Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

moniss

(6,116 posts)
30. Your assumption
Sun Aug 25, 2024, 03:36 PM
Aug 2024

that Gaza = Israel is in conflict with international law. The Philadelphi Corridor is Egyptian territory not Israeli. Israel can do what it wants within it's own borders. It has no legal claim to place troops just willy-nilly whenever and wherever it wants on the territory of other people. Yes I know they do it and get away with it because they have the US behind them but it doesn't mean it's legal under international law.

I have listened for decades and decades about terrorism and Israel defending itself but most Western media doesn't carry a whisper about Israeli terrorism in other countries over the decades. Terrorism is horrible. Everybody's terrorism. Violation of international law and treaties is horrible no matter who the violator or why. Some countries comply with obligations to international law, UN Resolutions etc. while others like Iran and Israel often do not. Iran worse than most.

Anybody can think what they want about the claim by the Israeli government that everyone is treated equally and that any abuses of people are rare and always dealt with but all of the human rights organizations in Israel and outside of Israel disagree and have the fact-finding to back it up. What they don't have is the political ability to improve the situation currently. We also have eyes to see what goes on in the West Bank with illegal squatters attacking Palestinian villagers while the IDF stands and watches. Israel is hardly "protecting their borders" with such conduct. Nor are they "protecting their borders" when they go thousands of miles away to assassinate the citizens of other countries regardless of whether they are in political or military opposition to you. Because if someone feels it is legitimate to do so then they have not one leg to stand on to complain when it is visited upon them in return.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

sounds suspiciously like a land grab nt msongs Aug 2024 #1
When conjecture turned speculation turned innuendo gets a platform to feign legitimacy, Beastly Boy Aug 2024 #2
possible tru in this case. the land grab on the west bank is not speculation however nt msongs Aug 2024 #3
It is not. But thankfully, the conversation has not gotten to the insanity Beastly Boy Aug 2024 #4
Control of water moniss Aug 2024 #7
Control of water is regulated by international treaties Beastly Boy Aug 2024 #9
The access issue has been extensively discussed moniss Aug 2024 #13
Possibly accurate, but this is not the issue raised in the OP. Beastly Boy Aug 2024 #25
SOS Blinken debunked the claim. lapucelle Aug 2024 #5
One more lie to the pile for Netanyahu would be no surprise moniss Aug 2024 #6
Your report is dated moniss Aug 2024 #8
Oh dear. Where to begin... lapucelle Aug 2024 #10
They reported what Netanyahu's office moniss Aug 2024 #14
Yes, but the fact remains that the source YOU chose to cite is a right wing, low credibility, state propaganda lapucelle Aug 2024 #19
Perhaps you are mixing things moniss Aug 2024 #20
It's not unusual that fanciful theories are backed up by nothing other than the random musings of fanciful theorists lapucelle Aug 2024 #21
Well there you go again failing to answer the substance of the response that was moniss Aug 2024 #22
Now that the fanciful theory that Israel is secretly planning to build a canal through Gaza lapucelle Aug 2024 #23
Hamas says what? Your right wing, low credibility, state media propaganda *news source* lapucelle Aug 2024 #11
Apparently you don't know think there is an ability to moniss Aug 2024 #15
Once again your report you reference is behind the times moniss Aug 2024 #16
Your right wing, low credibility, state propaganda source you reference does not support your fanciful theory lapucelle Aug 2024 #17
Once again moniss Aug 2024 #18
And finally, your right wing, low credibility, state propaganda link lapucelle Aug 2024 #12
Why shouldn't Israel control it's borders? Mosby Aug 2024 #24
Your assumption moniss Aug 2024 #30
The philadelphi corridor is the border. Mosby Aug 2024 #32
The Corridor is a strip of land on the Egyptian side of the Egypt/Gaza moniss Aug 2024 #33
This message was self-deleted by its author SheltieLover Aug 2024 #26
Tough to see how the geography works for this pipe dream. CincyDem Aug 2024 #27
I agree with you that moniss Aug 2024 #28
I suspect the width and location of the path might imply the end depth of the path. CincyDem Aug 2024 #29
Last estimated cost I saw was moniss Aug 2024 #31
US taxpayers' money at work over the moon (from South Lebanon, photograph by Yusuf Bazzi). walznotwalls Sep 2024 #34
let me try again (broken link) walznotwalls Sep 2024 #35
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»Why is Israel demanding c...»Reply #30