Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sknabt

(214 posts)
22. My empathy is limited concerning dairy farmers
Sun Dec 23, 2018, 06:12 PM
Dec 2018

I know a dairy farmer who recently retired as well. So I'm well versed on the issues. While I'm empathetic to anyone suffering economic hardship, my sympathy gets stretched to the limit in the case of dairy farmers.

As long as I can remember - over 20 years - my dairy farmer friend has struggled financially. He largely lived off of government handouts. He got land tax subsidies suburbanites like myself would envy. He got subsidies on insurance. He got subsidies on licensing farm vehicles. I'm sure I'm forgetting many others he bragged about. That's before the government milk subsidies.

My friend, a rabid Trump voter rarely seen without his MAGA hat on, lectures supply and demand like most conservatives. Well, dude, that's what kept your wages around the poverty level for decades (his wife's job kept the family afloat). Farmers are producing more milk than there's demand for torpedoing prices.

Then farmers generally are Trump voters. What does Trump do to help them? Well, he starts a trade war with China. China's response is to raise tariffs on milk powder and skimmed milk powder a big U.S. dairy export. That's approximately a $200,000,000 dairy market flushed down the toilet.

According to farmer Goodman Trump is giving some small additional subsidy relief to larger farms. No surprise. Look at Trump's tax scam marketed as a middle class tax cut but, in reality, is nothing but a corporate gravy train.

What's the expression Republicans always spew? Oh, "Elections have consequences." Yep. Be careful who you vote for!



Big corporate farming wins Bayard Dec 2018 #1
45 cows? How ironic. dameatball Dec 2018 #6
How ignorant. Yes, 45 cows. Husband and wife, maybe some kids and farmhands. Yes, small family farm. DRoseDARs Dec 2018 #9
You DO know that Demobrat Dec 2018 #13
If that was what was meant then my bad, but this wouldn't be the first time I've seen people knock DRoseDARs Dec 2018 #15
Yes, the # 45 was indeed an indirect slam at Trump It was not intended to be judgemental. dameatball Dec 2018 #17
*hug* DRoseDARs Dec 2018 #23
Back at ya.....:) Sorry for the misunderstanding. dameatball Dec 2018 #25
your comment is all I see that is ignorant Larrybanal Dec 2018 #21
It's okay. Easy to misinterpret sometimes. dameatball Dec 2018 #28
+1 Crutchez_CuiBono Dec 2018 #51
My mom named all of our cows too Rorey Dec 2018 #29
I used to have a pet Brahma steer Bayard Dec 2018 #45
the 'business man' hurts businesses all over demigoddess Dec 2018 #2
My heart goes out to this farmer. The greed of the corporate level farming killed his farm. That $5 iluvtennis Dec 2018 #3
Wonewoc is right next door. LakeArenal Dec 2018 #4
The first question I would ask DENVERPOPS Dec 2018 #5
no, you don't know the answer... handmade34 Dec 2018 #10
"75 percent of rural voters in the Farm Belt cast their ballots for Trump" SunSeeker Dec 2018 #16
Some misconceptions about farmers... Dickster Dec 2018 #39
What an odd assumption, that organic farmers vote republican. uppityperson Dec 2018 #48
First of all, I feel badly for dairy farmers. 3Hotdogs Dec 2018 #7
I would say "nice story", but it isn't really nice, it's just very well done.... George II Dec 2018 #8
Big factory farms that are abusive to animals Liberty Belle Dec 2018 #11
Many people don't realize how abusive the dairy business is. StarryNite Dec 2018 #19
Yup mucifer Dec 2018 #37
Has it always been so bad? Liberty Belle Dec 2018 #49
Vegan "milk" sales are up, Mendocino Dec 2018 #12
I hadn't thought of that customerserviceguy Dec 2018 #40
The league of national milk producers Corvo Bianco Dec 2018 #52
Economies of scale spelled the end of family dairies long ago. SunSeeker Dec 2018 #14
"What's the Matter With Kansas?" trev Dec 2018 #18
What's your point? Lemme guess... SunSeeker Dec 2018 #27
Relevant post - and I too am sadddened by the loss of small farms. A continuatiion of the c-rational Dec 2018 #20
My empathy is limited concerning dairy farmers sknabt Dec 2018 #22
Please let me be the first to call you on the carpet for what I think is PatrickforO Dec 2018 #31
Jim ain't reading our posts. 3Hotdogs Dec 2018 #44
totally relevant post Horse with no Name Dec 2018 #32
We had our dairy in the 70's and 80's Horse with no Name Dec 2018 #24
And organic farming??? We knew what was fed to the cows.... a kennedy Dec 2018 #26
What was? Eko Dec 2018 #55
If you are Jim Goodman, I'm so very sorry for the loss of your dairy farm. PatrickforO Dec 2018 #30
Seen all over the world Miigwech Dec 2018 #33
The vast majority of large farms are family owned Kaleva Dec 2018 #43
To make the Goodman Wellstone ruled Dec 2018 #34
Dairy Farmins seems to be growing in NM JDC Dec 2018 #35
I grew up working on neighboring dairy farms as a kid. berni_mccoy Dec 2018 #36
A way of life... I grew up on my uncle's dairy farms as a child. defacto7 Dec 2018 #38
Large family farms produce about 66% of dairy products. Small family farms can't compete. Kaleva Dec 2018 #41
"Fair prices" is really a false term in capitalism. MadDAsHell Dec 2018 #42
As Walmart took out main Street big farms take out small farms dembotoz Dec 2018 #46
Really appreciate this perspective, which we don't often get. calimary Dec 2018 #47
So what organic milk should I buy - I believe in voting with my $$$. Im in Madison now and had no Kashkakat v.2.0 Dec 2018 #50
This website is a great source. MoonchildCA Dec 2018 #54
A shame. Spent lot of wonderful times on grandparents small dairy farm in 1950/60s, outhouse and all Hoyt Dec 2018 #53
Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Wisconsin»Dairy farming is dying. A...»Reply #22