Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)
29. I'm not ignoring facts.
Sat Dec 1, 2012, 11:32 PM
Dec 2012

What studies have you shown which prove causality between homework performance?

"It teaches responsibility" For some it does. Obviously it isn't a fantastic motivator because plenty of students don't do it. And there are probably plenty of other ways to teach responsibility. And what does responsibility have to do with performance and test scores?

"It makes neural connections" Life makes neural connections. And if homework does make neural connections, it doesn't make connections that any study ever has been able to show causation to performance and test scores.

"it helps you to get further during CLASS time" Where is the study that shows that is true. I don't believe there is one and you have linked to a study that shows that. You have linked to a website that makes that claim, but that isn't a double-blind study.

Many parents and teachers seeing a value in it does not mean that it really makes a difference. If we are going to start basing our educational decisions on best practices and what is shown to actually work, there has been no study in the past two centuries that shows a benefit to homework beyond simple correlation that can be explain with other variables.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

link to Psychology Today original article Viva_La_Revolution Nov 2012 #1
When Kohn tweeted a link to his new blog post Goblinmonger Nov 2012 #2
that's cool, I hope he's getting paid Viva_La_Revolution Nov 2012 #7
always thought that any good that it did was outweighed by an order of mopinko Nov 2012 #3
I absolutely agree proud2BlibKansan Nov 2012 #13
bulls**t DetlefK Nov 2012 #4
Why does that neural network Goblinmonger Nov 2012 #5
positive and negative feedback DetlefK Nov 2012 #12
10000000000% correct! LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #6
So why is there NO study Goblinmonger Nov 2012 #9
Oh, you mean like this? LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #19
You did read this, right? Goblinmonger Nov 2012 #22
Quotes you chose to ignore when you posted your incomplete sentence . . . . LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #23
Of course homework improves grades Goblinmonger Nov 2012 #24
Well, several of us here have already shown the value of homework. LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #25
I'm not ignoring facts. Goblinmonger Dec 2012 #29
is family time less important than rote learning? Viva_La_Revolution Nov 2012 #8
Homework should not be rote learning. LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #20
I will second that. Ka hrnt Nov 2012 #10
+1000 nt LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #27
I have just one name for you: MALCOLM GLADWELL savebigbird Dec 2012 #28
malcolm gladwell = paid propagandist HiPointDem Dec 2012 #30
The relevancy of your post confuses me. savebigbird Dec 2012 #31
gladwell is a paid liar, so why would anyone quote him on anything? yes, learning requires HiPointDem Dec 2012 #32
The quote was not being used as an exact prescription for expertness. savebigbird Dec 2012 #34
There was a big Canadian meta-study that debunked that. knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #11
Kohn admits that correlation exists. Goblinmonger Nov 2012 #15
Homework is practice, and kids need practice, though. knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #17
Exactly right! nt LeftyLucy22 Nov 2012 #21
Right. A student who's engaged and interested is more likely to do his homework. pnwmom Nov 2012 #26
there's a study, period, to prove anything. HiPointDem Dec 2012 #33
Hence my last sentence. knitter4democracy Dec 2012 #35
i meant not just in education -- in every field. HiPointDem Dec 2012 #36
I hate homework. proud2BlibKansan Nov 2012 #14
It does in music and foreign language. knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #18
Absolutely right. I have not assigned any homework in 15 years. mbperrin Dec 2012 #37
I never give homework. Starry Messenger Nov 2012 #16
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Education»"Homework: New Resea...»Reply #29