Latest Breaking News

ms liberty

(9,879 posts)

6. My husband knew it was a lie as soon as the story hit the news

Reply to mahatmakanejeeves (Original post)

Fri Dec 13, 2024, 07:27 AM

Dec 13

The lacrosse house was once "Mrs Tyree's" house. My husband was inside that house many times as a child, as was his mother throughout her childhood and youth. My mother in law grew up in that neighborhood, her family lived on Watts St., the street behind the lacrosse house.
The first and main point of contention that I remember them discussing is that she said the whole team was there, but the house is way too small; the whole team could never have fit in that house.
The second point I remember is that she said they were yelling stuff at her as she left, but that house faces Buchanan Blvd (which is also Guess Rd) right across from the Duke East Campus (a park area with a lovely low stone wall that has a popular running/walking path) it's a very busy road and the park area is used a lot in the day and evening. I didn't believe that because it's just not quiet around there until late evening.

There were a lot of people here who were adamant she was telling the truth. I never believed her, because of the details that were not believable.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

5 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

raging moderate TheRickles IbogaProject LauraInLA MamaTrades

55 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Crystal Mangum admits to fabricating 2006 Duke lacrosse scandal accusations [View all] mahatmakanejeeves Dec 13 OP

Having both a daughter and son around that age, I could see both sides -- till my elderly mother pnwmom Dec 13 #1

Everyone makes mistakes RandiFan1290 Dec 13 #2

Those mistakes are really humbling and they remind me never Mike 03 Dec 13 #3

I don't remember. Could you show me a link? pnwmom Dec 13 #4

The photo was reported and removed by the jury. RandiFan1290 Dec 13 #5

My husband knew it was a lie as soon as the story hit the news ms liberty Dec 13 #6

that house was torn down several years ago. cab67 Dec 13 #23

This is why you can't believe anything until there is proof. BlueTsunami2018 Dec 13 #7

I'm reminded of that football player in college, who was falsely accused. Archae Dec 13 #9

They made a movie about that case. cab67 Dec 13 #42

"I can easily find all those articles at DU from the spring of 2006 about his incident." Prairie Gates Dec 13 #8

It's what I do. mahatmakanejeeves Dec 13 #10

I bookmarked a few threads leading up to the election Polybius Dec 13 #30

You're lucky. As someone "new" here, I was called a troll. Self Esteem Dec 14 #51

I remember on here most everyone here were calling them scumbag rich kids who needed to be metaphorically AZLD4Candidate Dec 13 #11

Standing up for due process was a risky proposition at DU back then Shrek Dec 13 #12

It remains so. TheProle Dec 13 #31

Over the last week or so sarisataka Dec 13 #32

Thanks Crystal. Clouds Passing Dec 13 #13

My Reaction Exactly RobinA Dec 13 #18

The more the media amplify stories like that the less likely rape victims are to be believed. Clouds Passing Dec 13 #19

This is why prosecutors sometimes decline to prosecute those who lie about these things. cab67 Dec 13 #43

In the 1940s, my father rented a room in the home of a prison warden Jarqui Dec 13 #14

And what is nearly always left out of the discussion of this dsc Dec 13 #15

If these had been three poor kids instead of Duke athletes they would have likely gone to prison. jalan48 Dec 13 #16

I believe that you are correct. mahatmakanejeeves Dec 13 #17

one of the most disturbing aspects of this case... cab67 Dec 13 #20

I'm all for the remaining "Gang of 81" faculty members being required to publicly, not in a Tweet or a written statement Seeking Serenity Dec 14 #52

The whole follow-up from that was a travesty. cab67 Dec 14 #54

This was a tragic fiasco on so many levels. yardwork Dec 13 #21

I had to stay out of the discussions here back then GusBob Dec 13 #22

In 1992 my friend was accused by her girlfriend of rape. It was a flashpoint on campus LauraInLA Dec 13 #44

Do you mean "could not"? Bernardo de La Paz Dec 14 #49

Eeek! Yes, thanks for catching it! LauraInLA Dec 14 #50

Tawawna Brawley redux. Sneederbunk Dec 13 #24

The case that radicalized many against Democrats mathematic Dec 13 #25

People wanted them to be guilty because they were 3 white "affluent" young men cabotnn22 Dec 13 #26

I believed her, but I didn't comment publicly. Beakybird Dec 13 #27

I don't care what she has to say. Basso8vb Dec 13 #28

There's a lot of people that ended up wrong about this sitation Renew Deal Dec 13 #29

The statute of limitations in rape/ sexual assault cases Mr.Bill Dec 13 #33

I think it's always important to reserve judgement. LisaM Dec 13 #34

This message was self-deleted by its author GusBob Dec 13 #35

Different story. That was UVa. mahatmakanejeeves Dec 13 #36

oops GusBob Dec 13 #37

This is why you always assume innocence IbogaProject Dec 13 #38

Okay, fine... 18 years later I stand corrected Blue_Tires Dec 13 #39

Perhaps if she had been prosecuted for perjury she would not have had the opportunity to commit murder Jose Garcia Dec 13 #40

so she basically ruins several peoples lives with her lies and now, almost 20 years later Javaman Dec 13 #41

I agree with the sentiment, but suing her would just waste a bunch of the plaintiffs' money on lawyers fees. LauraInLA Dec 13 #45

You can't get blood from a stone. LisaL Dec 13 #46

Lack of proofreading leads to deformations too. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Dec 14 #48

I'd sue if she left me deformed. cab67 Dec 14 #53

I believed her, and was very vocal about it here at the time. Moosepoop Dec 14 #47

Shame on her for real victims having more difficulty, and ruining these guys lives. Thinking of the reaction to the CEO electric_blue68 Dec 14 #55