Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

UrbScotty

(23,987 posts)
18. If you're in a low tax bracket, the only reason I can think of to open a traditional IRA
Wed Feb 10, 2021, 11:58 PM
Feb 2021

(i.e. not Roth) is if you want to roll over your 401(k) or other retirement plan assets from a previous job (which is allowed). That could give you more control over your investments than a workplace retirement plan provides (i.e. allowing you to invest in individual stocks, or in funds that the other plan doesn't offer).

Even then, there can be downsides to that kind of rollover. Many 401(k)/403/457 plans allow you to take money out of your plan (as taxable income) after you've left that employer - even if you're not 59 1/2 yet. If you rolled that over into an IRA, you'd have to wait until you're 59 1/2 or pay a penalty on top of whatever other tax.

I think a traditional IRA makes the most sense if you're in a higher tax bracket and your employer does not offer you a retirement plan. In that case, you can deduct your contributions now, with a view toward taking the money out when you're retired (and presumably in a lower tax bracket). (If your employer did offer a retirement plan, then it's probably better to just contribute to that, given the phase-out rule for IRA deductions and the higher contribution limits for employer plans versus IRAs.)

Question about IRA's: [View all] ret5hd Feb 2021 OP
Tax rates are based on income. After you retire you will mobeau69 Feb 2021 #1
But I am already in the lowest bracket... ret5hd Feb 2021 #2
With your assumptions, yes. There's not really any benefit to an IRA as far as I know. Salviati Feb 2021 #3
"a Roth IRA might have more advantages. You'd pay taxes on the $1000 now," progree Feb 2021 #7
The money you put into a Roth IRA is post tax money. Salviati Feb 2021 #8
I know. So? progree Feb 2021 #9
Not necessarily. You could withdraw it without paying any tax at all. mobeau69 Feb 2021 #5
Hides your capital gains zipplewrath Feb 2021 #4
Having some knowledge on this gibraltar72 Feb 2021 #6
Invest in a Roth while tax rates are low nt doc03 Feb 2021 #10
Or high, or in between. When one contributes to a Roth (compared to doing nothing), one is in progree Feb 2021 #12
I am 72 and have no idea where to park my RMDs from my traditional IRA. The banks and doc03 Feb 2021 #13
I'm 69, so am also not looking at a very long time frame for compounding my money! progree Feb 2021 #15
I am in 42% equites and 58% fixed income in my IRAs and Roth. I started withdrawing from my IRAs at doc03 Feb 2021 #17
The tax-deferral advantage of traditional IRAs progree Feb 2021 #11
Thank you! Exactly the kind of info l thought may be out there. ret5hd Feb 2021 #14
If you put that $1,000 in a Roth instead: progree Feb 2021 #16
If you're in a low tax bracket, the only reason I can think of to open a traditional IRA UrbScotty Feb 2021 #18
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Personal Finance and Investing»Question about IRA's»Reply #18