Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BigmanPigman

(52,344 posts)
4. I watched The Last Waltz for the 5th time a few days ago.
Fri Jul 21, 2023, 08:40 PM
Jul 2023

When I heard this song I decided to Google its meaning since it seemed like a pro-confederacy song. It turns out that Robbie Robertson, who is from Canada like the rest of the band except for Helm, and didn't understand the full history of the confederacy.

"The song has faced criticism for some historical liberties and inaccuracies, but it’s always worked with the listeners, most of whom probably don’t know Civil War history any better than Robertson did, and who just view it as a good story song sung by a guy with a distinctive voice. The song found its greatest commercial success not through The Band, though, but through folksinger Joan Baez, who took the song to number three on the Billboard charts for her highest chart appearance ever. It included a lyric change, as Baez had misheard the original; where Helm sang By May 10th Richmond had fell, Baez sang I took the train to Richmond that fell. But her mis-hearing it gave Robertson a big hit as the writer, no matter what the words were."
https://americansongwriter.com/band-night-drove-old-dixie/

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

It's more of an anti-war song than it is a pro confederacy song Docreed2003 Jul 2023 #1
that's exactly how I have always interpreted it prodigitalson Jul 2023 #2
When you do it this artistically, these qualms don't really matter in my book Hugh_Lebowski Jul 2023 #3
You ain't wrong brotha Docreed2003 Jul 2023 #5
Robbie Robertson was Canadian and Levon Helm a very enlightened Southern man... hlthe2b Jul 2023 #16
nice post thanks, I agree...and that is way better than the JB versio, which I still love prodigitalson Jul 2023 #18
Oh I agree totally hlthe2b Docreed2003 Jul 2023 #19
"and the people were sangin'!" prodigitalson Jul 2023 #21
I watched The Last Waltz for the 5th time a few days ago. BigmanPigman Jul 2023 #4
I have never watched that prodigitalson Jul 2023 #6
This is from The last Waltz...they rock!!!!!! BigmanPigman Jul 2023 #9
I have seen this performance, though not the whole film prodigitalson Jul 2023 #13
Here's an answer of sorts about Helm's opinions Docreed2003 Jul 2023 #17
The songs with Van Morrison and the Staple Singers are the highlights but its all good Hugh_Lebowski Jul 2023 #20
Funny thing is... Docreed2003 Jul 2023 #8
that is really funny prodigitalson Jul 2023 #10
artists! !?!?!? might be a few quirks here and there stopdiggin Jul 2023 #12
No doubt artists are quirky Docreed2003 Jul 2023 #15
I always just took it as the historical perspective of the average southern soldier. Irish_Dem Jul 2023 #7
like a guy who lost a limb in Iraq war, but had no Haliburtan stock, right? prodigitalson Jul 2023 #11
Exactly. Irish_Dem Jul 2023 #14
well .. exceedingly hard to see Joan as pro-South stopdiggin Jul 2023 #22
yeah, this prodigitalson Jul 2023 #24
I always enjoyed the Watergate era parody, "The Night They Drove Old Dickie Down" dflprincess Jul 2023 #23
bwahahahaha prodigitalson Jul 2023 #25
I have a difficult time listening to that song, I have it on a Baez and a The Band CD's, spike jones Jul 2023 #26
CSA - chicken shit assholes prodigitalson Jul 2023 #27
It's Ok To Still Like It ProfessorGAC Jul 2023 #28
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Musicians»The Night they Drove Ol' ...»Reply #4