assigned to the 11th Circuit Court BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #6
But how are the Justices assigned? Farmer-Rick Nov 2022 #18
Well they most likely take the assignment of the one being replaced BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #21
Thanks for the information Farmer-Rick Nov 2022 #42
SCOTUSBlog is a great site BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #44
Assignments are made by the Chief Justice. onenote Nov 2022 #26
Very interesting Farmer-Rick Nov 2022 #43
Ginny was in it up to her neck. Nobody can convince me Ocelot II Nov 2022 #12
K&R ffr Nov 2022 #13
I believe we must have the same MontanaMama Nov 2022 #17
Time to make arrests at the top. Bluethroughu Nov 2022 #19
The Federalist Society cultivated Ginny since she was a loose cannon tied to a justice erronis Nov 2022 #23
They certainly paid her enough. SergeStorms Nov 2022 #31
And Ginny reassured them that good ol' Clarence would be happy to oblige. flying_wahini Nov 2022 #30
Considering that Ginni Thomas was part of the insurrection, they knew what Thomas would Lonestarblue Nov 2022 #22
Were they in contact with the witch Ginny too? LiberalFighter Nov 2022 #2
"They had every base covered." Or so they thought 2live is 2fly Nov 2022 #3
Where is Roberts ? republianmushroom Nov 2022 #4
Hiding under his black robe. The white one is hanging in the SCOTUS cloakroom. erronis Nov 2022 #24
There's more than one. SergeStorms Nov 2022 #32
Clarence would look good in white... erronis Nov 2022 #36
He'll see the same dermatologist.... SergeStorms Nov 2022 #39
busy doing Trump a solid Grimelle Nov 2022 #45
It seems to me they still have the Thomas audible play in motion. Ford_Prefect Nov 2022 #5
What if any are our options here? bluestarone Nov 2022 #7
Not a lawyer but isn't the only option impeachment? Stuckinthebush Nov 2022 #10
From my reading, no action on the part of Thomas is spoken of karynnj Nov 2022 #16
But enough... SergeStorms Nov 2022 #34
Completely agree, but what I don't see is anything that says Thomas agreed to do this karynnj Nov 2022 #53
I fear you're right. bluestarone Nov 2022 #20
News came out last week that Thomas failed to Quakerfriend Nov 2022 #29
Past history. SergeStorms Nov 2022 #35
He really needs to be impeached and there is other evidence of corruption LymphocyteLover Nov 2022 #37
Pardon my ignorance. But can't any person in the US be arrested for crimes? erronis Nov 2022 #25
You would think so. bluestarone Nov 2022 #28
Never forget - DURHAM D Nov 2022 #8
Oh gee, how about that.... hadEnuf Nov 2022 #9
And of course there was no mention of Ginni Thomas ... aggiesal Nov 2022 #11
And remember when that same Justice Clarence Thomas ruled in Bush v Gore Mr.Mystery Nov 2022 #14
That's when this crap all started - Florida was the beginning in 2000 FakeNoose Nov 2022 #27
Freepers were so excited about challenges to the election reaching SCOTUS Kaleva Nov 2022 #15
I think many people are seeing this backwards Novara Nov 2022 #33
Well they put a lot of effort into AZ too (see Ginni) BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #38
And Wisconsin Novara Nov 2022 #40
WI has a Democratic governor BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #41
Good stuff! Ligyron Nov 2022 #52
Even though I am in PA, when Scott Walker finally went bye bye BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #54
How? Biden still would have won. Grins Nov 2022 #46
"only way this could work was to then concentrate on Arizona (11 votes) and Pennsylvania (20 votes)" BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #49
Rapist Thomas needs to be impeached. clementine613 Nov 2022 #47
Two rapists on the SCOTUS. WOW live love laugh Nov 2022 #50
Really? They are all rapists? NH Ethylene Nov 2022 #51
He's the "key" all right. Waterboard him and Ginny and see what secrets come out... Evolve Dammit Nov 2022 #48
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Clarence Thomas was 'key'...»Reply #21