Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ShazzieB

(18,751 posts)
19. Oh, when you said "boyfriend," I assumed you meant the guy who had just broken up with her.
Wed Nov 20, 2024, 04:26 PM
Nov 20

I'm still not sure if that's what you meant, but the boyfriend and the stepfather were 2 different people. The stepfather's name was Beverly Russell, and the boyfriend who dumped her because he didn't want a relationship with kids involved was Tom Findlay.

I followed the case pretty closely at the time, and have also read a book about it, and I don't see any reason to suspect that Smith's husband was not the father of her kids.

Russell molested her when she was a teenager, but the boys were born after she was married to David Smith. It would have been very unusual for the molestation to have continued after she was married and living in her own home with her husband.

As for Findlay, iirc she already had the 2 kids when she got involved with him, and as I said, he dumped her because she didn't want to to be in a relationship with a woman who had kids.

I'm sure that neither the cops or the media dug into the paternity angle because they didn't think there was any reason to do so. She confessed to the crime and has never recanted; and her motive of hoping to get Findlay back seems believable to me. Ymmv, I guess.

A horrific story that has been repeated all too many times since. hlthe2b Nov 20 #1
AND no_hypocrisy Nov 20 #3
Yes... Something that wipes out any attempt to make her sympathetic (assuming she "could" be) hlthe2b Nov 20 #6
NOT in any way an excuse but her whole story is chilling underpants Nov 20 #9
I'm not sure what you mean here. ShazzieB Nov 20 #14
He was her stepfather. He'd started abusing pretty much as soon as he married her mother. underpants Nov 20 #15
Oh, when you said "boyfriend," I assumed you meant the guy who had just broken up with her. ShazzieB Nov 20 #19
Okay. Thanks. I didn't know about the other boyfriend underpants Nov 20 #24
Good. She killed 2 kids horrifically. That should be 2 life sentences. applegrove Nov 20 #2
She is currently serving two life sentences SCantiGOP Nov 20 #16
But it has only been 30 years and she was up for parole. applegrove Nov 20 #17
In SC, a someone with a life sentence SCantiGOP Nov 20 #18
She needs Rebl2 Nov 20 #22
Good. Deuxcents Nov 20 #4
Good! keithbvadu2 Nov 20 #5
Die in prison lady. soon please ZonkerHarris Nov 20 #7
This quote is just beyond sick .... sinkingfeeling Nov 20 #8
sinkingfeeling............ Upthevibe Nov 20 #10
If this is true . . . colorado_ufo Nov 20 #25
Good - denied parole. Vinca Nov 20 #11
Newt Gingrich tried to make political hay of Smith, but it really backfired on him when more came out. Archae Nov 20 #12
Republicans put the spin on it that it's not so bad because she was his adopted, not biological daughter. keithbvadu2 Nov 20 #20
From the "HEY!!! NO FAIR REMEMBERING STUFF!!!" file Montauk6 Nov 20 #13
Are parole boards allowed to BigmanPigman Nov 20 #21
IIRC, she initially said a black man carjacked the vehicle TexasBushwhacker Nov 20 #23
Blamed it on a black carjacker maxrandb Nov 20 #26
Good. LoisB Nov 20 #27
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Susan Smith, who killed h...»Reply #19