Calling Israel an apartheid state is an insult to black South Africans

[shira]

68. WTF? The Methodist Church quoted from global BDS, ElectronicIntifada....

Last edited Sat May 14, 2016, 09:07 PM - Edit history (5)

....the type of BDS you say you're against. That's not just anti-settlements and fake "apartheid" but also against normalization b/w Israelis & Palestinians, support for 1-state with a vulnerable Jewish minority after full "right" of return. The same BDS that has proven over and over again to be a Jew hating, pro-Hamas movement.

Who are you trying to fool?

And there's not a single post explaining why the Apartheid analogy isn't valid...

It doesn't fit the description of Apartheid, that's why. Go with the detailed definition of Apartheid, not what BDS uses as a definition but the real one. Go on, provide us with the definition here if words have meaning to you. You'll find Israel doesn't fit the description so I doubt you'll want to provide a clear definition of apartheid that we can then use to judge all other nations, including all other democracies.

WRT Hillary, it's the same with Bernie and Obama. All oppose BDS on the grounds it's a hate movement.

Why pretend Hillary is different?

Here's the catch with Hillary and Zionists who you believe support settlements. We all here support 2 states which means the end of settlements. That goes for Hillary as well. When you say she's pro-settlements yet for 2 states, you don't know what you're blabbering on about. There can't be 2 states w/o an end to settlements.

Personally, I don't see why you are against settlements being that you, like BDS, favor 1-state after full-right-of-return. So what difference do the settlements make if that region - from Gaza to the W.Bank - is all one state? It makes no sense you're against settlements as that plays right into your plans.